Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
General issue
Lesley Wood, Irina Ceric, Laurence Cox, Radha d’Souza, Ana
Margarida Esteves, Sara Motta, Jiří Navrátil, Dawn Paley,
Eduardo Romanos, Heike Schaumberg, Anna Szołucha,
Peter Waterman
2017 is tense and uncertain. Diagnosing the current moment, with its ecological,
political and economic crises, and prescribing strategies for transcending and
interrupting these crises are challenges that generate discussion and confusion.
It is in these sorts of moments that Interface seems particularly relevant, as a
space to “learn from each other’s struggles” as we all, in our different
movements and research contexts, attempt to understand the nature of the
present crisis. The issue has no particular theme, imposed from above by us, the
editorial spokescouncil, but we have brought together the best of our
submissions to reflect on today’s dynamics.
In this issue
Organically, particular clusters of pieces emerged. The first cluster evaluates
particular tactics. Appropriately for the crises of the moment, David Hoffman,
Danny Lundy, Amanda Anderson and Michael Lanza discuss Internet
campaigning strategies with reference to the 2016 US presidential primaries.
Chandra Russo’s practice note explores the complexities and reworkings of the
safety pin tactic in current activist practice. In his article, Brian Mallon shows
and contextualises the rise of direct action in housing activism in Dublin. Phil
Hedges’ article draws on Benjamin, Jackson and Hobsbawm to discuss the
challenges in writing a history of a rent strike at University College London.
A second cluster of pieces considers the dynamics of movement building in
particular contexts. Janine Joyce and Joseph Llewellyn discuss the successes
and failures of bicultural and anarchist organising principles in a peace-building
project in Aotearoa / New Zealand. Geoffrey Pleyers’ article examines how local
food projects in Belgium have developed from a primarily prefigurative
approach to a more institutionalised one. Niccolò Bertuzzi looks at the
organisation and communication structures of the No Expo network in Milan.
Laurence Cox’s paper shows the importance of social movement dynamics in
the struggle against water charges in Ireland. Looking at women’s activism in
Oaxaca, Alice Poma and Tommaso Gravante show how emotions are central to
understanding emancipation in protest. Finally, Georgia Bekridaki and
Antonios Broumas’ article explores the resurgence and potential of socially
reproductive commons in the Greek crisis.
While many of these pieces involved a favourite topic of Interface, movement
learning, two pieces focused particularly on this idea. Thembi Luckett, Shirley
Walters and Astrid von Kotze recover the long history of popular education in
South Africa for today’s movements. Meanwhile Jeffrey Rubin and Emma
1
Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
Solokoff-Rubin discuss the dialogue they constructed across borders between
Brazilian women’s movement activists and US students.
Given the current moment, it is not surprising that we also have articles on the
repression faced by activists. In this issue we publish an interview with
assassinated Mexican activist Miguel Ángel Jiménez Blanco by Kara Andrade,
Ernesto Castañeda and Luis Rubén Díaz-Cepeda. Stefano Boni’s event analysis
discusses successful resistance to building a prison in Venezuela (in Spanish).
Each issue, we also receive a significant number of submissions on
environmental movements. This issue, Andreas Bieler’s article assesses
resistance to neoliberalism in the European Citizen’s Initiative “Water and
sanitation are a human right”. Matthias Schmelzer and Dennis Eversberg
analyse the political orientations of the movement for sustainable degrowth in
Europe. Lastly, linking a broad range of movements, there is also a short
introduction to the new activist/scholar oral history project on People’s Global
Action.
Within this open issue, we have experimented with a new format. Our special
section, guest-edited by Katia Valenzuela-Fuentes, Dominika V. Polanska and
Anne Kaun, brings together a number of activist/scholar pieces on the theme of
“The right to housing in theory and practice: going beyond the West”. Thanks to
Jiři, Ania and Alice for their assistance with the editing process. This section
opens with its own introduction by the guest editors. Next, Joanna Kostka and
Katarzyna Czarnota’s discusses the potential for engaged scholarship on the
basis of research in Poznan. Bálint Misetics discusses the complexities of
organising with homeless people in Hungary. Ana Vilenica (with Ana Džokić
and Marc Neelan / Who Builds the City) maps the experience and potential of
housing activism in Serbia. Marta Solanas’ Spanish-language piece discusses
cooperative housing and counter-hegemony in Uruguay and beyond. Klemen
Ploštajner asks about neoliberal ideology and the challenges facing housing
activism in Slovenia. Andrea Aureli and Pierpaolo Mudu’s article discusses the
Italian “anomaly” and residential squatting as a mode of political agency. The
special section closes with the transcription of an activist panel bringing
together people from organisations involved in struggles over housing in
Poland, Hungary, Turkey and Mexico.
As usual, we have a bumper crop of book reviews, collected by Bjarke and Dawn.
We have reviews of Heather Ann Thompson’s Blood in the Water: the Attica
Prison Uprising of 1971 and its Legacy (Elva Orozco); Andy Blunden’s The
Origins of Collective Decison Making (Bonnie Nardi); Andrew Lamas, Todd
Wolfson and Peter Funke’s The Great Refusal: Herbert Marcuse and
Contemporary Social Movements (Raphael Schlembach); Nicholas Hildyard’s
Licenced Larceny: Infrastructure, Financial Extraction and the Global South
(Alexander Dunlap); Javier Sicilia’s El Deshabitado (Andrew Smolski); William
Carroll’s Expose, Oppose, Propose: Alternative Policy Groups and the Struggle
for Global Justice (Andrew Kettler); Gladys Tzul Tzul’s Sistemas de Gobierno
Comunal Indígena: Mujeres Y Tramas de Parentesco En Chuimeq’ena’ (Meztli
Yoalli Rodríguez Aguilera, in Spanish); William Carroll and Kanchan Sarker’s A
2
Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
World to Win: Contemporary Social Movements and Counter-Hegemony
(Laurence Cox); Robert Press’ Ripples of Hope: How Ordinary People Resist
Repression without Violence (Richa Biswas); and Michelle Williams and
Vishwas Satgar’s Marxism in the 21st Century: Crisis, Critique and Struggle
(Lika Rodin).
Also in this issue you will find our first event announcement, for the 6th
international “Workers’ Economy” meeting (Aug 30 - Sept 2) in the Hotel Bauen
cooperative, Buenos Aires and an invitation to submit event announcements.
Finally we have details of another social movements journal, Moving the Social,
published by the Institute for Social Movements (Bochum, Germany).
Our current call for papers (for issue 10/1, to be published in May 2018) is on
“Political parties, trade unions and social movements: emancipatory
reconfigurations of popular organisation”, with a special section dedicated to
Peter Waterman’s activist-scholar life, work and legacy. Peter was still working
on the main call for papers when he was taken into hospital. The deadline will
be November 1 2017.
Updates from editors
As you can see, this issue brings together a broad set of movements from a
diverse (although always incomplete) range of struggles and territories. Starting
from these experiences and pieces, we as editors then work to strengthen and
produce the issue.
We thought it might be interesting for our readers and ourselves to know more
about the names behind the emails of the editors. Given the decentralized, and
voluntary nature of the project, many of us have never met “in real life”, and we
don’t know each other well. Here are a few words about what we’re up to, from
many, but not all of our crew (texts from late May).
3
Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
In alphabetical order…
Irina Ceric. I am currently involved in skill-building a renewed network of land
defender allies in the territory known as British Columbia, on the west coast of
Canada. As you may have heard, Canada's photogenic but deeply neoliberal PM
has approved numerous pipelines, and resistance continues to build. I am also
currently conducting interviews across Canada and the US with activist legal
collective members as part of a research project on radical legal support, social
movement knowledge production and legal consciousness.
Laurence Cox. I’m involved in the international outreach work for opposition to
the G20 meeting in Hamburg this July. The local police are throwing their
weight about and seriously irritating a lot of Hamburgers. It’s an important
protest at a European level in that Blockupy are hoping to use it to rebuild
networks of movements against austerity across the continent. There is also a
bit of a reconnection internationally around challenging the neoliberal summits,
with “BRICS from below” and companer@s in Argentina who are planning for a
WTO summit this December and the G20 next year.
Radha D'Souza. It is May Day in London. India Matters UK is on its first protest
march since it was founded two months ago to oppose fascism in India. On its
first march IMUK is demanding the release of Prof. Saibaba and his comrades
sentenced to life imprisonment for demanding social justice for the rural poor
and for setting aside the sentences handed out to 13 trade unionists in MarutiSuzuki's Manesar plant in India. In the past my comrades and I went from one
solidarity campaign to the next. Fascists in India are digging their heels in deep,
so are we.
Ana Margarida Esteves is currently a Postdoctoral Research Associate at
Centro de Estudos Internacionais, Instituto Universitário de Lisboa, ISCTEIUL. She is conducting Participatory Action Research with transition initiatives,
solidarity economy networks and integral cooperatives in Southern Europe and
Latin America. She is also active in the anti-austerity movement in Portugal and
at the European Level, as well as in the European Commons Assembly.
Sara Motta. I, with others, are dreaming into being a radical community
education collective The Communiversity Newcastle, and a sacred shared living
community here in Newcastle, NSW. We are also trying to keep spaces of
meaningful emancipatory scholarship alive in the University at a time of
increasingly cruel restructuring. I am writing my second book, a decolonial
feminist non-manifesto 'Liminal Subjects: Weaving (Our) Liberation, and
4
Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
visioning with mother-scholars in Colombia, Australia and Brazil a participatory
project 'La Politica de la Maternidad/ Reading Motherhood Politically'.
Jiří Navrátil. I´m currently doing a research project on progressive and illiberal
political activism in Czech cities and teaching at two universities. Besides this
I’ve been organising a series of discussions and meet-ups with former global
justice activists and autonomists over my recent book on the transformation of
alterglobalization activism in Central Europe.
Dawn Paley. Yet another difficult week in Mexico. A young woman named
Lesvy Berlin Orsorio was killed and her body was left tied to a phone booth on
the campus of Mexico's National University (UNAM). The Public Prosecutor of
Mexico City sent out a series of tweets after Berlin Osorio's murder was made
public, noting that she was not a student and that she had been drinking earlier
in the day. This follows a pattern of victim blaming common in Mexico. Seven
women are murdered every day in this country, and Berlin Osorio's murder sent
a strong message, generating a great deal of fear and rage among my
compañeras at grad school. ¡Nos queremos vivas!
Eduardo Romanos. I write this editorial with one foot out of Interface after two
and a half years of learning. I have only words of gratitude for the authors I have
worked with, for my colleagues from the Western Europe team and for the rest
of the editors. Thank you for your patience and understanding in this my first
experience as an editor. I am glad to have been part of a journal that is a
reference for both activists and scholars of social movements around the globe.
And I'm sorry to leave it, but my hours are limited. Acting as an editor is an
interesting task and at times very rewarding (especially when you see the
articles you have been working with published) but also demanding (this
shouldn’t discourage anyone interesting in joining the project – believe me: it's
worth it). Now I will continue to play the role of editor in another journal, which
I see as an ally rather than a rival. At the moment I am also the coordinator of a
Master’s Degree in applied sociology at the Universidad Complutense of Madrid
(if anyone is interested, admission is now open!). And I keep on teaching and
researching social movements. Among other projects, I am still devoting much
time to understanding the great, transformative adventure (still underway)
which many of us joined six years ago: the so-called indignados movement.
Alongside that, another adventure has transformed me even more for the past
three and a half years: my little boy.
Heike Schaumberg. I am writing these lines having just attended yet another
multitudinal demonstration in the Argentine capital, Buenos Aires. Today’s
mobilisation was against the “2x1”, an invalidated law that aimed to discourage
unnecessarily protracted detention, and which was shamefully revived in a
5
Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
recent High Court case but to benefit those standing trial for crimes against
humanity committed during the country’s brutal military dictatorship (19761983). This case would have set a precedent that could have seen many of those
responsible for genocide walk free. But public outcry persuaded Congress to
quickly repudiate this law just hours prior to the protest. Regardless, the
multitude turned out to protest and celebrate its victory. It followed a busy
month of a militant teacher’s strike, mass mobilisations against gendered
violence, evictions of workers’ cooperatives, redundancies, and a powerful
general strike on 6 April. This energetic show of defiance affirms that we can
change the world! Let that message ring loud and clear at capitalism’s planned
and upcoming fiestas hosted by the City of Buenos Aires: the WTO meeting this
coming December, and the G20 and G30 next year.
Bjarke Skærlund Risager. Having recently moved from one continent to
another with my young family, I'm trying to get my bearings in a new (political)
climate. My PhD dissertation on the spatial production of European social
movements in the context of economic and democratic crises is on hold while
I'm on parental leave with my one-year-old.
Ania Szolucha. I am working on the ground to document the impacts of shale
gas developments in Lancashire, UK which, most recently, include the increase
in policing with all its effects, lock-ons and other direct actions at the fracking
site that is currently under construction. I am also trying to assemble a
comprehensive history of shale gas in Poland.
Lesley Wood. Last night I spent the night sleeping on the concrete outside the
Toronto Mayor's condo building. The organization I work with is trying to put
pressure on the city to better fund both homeless shelters and support
affordable housing. Like many 'global' cities, Toronto has become affordable
only for the rich.
Farewells and welcomes
With this issue we are bidding farewell to no fewer than four Interface editors:
Elizabeth Humphrys, Alice Mattoni, Richard Pithouse and Eduardo Romanos.
Elizabeth was a founding editor whose contributions were central to keeping the
journal going, and whose beautiful covers have been the first thing most readers
have seen. Alice has been a long-time member of the western European group as
well as lead editor on numerous special issues. Richard’s connection with the
struggles of South African shanty-town dwellers and their razor-sharp
theorising has brought a very important dimension to Interface. Lastly
Eduardo’s involvement in the western European group and his sharp
understanding of a wide range of different social movements has been a great
6
Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
contribution. We are immensely grateful to everything they have brought to the
journal, and many of us will continue working with them in other contexts.
Meanwhile, Dawn Paley - radical journalist, media activist and researcher - has
joined us as a book reviews editor and is already bringing a huge amount to the
project; and Alexander Waters – activist and PhD student – has joined the
Australia / New Zealand group as well as helping with our website work.
We had a fantastic response to our call for new editors for the western European
group, and are working with a number of people who will hopefully join us as
full editors by our next issue.
North American editors wanted
Interface’s editorial collective for the US and Canada is looking for one new
editor to join the current editors, Irina Ceric and Lesley Wood. We handle
articles sent in by people across a very wide range of social movements,
academic disciplines; find reviewers when needed and take part in special issue
projects from time to time as well as helping to run the journal as a whole.
Interface is a voluntary project: we see this as an important contribution to
helping movements learn from each other and to develop dialogue between
researchers and movements outside the constraints of conventional academic
journals.
We’re looking for someone familiar with and involved in US movements (Irina
and Lesley are both based in Canada) and who is excited about working with
words and ideas; ideally scholar/activists who have time and enthusiasm to
contribute, but we’re also open to people outside academia altogether who have
strong writing/editing/theoretical skills. We’re hoping to find people who
complement the existing editors in terms of movement interests and
involvement, languages, countries and disciplines/intellectual traditions (we
don’t have to agree on everything!). We’re informal and comradely but also
organised in how we work together.
If you’re interested, please email both Irina and Lesley (ljwood AT yorku.ca and
irina.ceric AT gmail.com) by July 20th with a few paragraphs about yourself and
why you’d like to do this / how you see it fitting into what you want to do
politically or intellectually. Do also please let us know how we can get the best
sense of your work – a CV, a website link, a sample of your writing…
7
Interface: a journal for and about social movements
Volume 9 (1): 1 - 8 (2017)
Editorial
General issue
Peter Waterman, 1936-2017
Finally, and sadly, not long after writing his own contribution to these editors’
updates, our long-standing international / transnational editor Peter Waterman
died at the age of 81. This editorial is followed by his obituary, but it seems
appropriate to close this editorial, the last one he will co-sign, with his own,
typically casual update written in between medical appointments:
Peter Waterman. I am less active academically (being long retired) and
politically (in the sense of activism) than cyberspacially. This is firstly with the
free, online social movements journal, Interface. Cyberia, as I call it, is the
promised land - or cloud - for us 80-year-olds. And whilst it is also a 'disputed
terrain', Cyberia permits a range and flexibility of relationships that has never
previously existed. Just more or less completed my third compilation of
scattered papers which, like the two previous ones, will be available at a token
price or free on line. Oh, and Cyberia welcomes the under-80s also.
8