[go: up one dir, main page]

Academia.eduAcademia.edu
Colin Taylor Thesis proposal Proposed Title: Toward a Christian Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility Description of the Problem or Gap Addressed by the Project The sale of Infant Formula globally has been a contentious issue since the late 1970s. Makers of the products have been the subject of concerted action by non-governmental organizations for many years. At the forefront of the criticism, have been religious organizations such as the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility (ICCR), a corporate watchdog group affiliated with the National Council of Churches. Similarly, a significant sponsor behind a shareholders resolution against Bristol-Myers marketing practices of Infant Formula in Less Developed Countries (LDC’s) was a Roman Catholic order, the Sisters of the Precious Blood. The practice of Infant Formula marketing in the developing world, then, raises ethical issues and religious conflict. How is the concept of Corporate Social Responsibility, espoused by large corporations, a reality and to what extent is it simply a slogan? This thesis will seek to investigate the role Christian groups and the contribution a Christian Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility have to play in informing the debate and addressing the question of whether or not this role is a valid one. This thesis aims to analyze the current environment and the ethical issues raised by this controversy and move toward a Christian Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility, with particular relevance to church leadership in the Anglican Communion. Thesis Statement or Hypothesis: There is a need for a Christian Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility in response to the ethical issues raised by the controversy of the sale of Infant Formula globally. My aim is to prove the importance and relevance of Christian engagement in corporate social Responsibility (CSR) and how a positive engagement can be mutually beneficial. Project Purpose and Intended Audience: An analysis of the original Infant Formula controversy and the subsequent boycott of Nestle and other companies will be presented, raising the question of whether or not this was an effective Christian response. I will then seek to produce an analysis of the current environment and propose a practical framework for a Christian Understanding of Corporate Responsibility which provides suggestions for dealing in an ethical manner with large multinationals engaged in socially contentious areas. All multi nationals must deal with criticism about their ethical practices and how they operate in a complex and rapidly changing world. The question then arises of how Christian ethics might influence Business ethics and indeed should it? Can a Christian Understanding of Corporate Responsibility live in harmony with the commercial world? The intended audience fall into two groups. Firstly, Christians and theologians seeking positive engagement with Corporations on ethically contentious issues. Secondly, businesses presented with ethically contentious dilemmas and seeking A Christian Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility in order to engage effectively with religious and special interest groups. Learning Goals: 1. To analyze the controversy of the sale of Infant Formula in the developing World. 2. To understand and articulate how Christians can sensibly engage in discourse with business on areas of intense debate. 3. To explore the need for a Christian Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility and to suggest how that can be interpreted and enhanced by the Christian community. 4. To provide practical suggestions for the communication of a Corporate Social Responsibility between Christian groups and the Corporate World in a manner which is mutually advantageous. Sample Bibliography: Craig, Sharon. 2008. "Milking the innocent: marketing infant formula at the cost of young lives." Sojourners Magazine 37, no. 2: 8-9. Dobbing, John, ed. Infant Feeding: Anatomy of a Controversy 1973-1984. London: Spring-Verlag, 1988. Early, Tracy. 1979. "Why boycott Nestlé: testing the case for the defense." Christianity And Crisis 39, no. 11: 172-176 Frame, Randall L. "At last, Nestlé satisfies some of its church critics." Christianity Today 28, no. 1 (January 13, 1984)Koerber, Amy. 2013. Breast or Bottle? Contemporary Controversies in Infant-Feeding Policy and Practice. Columbia, South Carolina: University of South Carolina Press, 2013 Miller, Fred. Out of the Mouths of Babes: The Infant Formula Controversy. Bowling Green State University: Social Philosophy and Policy Center, 1983 Myers, Alicia D. 2014. 'In the Father's Bosom': Breastfeeding and Identity Formation in John's Gospel." The Catholic Biblical Quarterly 76, no. 3: 481-497 Rand Oakley, Maureen. “The Bottle, The Breast, and the State: The Politics of Infant Feeding in the United States”. Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books, 2015 Radzik, Linda. "BOYCOTTS AND THE SOCIAL ENFORCEMENT OF JUSTICE." Social Philosophy & Policy 34, no. 1 (Summer, 2017): 102-122 Rosin, Hanna. 2009. "THE CASE AGAINST BREAST-FEEDING." Atlantic 303, no. 3: 64-70 Sasson, Tehila. “Milking the Third World? Humanitarianism, Capitalism, and the Moral Economy of the Nestlé Boycott”. The American Historical Review, Volume 121, Issue 4, 1 October 2016, Pages 1196–1224, https://doi.org/10.1093/ahr/121.4.1196, Published: 03 October 2016 Taylor, Robin. 1989. "Infant-formula distribution controversial." National Catholic Reporter 25, 1-2 Van Esterik, Penny. “Beyond the Breast-Bottle Controversy”. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1989 Wirpsa, Leslie.. "Formula giants pursue 3rd World market." National Catholic Reporter 30, 12-13, 1994 Preliminary Outline: Introduction Chapter 1 An Exploration of the History of the Sale of Infant Formula Controversy: Understanding of The Corporate Protagonists and their Agenda. What was it like before the problem? Chapter 2 A Contemporary Christian Response to the Infant Formula Controversy: A Christian Understanding of Constructive and Active Engagement Chapter 3 Practical Suggestions for Christian Engagement emphasizing A Christian Understanding of Corporate Social Responsibility Conclusion Proposed schedule for the work: I plan to take CTS 455 Advanced Theological Research and Writing in Fall 2018. As part of this course, I will complete my reading and research. In consultation with my Advisor, I will complete a draft of chapter 1. I will complete a draft of chapter 2 by the end of January. A full draft, including chapter 3, will be completed by the end of March. In April, I will complete final edits in response to recommendations made by my Advisor and Reader.