[go: up one dir, main page]

Academia.eduAcademia.edu
ICSADU 2017 REVIEWER FORM Paper code: 025 Paper title: Waste Processing Building With Incineration Technology Abstracts: Keywords: OVERALL EVALUATION Your overall evaluation for this submission ☐5: excellent paper ☐4: good paper x 3: borderline paper ☐2: poor paper ☐1: fail paper REVIEWER’S CONFIDENCE Confidence of your expertise in the subject areas of the submission ☐5: expert ☐4: high x 3: medium ☐2: low ☐1: not familiar PRESENTATION Writing and expression ☐5: excellent ☐4: good x 3: fair ☐2: poor ☐1: fail ANALYSIS The depth of the analysis and the use of empirical data ☐5: excellent ☐4: good x 3: fair ☐2: poor ☐1: fail DISCUSSION The quality of discussion of the related work ☐5: excellent ☐4: good x 3: fair ☐2: poor ☐1: fail TECHNICAL SOUNDNESS The soundness of the proposed works ☐5: excellent ☐4: good x 3: fair ☐2: poor ☐1: fail ORIGINALITY The novelty of the work ☐5: excellent ☐4: good x 3: fair ☐2: poor ☐1: fail REVIEW Please provide a detailed review, including justification for your score. This review will be sent to the authors. This field is required. Writing: Figures need to be explained in the body of paper. Some part of Figure 4 is empty. Sources of figures need to be written. Some sentences need to be revised for easier understanding of the reader. Paper Content: Design based on analysis and or empirical study could not be found. Overall evaluation: Fair paper FINAL DECISION ☐ACCEPT x MINOR CHANGE ☐MAJOR REVISION ☐REJECT