[go: up one dir, main page]

Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Landscape and Divine Justice.pdf

A paper presented at the international conference "Sacred Spaces, Urban Networks", Research Center for Anatolian Civilizations (Koç University), Dec. 9, 2016. Addresses archbishop Hillerau (1798-1855)'s role in assessing and reworking the landscape of Catholic presence in late Ottoman Istanbul

Landscape and divine justice: archbishop Hillereau’s perception and patronage of Christian architecture in Istanbul The archbishop Julien-Marie Hillerau, apostolic vicar of the Latin Catholic community of Istanbul between 1835 and 1855, addressed in 1837 a report on the local situation of Catholicism to the Lyon chapter of the congregation De Propaganda Fide. In his description of the religious landscape of the Ottoman capital, he remarked that the magnificence and predominant standing of mosques was emphasized by their location on hilltops as well as by their design and size, in sharp contrast with the understated and hardly visible stance of churches. Rather surprisingly, he added that this was a sign of divine justice, a symbolic punishment of heresy, schism and deviation from the Catholic truth. In fact, Hillereau was describing a landscape in which most Catholic sanctuaries were not subject to the intimidating confrontation with mosques, being mostly concentrated in the Latin district of Galata - and especially (for the most recent establishments) on the heights of Pera. His remark was related to non-Catholic, Armenian and Greek-Orthodox churches. But the 20 years of Hillereau’s vicariate in Istanbul were actually one of the most crucial periods of change in power balances, inter-communal relations, and collective self-representation. In the 1840s and early 50s he would become a direct agent of this change, being involved in the patronage of two major churches, that marked a departure from the marginality and reduced visibility of older Catholic structures. With the aid of architectural, iconographical and textual evidence, this paper evaluates how the transforming landscape, in which Hillereau was both spectator and actor, signified and represented the drama of inter-communal relations and coexistence. Paolo Girardelli Associate Professor Boğaziçi University – Dept. of History Collection Nelly Durand http://vendeens-archives.vendee.fr/personnalite-hillereau-julien-mariefrancois-xavier-5142