APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
Asia-Pacific Management Accounting Association
APMAA News No.29, September 15, 2018
1. Messages from the APMAA Board Chair
2. Information from the 2018 Tokyo Conference Organizer
2.1 Message from the APMAA 2018 Conference Chair
2.2 Outline of the APMAA 2018 Conference
2.3 Special Session Ⅱ “Management Accounting Research and Education in Asia Top
Accounting Schools”
3. Guidelines for Presenters, Moderators and Discussants
4. Guidelines for Authors of APMAA Parallel Session Manuscripts
5. Screening Processes of Manuscripts Submitted to Parallel Sessions
6. Essays
APMAA 2018 in Tokyo
Theme: The Forefront of Management Accounting: Research and Practices
October 29th (Monday) – November 1st (Thursday),
Venue: The Waseda Campus of Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan
Organized by APMAA and Waseda University
http://s-ueno.sakura.ne.jp/APMAA_2018_Tokyo/
1
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
1 Messages from the APMAA Board Chair and APMAA 2018 President
The 2018 Conference of the Asia-Pacific Management Accounting Association (APMAA 2018 in
Tokyo) is about six weeks away. Preparation for the conference is progressing very well.
The mission of the APMAA annual conference is to provide researchers an easy-to-access
international platform for presenting research results. This year, our annual conference attracted
131 research papers. It is my pleasure to report that we received many quality papers this year.
Thank you very much for your warm support.
We spent a large amount of time, say, more than two months, to screen submitted manuscripts.
The main role of screening the manuscripts is to find writings that are appropriate for conference
presentation. In the process, we focus mainly on whether the manuscript satisfies standards of
format, readability and robustness. As an honest gatekeeper of conference papers, we did our best
to read manuscripts with care and sympathy. We are not just a filter, but rather, we are also
developers. We played “catch ball” with many authors and communicated what APMAA expects
in the parallel session papers to them.
To improve future conferences, we have been developing guidelines for authors and reviewers.
This issue of the APMAA NEWS includes a rough draft of these guidelines. I believe the
guidelines will help prospective authors to write their conference papers. In addition, this issue
includes the “Guidelines for Moderators, Discussants and Presenters.” Discussants, with a
generous spirit, are expected to provide authors constructive suggestions to improve their papers. I
believe all APMAA 2018 moderators, discussants and presenters will gain a lot of hints by
carefully reading the guidelines.
This year at APMAA 2018 we will hold a special forum, tentatively entitled “Management
Accounting Research and Education in Asia Top Accounting Schools,”. At the session we will
present the current status and future developments in research and doctoral education at leading
universities in Asia,
The doctoral seminar this year is “How to go through an Accounting Doctoral Program: Tips from
Supervisors.” Seminar panelists are incumbent supervisors who are tackling issues and problems
that doctoral students face.
During the conference this year, we will hold three special purpose meetings: the executive
meeting, the conference organizers’ meeting and the conference paper reviewers’ meeting.
Deliberations at these meetings will provide some solutions to APMAA for tackling with her
sustainable growth. Below are future conference venues that we have already officially approved.
All the organizers are working energetically to attract more paper submissions, participants and
donations. I wish you to become a conference organizer in the near future.
2019 Doha (Qatar University, Qatar)
2020 Kuala Lumpur (Universiti Teknologi MARA, Malaysia)
2021 Jakarta (Trisakti University, Indonesia)
The APMAA 2018 Homepage http://s-ueno.sakura.ne.jp/APMAA_2018_Tokyo/ provides a
tentative schedule and other current information about APMAA 2018. All researchers and
2
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
practitioners in the area of accounting and management are encouraged to attend the conference
and disseminate their knowledge. Please join the APMAA community and enjoy this year’s
conference in Tokyo. I look forward to seeing you soon.
Susumu Ueno
Chair of the APMAA Board of Directors
September 15, 2018
2 Information from the 2018 Tokyo Conference Organizer
(http://s-ueno.sakura.ne.jp/APMAA_2018_Tokyo/)
2.1 Message from the APMAA 2018 Conference Chair
On behalf of the committee of the APMAA2018 conference, I would like to report that the
preparation for hosting the annual conference is well underway without problems thanks to the
help of the board members. I am grateful that we have received 131 papers so far: 114 for the
Parallel Sessions, 4 for the Special Sessions and 13 for the Doctoral Colloquium. It is worth
noting that about half of the submitted papers are from other than the Asian region. I am very
glad to hear from Prof. Ueno, Chair of the board, that the quality of the papers has gotten
higher.
Nowadays, as a major role of management accounting, the ability to manage organizational
value is expected to be strengthened. I believe that management accounting is essential for
developing sound corporate strategies and business strategies. Generally, without a sound
financial strategy, business strategies are not well implemented. In short, business strategy and
financial strategy are tightly interlinked. The Chief Financial Officer (CFO) fulfills the role of
merging corporate strategy and financial strategy. In other words, the CFO is expected to be a
bridge between the strategic and business focus of the business division and the financial
requirements of corporations and investors. It goes without saying that the CEO is also
responsible for the company's ordinary financial decisions and financial reporting. I conclude
that the CFO is expected to take the lead in developing a value-creating corporate strategy for
an organization while working with the CEO and the heads of the business units to build a
value-management capability throughout the organization.
Observing the recent fraud or injustices in so-called prestigious companies, I realize that the
roles of a controller and an internal auditor need to be reshaped. We should not fault them for
thinking foremost about financial reporting and regulatory compliance. These are their
traditional jobs, but their modern functions need to tie traditional activities more closely to the
organization’s strategic objectives and risks.
That is why the committee set up the CFO / controller session on the second day of the
conference. It is very fortunate that we have prominent speakers as top professionals in these
fields mentioned above. You will learn about these topics at the session.
3
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
Let us proceed together on the road to make APMAA a principal world-wide organization in
management accounting. Please join us by attending the annual conference of APMAA 2018
and making sure that it is not just a dream. September 30 is the final day for the early
registration. The participation procedure can be done by accessing the following URL:
http://s-ueno.sakura.ne.jp/APMAA_2018_Tokyo/registration.htm.
We look forward to meeting with you at Waseda University in Tokyo.
Masao Tsuji
Chair of the APMAA2018 Conference
2.2 Outline of the APMAA 2018 Conference (Tentative: Edited on September 13 by Ueno)
Presentations:
CP=Competitive Paper Sessions (15 min. presentation, 10 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
DP=Development Paper Sessions (15 min. presentation, 10 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Special Sessions (Day 1= 3 panelists; Day 2= 4 papers)
DC=Doctoral Colloquium (20 min. presentation, 15 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Room 1
Room 2
Room 3
Room 4
Room 5
9.20-11.00
9.30-10.50
9.30-10.50
9.30-10.50
Board
Meeting
DC1 2papers
DC2 2papers
DC3 2papers
13.30-15.30
13.30-15.30
October 29
09.20-11.00
11.20-12.00
Opening /
Picture
taking
12.00-13.30
Lunch
13.30-15.00
*Special
Session Ⅰ
(Asia Top
Schools)
CP1 E1
3papers
CP1 G1
3papers
DC1 3papers
DC2 3papers
16.0017.00
15.30-17.00
15.30-17.00
15.30-17.00
15.30-17.00
CP1 E2
3papers
CP1 G2
3papers
CP1 G3
3papers
CP1 G4
3papers
15.30-17.00
Doctoral
Seminar
4
Room 6
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
17.40-20.00
Welcome Reception at Rihga Royal Hotel
October 30
09.00-10.00
10.20-11.50
CP2 G1 2
papers
CP2 G2
CP2 E1
CP2 E2
3 papers
2 papers
3 papers
CP2 G3
2papers
CP2 G4
2papers
CP2 G5
*Special
Session
Ⅱ(Evolution)
CP2 G6
papers
CP2 G7
11.50-12.50
Lunch
12.50-17.00
CFO Symposium at Ibuka Hall
17.40-20.00
Conference Dinner at Rihga Royal Hotel
papers
3papers
October 31
09.00-10.30
CP3 G1
3 papers
10.50-12.20
CP3 E1
3 papers
12.20-13.50
Lunch
13.50-15.20
CP3 E3
3 papers
15.40-17.10
CP3 E5
3 papers
17.40-20.00
CP3 G2 3
papers
CP 3G4
3papers
CP3 G4
3papers
DP1
CP3 E2
3papers
CP3 G5
3papers
CP3 G6
3papers
CP3 G7
3papers
3papers
GP3 G8
3papers
12.30-13.30
Executive
Meeting
CP3 E4
3papers
CP3 G9
3papers
CP3 G10
3papers
CP3 G11
3papers
2019, 2020
& 2021
organizers’
meeting
CP3 E6
CP3 G12
3papers
CP3 G13
3papers
DP2
2019, 2020
& 2021
reviewers’
meeting
3 papers
4papers
Farewell Party at Rihga Royal Hotel
November 1
09.00-17.30
Company Visits
*Special Session Ⅰ (13.30-15.00, Oct.29): Prof. Jimmy Tsay moderates the forum, tentatively entitled
“Management Accounting Research and Education in Asia Top Accounting Schools” ((Panelists: Prof.
Shuen-Zen Liu, National Taiwan University; Prof. Iny Hwang, Soul National University; Prof. Yasheng
Chen, Xiamen University; Commentator: Prof. Michael Tse, Chairman of Institute of Certified
Management Accountant, Australia).
5
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
*Special Session Ⅱ (10.20-11.50, Oct. 30): This session is a structured session focusing on the
management accounting evolution. Interesting findings from the management accounting evolution
research projects conducted in four different countries – China, Malaysia, Thailand and Vietnam will be
presented. Presenters are Prof. Kanibhatti Nitirojntanad, Prof. Kanitsorn Terdpaopong (Thailand), Prof.
Normah Omar (Malaysia), Prof. Robert C. Rickards and Prof. Rolf Ritsert (Germany).
Events on Day One (International Conference Center)
9.20-11.00
9.30-10.50
Board of Directors Meeting
Doctoral Colloquium (20 min. presentation, 15 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
11.20-12.00
13.30-17.00
Opening/Picture taking
Doctoral Colloquium (20 min. presentation, 15 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
13.30-15.00
13.30-15.00
Parallel Session (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Parallel Session (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Special Session Ⅰ
Break
Parallel Session (30 min: presentation, discussion, Q&A)
Welcome Reception at Rihga Royal Hotel
15.00-15.30
15.30-17.10
17.40-20.00
Events on Day Two (International Conference Center)
09.00-10.00
10.00-10.20
10.20-11.50
11.40-12.50
12.50-17.00
13.00-14.00
14.00-15.10
15.10-15.30
15.30-17.00
17.40-20.00
Parallel Session (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Morning Break
Parallel Sessions (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Special SessionⅡ
Lunch for All (Lunch box or buffet style)
APMAA 2018 CFO /Controller Symposium at Ibuka Masaru Memorial Hall in the
International Conference Center of Waseda U.
Plenary (CFO) Session (Presentation plus Q&A)
Controller Panel Session (sponsored by The Institute of Internal Auditors Japan)
Afternoon Break
CEO/CFO Panel Session
Welcome Reception at Rihga Royal Hotel
Events on Day Three (Parallel Sessions at 6 rooms of the 11th Building; Total 72 papers)
9.00-10.30
10.30-10.50
10.50-12.20
12.20-13.50
13.50-15.20
15.20-15.40
15.40-17.10
17.30-20.00
Parallel Sessions (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Development Paper Sessions (15 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion)
Morning Break
Parallel Sessions (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Lunch for All (Lunch box or buffet style): Executive Meeting
Parallel Sessions (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Annual Conference Organizers Meeting
Afternoon Break
Parallel Sessions (20 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A)
Development Paper Sessions (15 min. presentation, 5 min. discussion)
Conference Paper Reviewers Meeting
Farewell Meeting at Rihga Royal Hotel
Events on Day Four
One-day tour to factories for international participants
6
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
2.3 Special Session Ⅰ : “Management Accounting Research and Education in Asia Top
Accounting Schools”
Management Accounting Research and Education in Asia Top Accounting
Schools
Tsay, Yang-Tzong (Jimmy), (Professor Emeritus, National Taiwan
University, Taiwan; APMAA Deputy Chair of the Board of Directors and
Auditor)
The APMAA 2018 Annual Conference is not far away. This year we received many quality
papers and have a good number of participants from domestic and foreign countries to join the
conference. We think this is a greater opportunity than ever before for educators and scholars in
the region to share with each other not only their own but also their institutions’ experience in
teaching and doing research in management accounting, with a hope of promoting better
understanding of, and quick learning, from each other.
The Conference Organizing Committee will hold a special forum entitled “Management
Accounting Research and Education in Asia Top Accounting Schools”, in which 3 prominent
professors are invited to serve as panelists in the Forum sharing with the audience the current
status and future developments in management accounting education and research in their
respective university. Another professor with global perspectives is invited to help us
summarize and comment on the above three presentations in this Forum. The panel discussions
will be very interesting and valuable.
This will be the first forum of its kind in APMAA’s history. Definitely, we know that there are
now many more top Accounting Schools in Asia. Due to time constraints we couldn’t invite
more professors and top accounting schools to make presentations in the Forum. However, we
encourage you to participate in the discussions. We hope that we can continue forums of this
kind in the future so that more educators and researchers can exchange ideas for future growth.
The Forum is scheduled on October 29, 13:30-15:00. Each presenter and the commentator will
have 15-20 minutes to make his presentation or comments. Before we conclude the forum, we
will reserve some time for interactions between the panelists and the audience.
Moderator
TSAY, Jimmy, Professor Emeritus, National Taiwan University
Panelists
CHEN, Yasheng, Professor, Xiamen University
HWANG, Iny, Professor, Seoul National University
LIU, Shuen-Zen, Professor and Chairman, National Taiwan University
Commentator
TSE, Michael, Chairman, Institute of Certified Management Accountants, Australia
7
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
3 Guidelines for Presenters, Moderators and Discussants
There are several different types of APMAA research session. Here, we provide some guidelines
for presenters, moderators and discussants who play the core roles in parallel sessions. Following
these guidelines will lead your session to be a beneficial one for both the authors and audience.
Note that paying careful attention to time allocation is very important to all.
Guidelines for Presenters, Moderators and Discussants (Competitive Paper Sessions)
The presentations are organized into topic areas. All presentation session rooms have a PC,
screens and data projectors. Overhead projectors for transparencies are not provided in the rooms.
Papers in the session are presented sequentially in 30-minute presentation blocks (15 min.
presentation, 10 min. discussion, 5 min. Q&A). Each presenter's final written paper is available in
the conference USB proceedings.
Each session is either 90 min. (3 presenters 1 moderator and 3 discussants), or 60
min. (2 presenters 1 moderator and 2 discussants).
Each presenter is allocated 15 min. for presentation. (About 10-15 slides).
The moderator coordinates the session. If a discussant does not show up, the
moderator must discuss papers instead. Therefore, he/she should prepare discussion
slides for all three papers.
Each discussant is allocated 10 min.for discussion. (About 7-10 slides).
1 PRESENTER GUIDELINES
During your 15-minute paper presentation, be sure to state the structure and main points of your
argument explicitly and clearly at the outset and again in the summary. Your slides should contain
only what is necessary to help the audience follow the key points of the paper.
•
•
•
Spend most of the time on results, discussion, and conclusions, and
Concisely describe your method.
Go very lightly on the literature,
Do not overwhelm people with a lot of tables that take time to interpret. Be a guide to the
audience rather than piling on facts. Practice your presentation to get it down to the specified time.
Respond to the moderator when your time is at an end.
Rehearse your presentation out loud several times, if possible in front of a listener who can give
you feedback on both form and content. Make sure your talk fits into the allotted 15 minutes of
your presentation. The session moderator in the room will have to cut your talk short, should it run
over, to ensure all presenters in the session are allotted their full presentation time.
Arrive early and make yourself known to your discussant and session moderator.
8
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
2 MODERATOR GUIDELINES
Session moderators introduce the speakers, keep time for the presentations, and facilitate the
discussion. Make sure there is time for reasonable presentation and discussion and to finish on
time. Bring along time cards large enough that the presenter can see. Have a 5-minute card and
a time-is-up card. Even if it is a bit uncomfortable be firm with presenters who continue past the
allowed time.
Begin on time. Start with a welcome message to the audiences, including a clear statement of the
session title. Describe the process followed in the session. Tell people how many papers will be
presented, how much time each presentation will be and also, at what point questions will be
possible. Keep your comments to a minimum other than introducing presenters.
You should go last if you are presenting your own paper during the session you are moderating,
even if you need to change the order from the program. If a discussant does not show up, the
moderator must discuss papers instead. Therefore, you should prepare discussion slides for all
three papers.
3 DISCUSSANT GUIDELINES
If you are well-prepared, it will greatly enhance the paper session, so please spend the time needed
for careful analysis. Please prepare PPT slides for your comments.
Mention both the strengths of a paper and areas for improvement. It is difficult to make points that
are both useful for the authors as well as being interesting to the audience. Avoid “insider”
discussions that probe small details of a paper. These are best given to the author in written notes
or outside discussion over tea (coffee, if you must☺). You have 10 minutes for discussion. Finish
on time!
4 Guidelines for Authors of APMAA Parallel Session Manuscripts
This section provides guidance for authors who submit their manuscripts to APMAA Parallel
Sessions.
APMAA selects conference papers based on their relevance, clarity, topicality, the extent to which
they advance knowledge and their contribution to inspiring further development and research.
Please maximize clarity of your manuscript. We strongly advise you to study layouts, formats,
writing styles of robust and rigorous papers in international scholarly journals. To avoid
unnecessary errors, please use the 'spell-check' and 'grammar-check' functions of your word
processor. The on-line service called Grammerly (https://www.grammarly.com/1) can also be
useful. If your native language is not English, or you have not received a doctoral degree from an
Anglo-American institution, think of using professional editing services provided by good native
English speakers.
This guideline includes self-review guidelines; standards for theoretical contributions, research
critiques and conference papers; and a submission checklist.
9
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
A material for the reviewers’ meeting on October 31, 2018
(tentative) Guidelines for authors of APMAA parallel session manuscripts
I Self-review guidelines
This document is an excerpt from
https://www.elsevier.com/__data/promis_misc/edurevReviewPaperWriting.pdf (Elsevier). It is
intended to make prospective authors familiar with APMAA’s basic principles and philosophy
regarding to parallel session manuscripts.
Please review to what degree your manuscript satisfies each of items a.-j. and polish your draft
paper.
a) Overall Quality & Scientific Originality (including quality of literature used)
Reviews take into account the quality of the literature and its impact on findings. Authors should
attempt to review all relevant literature on a topic, including cross-disciplinary work. A consistent
description of procedures is required to provide external quality assurance of inclusion and
exclusion criteria, keyword mapping (minimizing data entry errors) and data-extraction codes.
New and accessible syntheses of evidence or scopes are produced and of valuable contribution to
the field.
b) Theoretical Framework; Conceptual Rationale; Pragmatic Grounding
Describe the broad aims of the study: why is the study done, why at this time, with this sample
and in this context, the study’s foundation and when it was carried out. Relevant background
literature should be reviewed and synthesized. The study should be linked to theory and/or other
empirical studies.
c) Clear definition of the research questions/purpose
The purpose of any article should be to connect the particular problem to a larger context of
management and accounting. Such purpose should be clearly explained, and research questions
should be listed briefly and clearly. Describe the study research question, hypothesis and/or
possible predictions with a preferred accuracy since it directs the used research design. When
relevant, describe the topic focus of the study and curriculum area as well.
d) Research design, data sources, sampling and procedure
Describe and justify the used data-collection method, the selection of a study design, allocation
conditions, investigated concepts and variables, e.g. questionnaire survey, ethnography, quasiexperiment like the investigated concepts or variables, the sampling strategy (population, sample
selection and planned sample size), subject recruiting, the way of consent, etc.
e) Research Method & Instruments
Describe and justify the used methods to process and analyze the data. Depending on the type of
research, quantitative versus qualitative, different measurement instruments must be taken under
consideration e.g. data handling or statistical tests.
f) Quality & Appropriateness of the Analysis
10
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
A review should go beyond a description to include analysis and critiques of theories, methods
and conclusions represented in the literature. This analysis should also examine which
perspectives are included or excluded in a body of work and should be reflective in nature.
Discuss and substantiate the rigor, trustworthiness, reliability and validity of the analysis.
g) Clarity of the results and appropriateness of the interpretations
Study results will vary according to the selected study type. Nevertheless, some general aspects
are of particular relevance for secondary data analysis. Clear and detailed information with regard
to the context of the study and the subjects e.g.: age, sex, SES, country, culture. Reported results
should be consistent with the methods used. For quantitative research every significant value of all
variables should be mentioned and explained, for qualitative research a clear picture must explain
how the results (e.g. themes) are derived from the data collected.
h) Organization, Structure and brevity
The study needs to be reported according to the APA standards for publication. In practice,
deviation from the rigorous prescriptions can be allowed for different reasons e.g. the complexity
or diversity of the study or the artificial distinction between different topics like results and
discussion. The report has to be founded on a systematic ground, shaped in different common
divisions: introduction, methods, results, conclusion, colored by the aspects of the study. In short:
a clear comprehensive organization with brevity kept in mind, containing all the important aspects
of the study since secondary research, individual interpretation or replication can be made.
i) Significance for Theory, Practice and Policy; Relevance to the field of management and
accounting
The article should seek to inform and/or illuminate questions important to the fields of
management and accounting. Such questions may be broadly based but they should have
implications for management and accounting problems. The publication should be seen like an
important contribution to science and a relevant source of information to different researchers and
professionals dealing with management and accounting problems. Good quality research about the
effects of management and accounting interventions can help practice and policy-makers to make
decisions. Also, theory is a necessity to ground possible useful interventions or management and
accounting problem-solving issues.
j) Style and language
The article must be well written and conform to the style of the Publication Manual of the
American Psychological Association (APA) with a few exceptions. Authors should avoid the use
of unexplained jargon and should write in respectable and correct American or British English.
Referees are not expected to correct or copyedit one’s contribution. Language correction is not
part of the peer review process. Keep in mind that the research publications are mainly written for
people in management and accounting research, practice or policy. Explain, therefore, the
phenomena or results in understandable terms.
II Standards for theoretical contributions, research critiques and conference papers
Below are excerpts from
https://www.elsevier.com/__data/promis_misc/edurevReviewPaperWriting.pdf. Please read and
download the PDF by visiting the URL.
a) Overall Quality & Scientific Originality (including quality of literature used)
b) Theoretical Framework; Conceptual Rationale; Pragmatic Grounding
11
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
c) Clear definition of the research questions/purpose
d) Organization, Structure and brevity
e) Significance for Theory, Practice and Policy; Relevance to the field of education
f) Style and language
Ⅲ A submission checklist (excerpts from Elsevier URL, Below is an excerpt from
https://www.elsevier.com/wps/find/journaldescription.cws_home/30435?generatepdf=true).
You can use this list to carry out a final check of your submission before you send it to the
conference organizer for review.
One author has been designated as the corresponding author with contact details:
• E-mail address
All necessary files have been uploaded:
Manuscript:
• Include keywords
• All figures (include relevant captions)
• All tables (including titles, description, footnotes)
• Ensure all figure and table citations in the text match the files provided
• Indicate clearly if color should be used for any figures in print
Graphical Abstracts / Highlights files (where applicable)
Supplemental files (where applicable)
Further considerations
• Manuscript has been 'spell checked' and 'grammar checked'
• All references mentioned in the Reference List are cited in the text, and vice versa
• Permission has been obtained for use of copyrighted material from other sources (including
the Internet)
• A competing interests statement is provided, even if the authors have no competing interests
to declare
• Formatting requirement have been reviewed
Finally, you should be able to answer yes to the following questions:
• Have you told readers, at the outset, what they might gain by reading your paper?
• Have you made the aim of your work clear?
• Have you explained the significance of your contribution?
• Have you set your work in the appropriate context with sufficient background, and all relevant
references?
• Have you addressed the question of practicality and usefulness?
12
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
• Have you identified future developments that may result from your work?
• Have you structured your paper in a clear and logical fashion?
5 Screening Processes for Manuscripts Submitted to Parallel Sessions
This year, APMAA received more than 110 submissions to the parallel sessions. We would like to
share the review process of manuscripts submitted to parallel sessions with you.
The mission of the APMAA annual conference is to provide researchers an easy-to-access
international platform for presenting research results. The main role of screening (filtering)
manuscripts is to find writings that are adequate for conference presentation. In the review process,
we focus mainly on whether the manuscript satisfies standards of format, readability and
robustness. Please carefully check all the sections of a paper; i.e., the abstract, introduction,
literature review and hypotheses, methods, results, interpretations and discussions, conclusions,
and references before the paper submission.
As an honest gatekeeper of conference papers, we do our best to read manuscripts with care and
sympathy. We are not just a filter, as in the case of the AAA, but rather, we are also developers.
We provide a strong developmental component to our review process. Even if a manuscript is
weak, we usually approach it with a generous spirit and provide authors constructive suggestions
to improve their papers. This is easy to do when the manuscript is good but is still desirable even
when it is not. We strongly recommend you use editing services of professional native speakers if
English is not your official language.
People who attend the conference, or who consult our conference proceedings, must be confident
that the research results reported there are honest, accurate, and can be relied upon. It should be
noted that ensuring the integrity and the reliability of the research paper in the conference
proceedings is the author’s responsibility. (Written by Susumu Ueno, APMAA board chair, on
September 10, 2018)
Four Types of Decision Results: Accepted, Conditionally Accepted, Awaiting Decision, and
Reject
Accepted (or Accept):
The paper that satisfies our review standards receives an “Accept” notification. Please enhance
the quality of the manuscript and maximize clarity before submitting your proceedings paper.
Conditionally Accepted (or Conditional Accept):
An author, who received a “Conditionally Accepted” notification, is required to revise the
manuscript and resubmit a revised version. The manuscript is accepted if the revisions have
13
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
been made properly.
Evaluation is postponed (Awaiting Decision)
Authors, who received an “Evaluation is postponed (Awaiting Decision)” notification, are
requested to re-submit the revised manuscript.
Rejected
6 Essays
Grahita Chandrarin, Professor in Accounting, Director of Graduate Program,
University of Merdeka Malang, Indonesia (grahitac@unmer.ac.id).
My Participation at Asia-Pacific Management Accounting Association
(APMAA)
It has been 8 years since I attended my first APMAA annual conference
(Taiwan, 2010). I found that APMAA is a dynamic and fast-growing association in the AsiaPacific area. Since my first involvement, I have always actively introduced and promoted
APMAA in every conference and seminar I attend, to profession organization I join (Ikatan
Akuntan Indonesia or Institute of Indonesia Chartered Accountants), and to my colleagues and as
well as to my graduate students (especially Ph.D. students). Besides, I also encourage the
colleagues at University of Merdeka Malang to continuously and annually conduct scientific
events, such as conferences, seminars and guest lecturers and promote APMAA there. On 11 th12th August 2017 we invited Prof. Susumu Ueno and Prof. Normah Omar to become invited
speakers in an international conference on “Sustainable Goals 2030: Challenges and Solutions”,
conducted by Graduate Program of University of Merdeka Malang. And this year, we have
planned to conduct another one in September 2018 with the theme: “Contemporary Studies on
Sustainable Development”. That is how I introduce and promote APMAA from time to time and
I am glad to know that every year more people, both academicians and practioners, attend and
participate in APMAA annual conference. By the way, thank you to APMAA for the trust and for
electing me to be the 2016 President of APMAA. In 2015, working cooperatively with 5 other
universities in Indonesia (Trisakti University, Udayana University, Warmedewa University,
Mercu Buana University and Hasanuddin University) we successfully conducted The 2015
APMAA Annual Conference in Bali, Indonesia. It was definitely a great experience for all of us.
Finally, I do hope that APMAA will be more world widely known by both academicians and
practioners. See you all in Tokyo, Japan.
(August 19, 2018)
14
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
Jan Alpenberg, Econ Dr, Head of Department for Accounting, Logistics and
Legal Science, Senior lecturer in Accounting and Finance, School of Business
and Economics, Linnaeus University, Sweden (jan.alpenberg@lnu.se)
After the warmest summer in history, at least since they started to measure the temperatures in
Sweden, I am looking forward to the beginning of the fall and a busy semester with colder days.
This short essay is an attempt to give you some inspiration for making new friends at the
upcoming APMAA-conference.
This coming academic year is going to be an excellent example of how my international network
of friends from APMAA-conferences have grown into something more than just joint research
projects. It all started quite many years ago with Professor Scarbrough who was a visiting scholar
at Växjö Universit in the fall of 2000. After that I have had the privileges to host many prominent
professors that I have got to know through the APMAA-conferences. It was especially a great
honor to have both Professor Monden and Professor Ueno, visiting Linnaeus University for
research and teaching periods in 2010. This coming academic year, Professor Scarbrough from
Brock University in Canada is going to visit Linnaeus University and teach at our newly
developed Master of Management Accounting and Supply Chain Management program for a
couple of weeks. Later in the program, Professor Wnuk-Pel from University of Lodz in Poland is
arriving to teach for a couple of weeks. I am also very proud to have been able to develop stronger
institutional ties with both Professor Scarbrough and Professor Wnuk-Pel who both are affiliated
professors at Linnaeus University and our research group Centre for Management Accounting
Research. In the fall, both myself and Professor Karlsson from Linnaeus University are going to
University of Lodz for shorter teaching assignments and in the spring of next year, I am spending
some time at Brock University.
So, what I am trying to say? Through the illustrations above, I am encouraging all of you to start
developing stronger ties, even outside the joint research activities, with your APMAA-friends.
When you visit other universities and work with your friends from other parts of the world, you
expand your horizon and you learn new things from your friends and hopefully, they also learn
new things from you. Use the APMAA-conference to make new friends and don´t forget about
them when you come home to your home university. Your APMAA-friends are a great resource
not only for you but also for your students. Start tapping into this resource!
(August 2, 2018)
15
APMAA News No.29: September 15, 2018
Editorial Team for the APMAA News September 15, 2018 Issue (No.29)
Prof Dr Ueno, Susumu (ueno@konan-u.ac.jp)
Chair of the APMAA Board of Directors
Konan University, Japan
Prof Dr Scarbrough, Paul (pscarbrough@brocku.ca)
APMAA Senior Director
Brock University, Canada
We welcome your submissions of an article/an essay. It should be of less than one page in length.
We are interested in articles on a wide range of topics, including well-researched features on
current issues in accounting, management, professional ethics, education, etc. We also welcome
thoughtful or thought-provoking essays that explore issues of interest to APMAA members.
Submission Deadlines are as follows:
For January 1, 2019 edition (Vol.30): December 1, 2018
For May 1, 2019 edition (Vol.31): April 1, 2019
For September 15, 2019 edition (Vol.32): August 15, 2019
Asia-Pacific Management Accounting Association Homepages
http://www.apmaa.asia/
APMAA 2018 Homepage
http://s-ueno.sakura.ne.jp/APMAA_2018_Tokyo/
16