Synthesis and characterization of self-curing hydrophilic bone cements
for protein delivery
ndez1
E. Franco-Marquès,1 J. Parra,2 M. A. Pèlach,1 J. A. Me
1
LEPAMAP Group, Universitat de Girona, Maria Aurèlia Capmany 61, 17071, Girona, Spain
n Clınica y Biopatologıa Experimental, Complejo Asistencial de Avila
Unidad Asociada de I1D al CSIC de Investigacio
s del Gran Poder 42, 05003 Avila, Spain
(SACYL), Jesu
2
Received 30 April 2014; revised 25 July 2014; accepted 19 August 2014
Published online 00 Month 2014 in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI: 10.1002/jbm.b.33283
Abstract: New formulations of acrylic bone cements for bone
defect reparation, based on self-hardening methyl methacrylate (MMA)/methacrylic acid (MAA), with a high capacity for
protein delivery, have been developed. The self-curing formulations were prepared by partial substitution of solid phase
PMMA microparticles by newly obtained PMAA microspheres. The PMAA microspheres were prepared by inverse
suspension polymerization of their monomer and were crosslinked with N,N’-methylene-bis-acrylamide (MBA) (10–15 wt
%) to produce stable systems in contact with aqueous media.
PMAA microspheres were loaded with hydrolyzed collagen
(HC) as a model protein to simulate bone morphogenetic protein delivery useful for hard tissue reconstruction. Solid
phase PMMA microparticles in the formulation were partially
substituted by new PMAA-HC microspheres and were characterized to determine viability as an acrylic bone cement in
minimally invasive surgery. The incorporation of PMAA-HC
microspheres decreased peak temperature by 20 C, which
minimized thermal necrotic risk after implantation. Mechanical compression tests revealed a behavior, under dry conditions, close to ISO 5833 standard requirements. However, a
drastic drop in mechanical strength, 64%, was obtained
after 15 days of immersion in simulated physiological conditions (37 C and pH 7.4) and was attributed to water absorption and a subsequent plasticizing effect. The increase in
water uptake and retention enhanced the capability for controlled protein delivery. Finally, the biocompatibility of the
cements was determined; some toxicity of the material during the first hours of culture incubation was observed. Later,
toxicity was observed to decrease due to nonreacted monomer leaching, which ensured the low toxicity of the already
C 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater
polymerized phase. V
Res Part B: Appl Biomater 00B:000–000, 2014.
Key Words: self-curing bone cements, minimally invasive surgery, hydrophilic cements, protein delivery, dorsalgia
ndez JA. 2014. Synthesis and characterization of self-curing
How to cite this article: Franco-Marquès E, Parra J, Pèlach MA, Me
hydrophilic bone cements for protein delivery. J Biomed Mater Res Part B 2014:00B:000–000.
INTRODUCTION
Current acrylic bone cements, which are used for bone reparation and reconstruction, are based on poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA). These types of materials are obtained by
radical polymerization, which is initiated at low temperature
with a redox initiating system, of a liquid phase based on
methyl methacrylate monomer (MMA) in the presence of an
already polymerized solid phase based on PMMA microparticles. From the beginning, these materials have been used
in hip and knee total arthroplasty,1,2 dental surgery,3,4 bone
defect reparation and reconstruction5, and even in the treatment of tumors.6
The use of plain PMMA systems is focused on the prosthesis fixation or bone defect stabilization without any other
expectation of interaction with living tissue. The interaction
of biological activity with damaged or newly born tissue is
a broad field of research that is constantly growing. Mendez
et al. developed an acrylic bone cement that was modified
with a phosphate derivative of salicylic acid; antiinflammatory activity on the implant’s surrounding tissue
diminished the inflammatory process because of the presence of scanty multinucleated giant cells.7 Included antibiotics8,9 have effectively diminished the risk of infection after
surgery by controlled delivery during the first period of
implantation. Vitamins such as a-tocopherol have also been
included both by mixing with biodegradable polymers10 and
by copolymerizing with MMA11 to decrease oxidation phenomena during in situ polymerization, which improves
biocompatibility.
One of the handicaps of this biomedical technology is
related to the low capacity of interaction of PMMA with
aqueous fluids, such as biological ones, to promote the
interaction between living tissue and PMMA implants.
PMMA is a very hydrophobic polymer with a water uptake
ndez; e-mail: jalberto.mendez@udg.edu
Correspondence to: J. A. Me
Contract grant sponsor: MEC of Spain; contract grant number: MAT2010-18155
Contract grant sponsor: University of Girona; contract grant number: BR-07/05
C 2014 WILEY PERIODICALS, INC.
V
1
capacity lower than 2.0–2.5 wt %, which avoids the diffusion of water through the material and limits its use as a
carrier for hydrophilic medicaments.9,12 In this sense, many
of the medicaments, with useful activity for osteoinduction
and osteoconduction, are highly hydrophilic and once incorporated to the cement, have serious limitations in migrating
from the material to the surrounding tissue. The common
behavior of the delivery process from highly hydrophobic
materials is characterized by a fast release of the drug close
to the implant surface,8,9 which is limited to the outer layers
of the material. The release profile presents a burst effect,
leaching up to 90% of the maximum medicament content
during the first hours of incubation/implantation, and
retaining a high percentage inside the material
after reach
ing the equilibrium release d½drug dt 50 .
Release behavior depends on the drug-polymer interaction. Caracciolo et al. synthesized polyurethane networks
(PUNs) based on oligomers of caprolactone (CL) triol or
tetronic 701 as a polyol and poly(ethyleneglycol) (PEG) as
an extender cross-linked using hexamethylene diisocyanate
(HDI) to determine its use as a drug delivery system of
paracetamol.13 The high hydrophilicity of the polymer
matrix and its low interaction with the medicament gave
rise to release profiles with 20% of the total drug delivered
in the first 10 h of immersion in phosphate buffered solution. Thus, the equilibrium between the hydrophobic and
hydrophilic ratio must be controlled to reach the desired
profiles.
The application of the self-curing acrylic material prepared in this work is designed to repair vertebra bone
defects derived from degenerative pathologies such as
osteoporosis. Osteoporosis appears with irreversible damage
of bone microarchitecture and a reduced bone mass, which
increases the risk of fractures. The disease is mainly due to
a dysfunction of bone remodeling and allows the formation
of bone cavities produced by the loss of bone. Most patients
suffer strong back pain (dorsalgia) related with the vertebrae crushing affected by osteoporosis.14 One surgical technique used to diminish dorsalgia is vertebroplasty, where an
acrylic bone cement is injected directly into the vertebra to
reconstruct its structure and support the body’s weight.
In this work, a new self-curing acrylic material has been
obtained to allow protein delivery, which minimizes burst
effect and increases release time. Solid phase PMMA microspheres of the acrylic formulation have been substituted by
poly(methacrylic acid) (PMAA) cross-linked microspheres to
increase water uptake and maintain the methacrylic nature
of the polymer matrix to improve the chemical compatibility. PMAA-based microspheres have been prepared by
means of inverse suspension polymerization using methacrylic acid (MAA) as a monomer cross-linked with N,N’methylene-bis-acrylamide (MBA) to avoid solubilization in
aqueous media. The PMAA microspheres were characterized
by different microscopic and spectroscopic techniques and
loaded with hydrolyzed collagen (HC) as a model protein to
simulate the delivery of bone morphogenetic proteins
(BMPs) with a high capacity for osteoinduction and osteoconduction.15–17 Finally, the biocompatibility of the formula-
2
ET AL.
FRANCO-MARQUES
tions was characterized by means of studying the in vitro
toxicity of samples in contact with human osteoblasts.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
Materials for synthesis and physical-chemical characterization. Poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) microspheres
(DegacrylTM MW 332) were provided by Degussa, with an
average diameter of 60 lm. Methacrylic acid (MAA) (SigmaAldrich) was purified by vacuum distillation and neutralized
with a concentrated solution of NaOH to avoid monomer
distribution between the aqueous and organic phases during inverse suspension polymerization. Methyl methacrylate
(MMA) (Acros Organics) and N,N0 -methylene-bis-acrylamide
(MBA) (Sigma-Aldrich), used as received, were used as
acrylic monomer and the crosslinking agent, respectively.
Benzoyl peroxide (BPO), purchased from Scharlau, purified
by fractional crystallization from methanol (mp 104 C), and
4,40 -(dimethyl amino)diphenyl carbinol (BZN) (Fluka), used
as received, were used as a low temperature redox initiator
system. Hydrolyzed collagen (HC) has been kindly given by
Protein (Celra, Spain) and is commercialized under the commercial name of Colnatur. Potassium peroxodisulphate
(K2S2O8) and Span 80 (sorbitan monooleate) (SigmaAldrich) were used as received as the polymerization initiator and nonionic surfactant. The other reagents for synthesis were of analytical grade and used without any further
purification.
Materials for toxicity characterization. Nunc ThermanoxTM
coverslips were provided by Thermo Scientific. Foetal
bovine serum (FBS) and Triton X-100 were supplied by
Gibco and Merck, respectively. Dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO)
was acquired from Scharlau. All other reagents were supplied by Sigma-Aldrich.
Methods
Preparation of PMAA microspheres by inverse suspension
polymerization. A typical procedure for the inverse suspension polymerization.
Aqueous phase. MAA (17.0 mL, 17.2 g, 200 mmol) were
drop-wise neutralized with an alkaline aqueous solution
(NaOH, 8 g, 200 mmols), and dissolved in 20 mL of distilled
water in an ice cooling bath. MBA was added to the totally
neutralized MAA solution in a 100-mL beaker. After mild
stirring for few minutes, K2S2O8 (1% w/w regarding monomer content) was added to the monomer solution. To
induce complete dissolution of the polymerization initiator,
the minimum volume of distilled water was added to the
solution at room temperature until obtaining a clear and
saturated homogeneous solution.
Oil phase. 8.7 mL of Span 80 (5.5% v/v regarding oil
phase) were added to 150 mL of toluene in a 250-mL
three-neck jacketed reactor mechanically stirred (600 rpm)
and heated at 70 C. The mixture was purged with nitrogen
for 10 min prior to the reaction.
The aqueous phase was placed in a dropping funnel and
flushed with nitrogen for 15 min. Later, the aqueous phase
SELF-CURING HYDROPHILIC BONE CEMENTS FOR PROTEIN DELIVERY
ORIGINAL RESEARCH REPORT
was drop-wise added to the oil phase, also previously
flushed with nitrogen. The reactor was stirred (600 rpm)
and heated for 4 h. Once this time had elapsed, the temperature was increased to 80 C for two more hours.
Isolation of the PMAA microspheres. The oil phase (upper
phase) was removed by a Pasteur pipette and the obtained
PMAA microspheres, together with the aqueous phase, were
added to 400 mL of acetone in a 1L-beaker and stirred for
20 min. Later, the microspheres were filtrated under vacuum. This dispersion/filtration process was repeated three
times. The microspheres were washed with distilled water
and lyophilized to constant weight (Virtis lyophilizer, New
York).
Preparation of PMAA-HC microspheres. Depending on the
intended HC content, 2 or 5 g of HC were dissolved in
200 mL of distilled water at room temperature. The solution
was added to 20 g of PMAA-microspheres under strong stirring. Once the solution was completely absorbed by the
microspheres, the newly formed PMAA-HC microspheres
were lyophilized (Virtis lyophilizer, New York) to eliminate
water. Afterwards, PMAA-HC microspheres were stored until
use in an anhydrous atmosphere.
Characterization of PMAA and PMAA-HC microspheres.
Particle size distribution. The particle size distribution
was evaluated by laser scattering using a Coulter LS320
(Beckman). About 10 mg of each powdered material were
thoroughly dispersed in 2 mL of acetone by magnetic stirring for 10 min and finally, an average of three measurements was recorded for each sample.
Surface characterization. The prepared microparticles
and the derived acrylic self-curing formulation were characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Each sample
was previously conditioned by freezing with liquid nitrogen
and sputter-coating with gold (K550 from Emitech, Ashfort,
UK). Finally, the samples were observed under a Zeiss DMS
960 model electronic microscope.
Chemical composition. Qualitative chemical composition
of the microparticles was determined by means of FTIR
spectrophotometry. KBr-supported pellets were prepared
with 2–3 wt % of each sample and the spectra were
recorded, from 400 to 4000 cm21 wavenumber, using a
Mattson-Satellite FTIR spectrophotometer.
Thermal characterization. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) were performed. Samples of 10 mg were submitted to a heating
program from 25 to 200 C in a Mettler Toledo 822e calorimeter (Switzerland). Additionally, samples of 8–10 mg
were heated from 50 to 650 C using a Mettler Toledo TGA/
DTA 851e thermobalance (Switzerland). Both tests were carried out in independent experiments and were performed
under inert atmosphere (nitrogen 40 mL min21).
Preparation of hydrophilic self-curing formulations. The
solid phase of the self-curing formulation was based on
three main components: commercial PMMA beads, and/or
the prepared PMAA/PMAA-HC microspheres (50 : 50), and
BPO as the polymerization initiator (1.5 wt % regarding
solid phase). The liquid phase was composed of the monomer (MMA) and BZN (1.0 wt %). To obtain low viscous and
easy handling formulations, the solid:liquid ratio of compositions (S:L) was adjusted to 1 : 1. Polymerization started
with the addition of the liquid to the solid phase. Initially,
the reacting mass was hand-stirred with a spatula at a very
low mixing rate (20–30 r.p.m.) to avoid trapping air bubbles. Once the reacting mass was not stuck to the surgical
glove, it was molded inside PTFE-moulds equipped with
pressing plates. Finally, the mould was placed in an oven at
37 C for 1 h, to simulate physiological conditions.
Characterization of hydrophilic self-curing formulations.
Curing parameters. The energetic behavior of the polymerizing
process
was
determined
by recording
temperature-curing time values of the curing process, performed within a cylindrical PTFE-made mould at 25 C,
according to ISO 5833 standard specifications. A thermocouple was placed in the centre of the polymerizing mass, at a
height of 3 mm in the internal cavity of the mould, to detect
the variation of temperature with curing time. The
temperature-time data were recorded with a highly sensitive
thermotester with automatic data acquisition (Testo 177,
Barcelona, Spain).
In vitro behavior. Water sorption (%WS) of the hydrophilic acrylic formulations was evaluated at 37 C and pH
7.4 (PBS). This parameter was studied after the immersion
of discs of each formulation (15 mm in diameter and 1 mm
in thickness) during different time periods. An average of a
minimum of three independent experiments was obtained.
The determination of %WS was according to Eq. (1):
ðWt 2W0 Þ
%WS5
100
W0
(1)
where W0 is the weight of the sample before immersion
and Wt is the weight at immersion time t.
Mechanical characterization. A minimum of five
cylindrical-shaped specimens of each formulation, 6 mm in
diameter and 12 mm in height, were tested at room temperature under compression stresses in an IDM DTC-10 dynamometer according to ISO 5833 standard specifications.
Evaluation of protein delivery. Hydrolyzed collagen, HC,
was used as a protein model to determine the capacity of
the system to be used as a protein carrier. Polymerized
disc-shaped specimens (15 mm in diameter and 1 mm in
thickness) of formulations loaded with HC were immersed
in 15 mL of PBS (37 C and pH 7.4). PBS was totally
replaced at specific periods of time by a fresh buffer solution and the HC content was monitored by UV-VIS spectrophotometry (205 nm) (Schimadzu UV-160).
Toxicity evaluation. The biological response to the experimental formulations was tested using cultures of human
foetal osteoblasts (HOb; Health Protection Agency Culture
Collections). The culture medium was Dulbecco’s Modified
Eagle’s Medium/Nutrient Mixture F-12 Ham (DME/F12 1 :
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | MONTH 2014 VOL 00B, ISSUE 00
3
1 mixture) modified with HEPES (4-(2-hydroxyethyl)21piperazine ethanesulfonic acid) and supplemented with
10% fetal bovine serum (FBS), 200 mM L-glutamine (Sigma),
100 units/mL penicillin and 100 lg/mL streptomycin. HOb
cultures were maintained at 37 C in humidified air with 5%
CO2, and the culture medium was changed every 2 days
with care to cause little disturbance to culture conditions.
R coverslips with a diameter of 13 mm (TMX)
ThermanoxV
and Triton X-100 (0.5% aqueous solution) were used as
negative and positive controls, respectively. Square-shaped
samples of the experimental formulations, with a side length
of 12 mm and a thickness of 2 mm, were used to quantify
the cytotoxicity. All specimens were sterilized with ethylene
oxide. The in vitro biological behavior of the analyzed systems was assessed with a MTT (3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2yl)22,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide) assay, using a HOb
culture (subculture 4) and the extracts eluted from both the
experimental formulations and TMX samples. For determination of the extracts’ toxicity, the samples were set up in
5 mL of FBS free medium, and they were placed on a roller
mixer at 37 C. The medium was removed and cryopreserved at different periods of time (1, 3, and 7 days) and
replaced with the other 5 mL of FBS free fresh medium at 1
and 3 days. All of the extracts were obtained under sterile
conditions. Osteoblasts suspended in complete culture
medium were seeded into sterile 96-well culture plates at a
density of 1 3 105 cellsmL21 (100 mL/well) and were incubated to confluence during 24 h. Next, the medium was
replaced with the corresponding extract (n 5 6), and the
cultures were incubated at 37 C in humidified air with 5%
CO2 for 24 h. A solution of MTT was prepared in warm PBS
(0.5 mg/mL), which, after removal of the sample extracts,
was added to the cultures (100 mL/well). Then, the plates
were incubated at 37 C for 4 h. Excess medium and MTT
were removed, and dimethyl sulphoxide was added to all
wells to dissolve formazan resulting from the reduction of
MTT by the cells. After mixing for 10 min, the absorbance
was measured with a Biotek ELX808IU detector using a test
wavenumber of 570 nm and a reference wavenumber of
630 nm. The cell viability was calculated using Eq. (2):
.
RELATIVE VIABILITY ð% TMXÞ5ðODS 2ODB Þ
3100 (2)
ðODC 2ODB Þ
where ODS, ODB, and ODC are the optical density of formazan production for the sample, blank (medium without
cells) and TMX negative control, respectively.
Analysis of variance (ANOVA) of the results was performed with respect to TMX at p < 0.05, p < 0.01, and
p < 0.001 significance levels.
RESULTS
Preparation of PMAA and PMAA-HC-microspheres
In this work, methacrylic acid (MAA) has been used as a
hydrophilic monomer to prepare PMAA microspheres and
was subsequently loaded with hydrolyzed collagen as a
model molecule for controlled delivery of bone morphogenetic proteins. A difunctionalized monomer (MBA) was also
4
ET AL.
FRANCO-MARQUES
added to MAA to induce crosslinking and avoid dissolution
of PMAA in contact with simulated physiological fluids. Two
different systems of microspheres were designed depending
on MBA content: M10 and M15, where MBA was added by
10 and 15 wt % regarding the monomer weight, respectively. The addition of lower percentages of the crosslinking
agent led to water soluble materials, which were not useful
for our purposes. In both cases, microsphere particles were
obtained, as can be observed in Figure 1(A,B); microsphere
particles were insoluble in water but had a high capacity
for water retention.
Characterization of the microspheres
Once the PMAA microspheres were dried, both formulations
M10 and M15 were swollen with a solution of hydrolyzed
collagen (HC) in distilled water. Four formulations of
PMAA/HC-loaded microspheres were obtained, depending
on the microsphere composition, which are summarized in
Table I. The subsequent lyophilization process produced a
material loaded with HC spherical-shaped microparticles as
can be observed in Figure 1(C,D).
Laser scattering revealed a different particle diameter
average compared with SEM observation. Via laser scattering, no substantial dependence was observed between the
particle size distribution and the content of MBA because
the maximum population of microparticles of both sizes’
dispersion curves were centered very closely. M10 and M15
showed a particle diameter centered at approximately 80–
90 lm [Figure 2(A)], although M15 had a broader dispersion. However, M10 exhibited a particle size in the range of
30–40 lm, as measured by SEM (n 5 100 particles). These
differences in particle size and statistical distribution are
related with the establishment of particle aggregates as
observed in Figure 2(B).
PMAA and PMAA-HC microspheres were submitted to a
physicochemical characterization to determine their properties and compositions. An FTIR spectrum of PMAA microspheres revealed the presence of methacrylate salts instead
of methacrylic acid functionality, corroborating the previous
neutralization of the monomer (Figure 3). Signals at 1540
and 1392 cm21 correspond to symmetric and antisymmetric stretching of carboxylate functionality (COO2).
The presence of the signal 1197 cm21 (C-COO2 stretching)
also confirms this hypothesis.18
The results of weight loss versus temperature, obtained
by TGA-analysis, of the formulations of composites reinforced with PMAA and with PMAA-HC microspheres are
shown in Figure 4. There is a progressive degradation, in all
cases, of the material over 100 C to 400 C, far above the
use temperature for these materials (37 C). The degradation
is more intensive in the case of materials loaded with HC
because of its lower thermal resistance. The thermal decomposition under inert conditions left a high content in char
residue at temperatures lower than 500 C, which was in the
range of 40–50 wt % in all cases.
DSC profiles of the materials prepared in this work are
shown in Figure 5. Taking into account the percentage of
crosslinker used for their formulation, no glass transition
SELF-CURING HYDROPHILIC BONE CEMENTS FOR PROTEIN DELIVERY
ORIGINAL RESEARCH REPORT
FIGURE 1. SEM microphotographs of PMAA-microspheres: (A) M10, (B) M15, (C) M10-10, and (D) M10–25.
was observed in the range of temperatures assayed in this
work. Intermolecular crosslinking reduces the mobility of
the polymer segments, giving rise to an increase in the glass
transition that, in all cases, was higher than the degradation
temperature.
Preparation and physicochemical characterization
of the self-curing formulations
Four different acrylic cements were prepared using each
formulation of PMAA-based microspheres loaded with
TABLE I. Composition of PMAA Microsphere (Mxx) and
PMAA-HC Microcapsules (Mxx-yy)
Formulation
M10
M15
M10-10
M10–25
M15-10
M15–25
a
b
PMAA
(wt %)a
MBA
(wt %)a
HC
(wt %)b
90
85
90
90
85
85
10
15
10
10
15
15
0
0
10
25
10
25
Regarding weight of PMAA microspheres.
Regarding weight of PMAA-HC microspheres.
hydrolyzed collagen (HC). Moreover, four formulations
named FC-10, FC-25, FM-10, and FM-25 were also prepared
for comparison purposes. The compositions of all of the
cement formulations are summarized in Table II.
To acquire easily handled reacting masses and to allow
an optimal molding of the material, a typical 1 : 1 solid phase:liquid phase composition was used. All of the formulations were cured at 37 C for 1 h and stiff materials were
obtained in all cases.
The study of the curing process allowed for the determination of the peak temperature (Tpeak) and the setting time
(tsetting), derived from the exothermic polymerization process, which are summarized in Table III. The peak temperature of the cements modified with PMAA-microspheres, and
specifically, with PMAA-HC microspheres, was lower than
that of the reference (PMMA) and lower than the maximum
value accepted by ISO 5833 (90 C). The tsetting was not
influenced by the composition of the microspheres; in all
cases, tsetting was in the range of 13–14 min.
The fracture surface of composites was evaluated by
SEM microscopy and the micrographs are shown in Figure
6. It is possible to observe the interphase between the continuous PMMA matrix, synthesized during the curing
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | MONTH 2014 VOL 00B, ISSUE 00
5
FIGURE 2. (A) Particle size distribution obtained by laser scattering; (B) SEM microphotograph of M10 aggregates.
process, and the PMAA-microspheres, characterized by the
hollows between both components, where the transmission
of loads is not optimized. The micrograph also shows the
dispersion and individualization of the PMAA-based microparticles inside the material, helping the maintenance of the
material’s mechanical properties.
The materials were tested under compression stresses,
in a dry state and after 15 days of immersion in PBS, and
the results are summarized in Table IV. A decrease in the
compression yield stress (rc) has been observed when the
material is modified with PMAA or PMAA-HC microspheres
because of the incorporation of water inside the structure
of the composite. This phenomenon is more evident in formulations modified with the obtained PMAA microspheres
than in the reference (PMMA), due to their higher water
uptake capacity.
In the case of the formulations modified with hydrophilic microspheres, the value of rc was close to ISO 5833
standard requirements (70 MPa), which was an acceptable
result considering the high level of chemical structure modification of the cement (50 wt % regarding the solid phase).
The immersion of the samples in PBS (37 C) led to an
important decrease in rc. The incorporation of water in the
internal structure of the samples acts like a plasticizer, and
decreases the mechanical capacity of the material.
Increasing hydrophilicity of the acrylic cements has been
corroborated by means of monitoring the in vitro behavior
of the material, after immersion in PBS for different time
periods at 37 C. PMMA, FC-10 and FC-25 showed a typical
hydrophobic behavior of common acrylic bone cements as
shown in Figure 7. All formulations modified with PMAA or
PMAA-HC microspheres reached higher values of water
uptake without modification of the samples’ dimensions.
These water uptake results (WS%), in the range of 50–55%
for the formulations modified with PMAA microspheres, are
slightly higher, in the range of 35–50%, than those of materials modified with PMAA-HC microspheres. To keep the
dimensions of the samples stable, the absorbed water is
expected to be located in the holes/pores created in the
PMMA-PMAA interfaces and is expected to interact with
polar groups of the microparticles.
FIGURE 3. FT-IR spectra of hydrolysed collagen (HC), M15 PMAA
microspheres and M15–25 PMAA-HC microspheres.
FIGURE 4. TGA thermograms of PMAA microspheres (M10 and M15)
and PMAA-HC microspheres (not distinguished).
6
ET AL.
FRANCO-MARQUES
SELF-CURING HYDROPHILIC BONE CEMENTS FOR PROTEIN DELIVERY
ORIGINAL RESEARCH REPORT
ered a toxic species due to the high viability of cells in formulations FC-10 and FC-25.
DISCUSSION
FIGURE 5. DSC thermograms of PMAA and PMAA-HC microspheres.
The profiles of HC delivery with immersion time in PBS
are shown in Figure 8, and follow a similar water sorption
profile trend. The drug delivery capacity is strongly dependent on the presence of PMAA in the chemical structure of
the cement. The nonmodified formulation, made of plain
PMMA in the solid phase (PMMA, FC-10, and FC-25),
showed the lowest capacity of protein delivery with a maximum dosage of 0.33 mg/mL delivered during the first 24–
48 h of immersion. However, the formulations modified
with PMAA-HC microspheres deliver higher protein content,
which is higher for formulations with higher HC content in
the composition.
Characterization of the toxicity of the self-curing
formulations
A partial toxicity of formulations modified with PMAAmicrospheres has been detected and is shown in Figure 9. A
decrease of the cell viability during the first hours of incubation for formulations obtained with PMAA microspheres
can be observed, but after 3 or 7 days, a decrease in toxicity
was found, which suggests an initial toxicity attributed to
material components that are washed at the beginning of
the test. Additionally, hydrolyzed collagen was not considTABLE II. Composition of the Solid Phase of Self-Curing
Formulations Loaded with HC as Protein Model
Solid phase
a
Formulation
PMMA
FC-10
FC-25
FM10
FM15
FM10-10
FM10–25
FM15-10
FM15–25
a
b
PMMA
(wt %)
98.6
93.5
86.1
49.3
49.3
49.3
49.3
49.3
49.3
PMAAa
microspheres
(wt %)
HCa
5
12.5
49.3
49.3
44.2
36.7
44.2
36.7
(M10)
(M15)
(M10)
(M10)
(M15)
(M15)
Regarding weight of the solid phase.
Regarding full weight of the cement.
5
12.5
10
12.5
HCb
(wt %)
0
2.5
6.25
0
0
2.5
6.25
2.5
6.25
The self-curing formulations, also named acrylic bone
cements, have been designed for several decades as fixation
systems in orthopaedic surgery. Most of these systems also
offer the capacity to deliver pharmaceutical species for different therapies.5,8,9,19 However, in many cases, such species
show delivery difficulties because of the low chemical interaction between PMMA and the physiological media. To
increase the hydrophilic character and the delivery capability of the medicament, chemical modification of the polymer
matrix could be an interesting alternative. Because of the
singular particles’ shape of PMMA in this application
(microspheres), this chemical modification should be compatible with the preparation of microspheres for subsequent
loading with the desired pharmacological molecule. In this
sense, a polymerization reaction based on a suspension
polymerization system was intended. The polar characteristic of methacrylic acid led to development of the suspension
polymerization reaction in an inverse way, where the dispersant is the organic phase. An inverse suspension polymerization reaction is one of the most useful methodologies
to obtain highly hydrophilic microsphere-shaped polymers.20,21 This hydrophilic character, together with the
crosslinking structure inducted by MBA, allowed us to
obtain microspheres nonsoluble in water with a high
capacity for water swelling. Moreover, spherical shape maintenance, after water addition and lyophilization, is additional evidence of the crosslinking process induced by MBA
during polymerization. Depending on the amount of HC
added to each formulation, two different surface morphologies were obtained. The formulations loaded with higher HC
content (M10–25 and M15–25) showed an irregular surface
morphology attributed to a saturation phenomenon of the
HC content inside the microparticle. The addition of 25 wt
% of HC led to materials in which HC could not be totally
absorbed by the microsphere and the excess remained precipitated on the particle’s surface after lyophilization. However, in formulations loaded with lower content of HC
(M10-10 and M15-10), HC was almost completely absorbed
inside the particle as shown in the drug delivery results.
One of the most significant observations of the already
polymerized PMAA microspheres was the high tendency for
particle-particle interactions giving rise to aggregates. This
adhesion capacity has been previously reported in adhesive
materials for dentine defect reparation22 and promotes
aggregation character. The establishment of these aggregates
does not represent a disadvantage to protein delivery, as
the main objective of the work was focused on the design
of a polar system to increase water uptake and act as a carrier of hydrophilic species such as proteins.
The chemical composition of the microspheres and
microparticles was characterized by FTIR. The spectrum of
M15–25 reveals the presence of HC as well as PMAA in the
composition of the PMAA-HC-based microspheres. NAH and
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | MONTH 2014 VOL 00B, ISSUE 00
7
TABLE III. Curing Parameter of Control and Self-Curing
Formulations Loaded with HC
Formulation
PMMA
FC-10
FC-25
FM10
FM15
FM10-10
FM10–25
FM15-10
FM15–25
Tpeak ( C) [s.d]
92.3 [1.1]
85.8[0.6]
75.4 [1.6]
62.0 [0.7]
65.8 [2.4]
64.8 [1.0]
63.4 [0.6]
61.1 [0.7]
67.3 [1.3]
Tsetting (min) [s.d.]
14.4
13.1
13.1
15.1
13.5
14.1
14.8
14.5
13.4
[0.9]
[0.9]
[0.3]
[0.1]
[0.3]
[0.6]
[0.1]
[2.4]
[0.3]
[s.d.]: standard deviation.
C@O symmetric stretching signals at 3300 and 1643 cm21
(Ref. [23), respectively, together with the above-mentioned
signals of PMAA, informs qualitatively about the presence of
both components.
TGA-analysis shows a different degradation process for
PMAA and PMAA-HC microspheres, as expected. Two major
behaviors were observed: (1) High content of char after a
heating rate of 10 C/min and (2) a lower thermal resistance
of the material when modified with collagen. The first
observation corroborates the presence of poly(sodium methacrylate) instead of poly(methacrylic acid), and suggests the
salt nature of the polymer as previously reported.24 The
lower thermal resistance of these formulations is directly
related with the lower thermal resistance of collagen compared with that of the cross-linked matrix of PMAA.
DSC was performed to demonstrate the cross-linked
nature of the microsphere structure. The presence of crosslinking linkage in the structure shifts the glass transition (Tg)
to higher temperatures, even beyond degradation temperature, as an answer to a decrease in the polymer segment
mobility. Brock et al. found that in the case of poly(metha-
FIGURE 6. SEM microphotograph of the surface of the self-curing formulation FM10.
8
ET AL.
FRANCO-MARQUES
crylic acid), the addition of 0.43% of a crosslinking agent
shifts Tg by 7 C (from 178.4 to 185.2 C).25 If the amount of
crosslinker rises to 3%, Tg shifts to 222.2 C. In our case, the
crosslinker (MBA) is added in a range of 10–15 wt %, because
lower quantities led to partially soluble materials. This result,
together with the maintenance of the spherical shape of the
PMAA microsphere after hydration/lyophilization, confirms
the cross-linked structure of the microspheres.
ISO 5833 suggests a maximum peak temperature lower
than 90 C to minimize possible necrotic effects in the surrounding tissue close to the implant. All formulations designed
in this work showed a maximum curing temperature of the
material lower than standard requirements. In fact, the formulations modified with PMAA microspheres showed a peak temperature close to 20 C lower than control formulations
(PMMA, FC-10, and FC-25). The presence of interfaces PMMAPMAA decreases the peak temperature acting as a barrier to
the diffusion of the exothermic polymerization heat from inner
cement to external medium, diminishing the necrotic thermal
risk.12 The formation of such interfaces is demonstrated by
SEM microscopy as shown in Figure 6, where hollows around
PMAA microspheres are formed after curing.
The incorporation of the hydrophilic microparticles did
not produce a significant increase of tsetting, and was, in all
cases, close to 13–14 min. This behavior also helps the surgeon to properly handle the material, prior to vitrification,
before its introduction in the bone cavity or defect.
A compression test was carried out to determine the
mechanical strength of these materials. Other mechanical tests,
such as tensile or bending tests, have also been considered by
researchers to determine the mechanical behavior of the material. In the case of the systems prepared in this work, only the
compression test has been considered as compression is the
most important stress that the material supports after vertebroplasty and kiphoplasty surgery. When the materials were
tested in dry conditions, the formulations modified with
PMAA-microspheres, PMAA-HC-microspheres or even HC powder showed a decrease in compression yield stress, compared
with that of the PMMA control. The formation of the polymer–
polymer interfaces led to a decrease in the mechanical strength
of the material as mentioned above. Additionally, the presence
of HC in the formulation also decreases this mechanical property. This decrease is also attributed to the important difference of molecular weight between HC and PMMA
microparticles: 5103 and 200103 Da, respectively. HC could
be considered a plasticizer of PMMA giving rise to a material
with diminished mechanical properties.
In the case of the formulations modified with the PMAAHC microspheres, the value of rc was close to ISO 5833
standard requirements (70 MPa) and was an acceptable
result considering the high level of chemical structure modification of the cement. Previously, Franco-Marquès et al.
reported an important decrease of mechanical properties of
acrylic bone cements modified with polymer particles not
compatible with PMMA, which is related with the existence
of interphases between PMMA and the modifying polymer.12
In the formulations of this work, the addition of PMAAmicrospheres with a chemical structure close to that of
SELF-CURING HYDROPHILIC BONE CEMENTS FOR PROTEIN DELIVERY
ORIGINAL RESEARCH REPORT
TABLE IV. Compressive Strength of Self-Curing Formulations
Loaded with HC
rc (MPa)
Formulation
PMMA
FC-10
FC-25
FM10
FM15
FM10-10
FM10–25
FM15-10
FM15–25
a
b
a
Dry
82.1
75.2
77.6
74.3
67.4
68.7
66.4
67.0
64.9
[1.5]
[0.8]
[1.9]
[2.7]
[0.8]
[2.6]
[0.9]
[3.0]
[0.6]
Wetb
78.8
71.4
60.5
27.3
29.7
28.7
28.8
29.0
28.8
[1.8]
[1.9]
[0.9]
[3.5]
[1.3]
[1.8]
[1.4]
[1.7]
[1.2]
Before immersion.
After 15 days of immersion in PBS.
PMMA led to a lower loss of material mechanical strength
under dry conditions.
The materials were also tested under wet conditions
after 15 days of immersion in PBS at 37 C. In all cases, a
drastic decrease in strength was observed and was attributed to the hydrophilic character of PMAA. This material is
expected to interact more intensively with external aqueous
media than PMMA, and give rise to a plasticizing behavior
by the incorporation of water. Moreover, the penetration of
the external medium is favored by the polymer–polymer
interfaces, creating a network of micropores to increase
water diffusion inside the material. The average loss of rc
was in the range of 63.3–65.3% without significant differences between the formulations.
The hydrophobic chemical structure of PMMA does not
allow the absorption of water beyond 2–2.5 wt %. In the
cases of FC-10 and FC-25, water uptake was slightly higher
than PMAA cement because of the high solubility of HC in
water at experimental conditions (pH 7.4). The dissolution
of HC led to a porous material where water can diffuse, but
cannot interact by any chemically compatible functionality.
However, the addition of PMAA or PMAA-HC microspheres
induces the absorption and retention of higher amounts of
water due to the higher hydrophilic character and the cross-
FIGURE 7. Water absorption (in vitro behavior) of formulations of
acrylic bone cements modified with PMAA microspheres and PMAAHC microspheres.
FIGURE 8. Controlled delivery profiles of hydrolyzed collagen from
self curing formulations modified with PMAA-HC microspheres.
linked nature of the microspheres. The water interaction is
higher for the formulations FM-10 and FM-25 due to –
COONa hydrophilic groups of PMAA that do not have to
compete with the hydrophilic functionality of HC for water.
Thus, the average of water absorption of FM-xx formulations is in the range of 48–54 wt % and that of FMxx-yy,
loaded with HC, is in the range of 38–50 wt%. This higher
capacity for water retention has been used to improve controlled delivery of HC from the formulations.
In terms of HC delivery, the formulations based on plain
PMMA showed a very low capacity for delivery during a very
short period of time. This behavior suggests a delivery of the
protein closer to the surface of the samples.7,8 A material
with higher hydrophilicity is required to allow water diffusion
inside the specimens, which is the case for materials where
part of the PMMA was substituted by PMAA microspheres.
This hydrophilic polymer drives the external aqueous
medium towards the inner part of the samples, allowing the
dissolution of the protein and its delivery to the surrounding
tissue outside the sample. This behavior involves values of HC
delivery close to 1.6 and 2.7 mg/mL, depending on the initial
composition of HC in the material. Thus, a higher composition
of HC, previously absorbed by the PMAA-microspheres, leads
to higher profiles of release and longer delivery periods.
FM15–25 is able to deliver 2.7 mg/mL of protein for more
than 20 days. No significant influence on the composition of
MBA was observed in the delivery of HC and was only considered as a structural agent to avoid the dissolution of the
PMAA-microspheres in the aqueous media.
The toxicity of the cements formulated with PMAA or
PMAA-HC microspheres is not directly related with the
already polymerized phase, but with the used monomers
MMA, MAA, and MBA. Cell viability shows a minimum value
after 1 day of incubation but a significantly higher value
after the seventh day. In the case of the four formulations
modified with PMAA-HC microspheres, cell viability rises
from the first to seventh incubation day; cell viability in
contact with FM10–25 rises significantly (F1,10 5 7.28;
p < 0.05) from 64.6 6 4.3% to 74.6 6 8.5%. This result suggests a partial toxicity of the residual monomers during the
first hours of incubation that subsequently is diminished
JOURNAL OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS RESEARCH B: APPLIED BIOMATERIALS | MONTH 2014 VOL 00B, ISSUE 00
9
FIGURE 9. MTT results for determination of cell viability in presence
of the extracts of PMMA and curing formulations modified with
PMAA and PMAA-HC microspheres eluted in culture medium. The
diagram includes the mean (n 5 6), the 0.95 confidence interval for
the mean, and the ANOVA results with respect to TMX extracts samples (*p < 0.01, **p < 0.001).
due to the experimental assay where the culture medium is
substituted with fresh medium after proper periods of time.
The same result would be obtained under in vivo conditions
due to the dynamic behavior of fluids in the body. This characterization procedure simulates body behavior where the
body fluid washes the implanted material and removes the
secreted residues. After seven days of incubation, these toxicity levels were within the limits considered by ISO 10993
to determine the cytotoxicity of medical devices (70%).
CONCLUSIONS
Inverse suspension polymerization is a useful polymerization
system for microsphere preparation of hydrophilic polymers for
biomedical purposes. PMAA-based microspheres have been prepared and characterized as an interesting carrier for protein
delivery. PMAA-HC-based microspheres improve protein delivery from two different points of view: increase of protein content delivery to the surrounding tissue and maintenance of its
release during a longer period of time compared with common
formulations of cements. Because of this behavior, a decrease in
compression stress has been found to increase the macromolecule mobility derived from the plastifying effect induced by
absorbed water. Finally, a decrease of cell viability of human
osteoblasts has been obtained as a result of the reacting monomers’ toxicity. This negative reaction is diminished with the
incubation time because of the washing effect related with the
simulated testing technique; the toxicity after the seventh incubation day is within the limits assumed by ISO 10993.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the financial support to MEC-Spain
(MAT2010-18155) and Protein for HC supply. Franco-Marquès
thanks UdG for doctorate grant (BR-07/05).
REFERENCES
1. Charnley J. Anchorage of the femoral head prosthesis to the staft
of the femur. J Bone Jt Surg B 1964;42:28–30.
2. Charnley J. Fracture of femoral prosthesis in total hip replacement. Clin Orthop Rel Res 1975;111:105–120.
10
ET AL.
FRANCO-MARQUES
3. Sweeny WT. Acrylic resins in prosthetic dentistry. Dent Clin North
Am 1958;2:593–601.
zquez B, Deb S, San Roman J. Eugenol derivatives
4. Rojo L, Va
immobilized in auto-polymerizing formulations as an approach to
avoid inhibition interferences and improve biofunctionality in dental and orthopedic cements, Acta Biomaterialia 2009;5:1616–1625.
5. Lopes P, Corbellini M, Ferreira BL, Almeida N, Fredel M,
Fernandes MH, Correia R. New PMMA-co-EHA glass-filled composites for biomedical applications: Mechanical properties and bioactivity. Acta Biomaterialia 2009;5:356–362.
6. Nelson DA, Barker ME, Hamlin, BH. Thermal effects of acrylic
bone cements at bone sites. Int J Hyperthermia 1997;13:287–306.
7. Mendez JA, Fernandez M, Gonzalez-Corchon A, Salvado M, Collia
F, de Pedro JA, Levenfeld BL, Lopez-Bravo A, Vazquez B,San
Roman J. Injectable self-curing bioactive acrylic-glass composites
charged with specific anti-inflammatory/analgesic agent. Biomaterials 2004;25:2381–2392.
8. Mendez JA, Abraham GA, Fernandez MD, Vazquez B, Roman JS.
Self-curing acrylic formulations containing PMMA/PCL composites: Properties and antibiotic release behavior. J Biomed Mater
Res 2002;61:66–74.
E. Anti9. Miola M, Bistolfi A, Valsania MC, Bianco C, Fucale G, Verne
biotic-loaded acrylic bone cements: An in vitro study on the release
mechanism and its efficacy. Mater Sci Eng C 2013;33:3025–3032.
F, Aina V, Gatti S, Cannas M. Effect of vitamin E addition to
10. Reno
poly(D,L)-lactic acid on surface properties and osteoblast behaviour. Biomaterials 2005;26:5594–5599.
11. Mendez JA, Aguilar MR, Abraham GA, Vazquez B, Dalby M, Di
Silvio L, San Roman J. New acrylic bone cements conjugated to
vitamin E: Curing parameters, properties, and biocompatibility.
J Biomed Mater Res 2002;2:299–307.
12. Franco-Marques E, Mendez JA, Girones J, Ginebra MP, Pelach MA.
Evaluation of the influence of the addition of biodegradable polymer matrices in the formulation of self-curing polymer systems for
biomedical purposes. Acta Biomaterialia 2009;5:2953–2962.
13. Caracciolo PC, Sanz Pita C, Abraham GA, Mendez JA, Molera JG. Synthesis, characterization and applications of amphiphilic elastomeric
polyurethane networks in drug delivery. Polym J 2013;45:331–338.
~o
14. Palomino B, Jimenez L, Ferrero A. El dolor lumbar en el an
n 2010;44:69–81.
2009. Rehabilitacio
15. Forriol F. Proteinas morfogenicas oseas y su aplicacion clinica.
~ ola de Cirugia Ortopedica y Traumatologia54, SupRevista Espan
plement 2010;1:2–10.
16. Chen DI, Zhao M, Mundy GR. Bone Morphogenetic Proteins.
Growth Factors 2004;22:233–241.
17. Abdalla MA, Suhaimi F, Das S, Shuid AN, Mohamed Z, Soelaiman
IN. Expression of TGF-B1 in the blood during fracture repair in an
estrogen-deficient rat model. Clinics 2011;66:2113–2119.
18. Kim B, Peppas NA. Analysis of molecular interactions in P(MAAg-EG) hydrogels. Polymer 2003;44:3701–3707.
19. Luginbuehl V, Meinel L, Merkle HP, Gander B. Localized delivery
of growth factors for bone repair. Eur J Pharma Biopharma 2004;
58:197–208.
20. Renard B, McKenna TF. Kinetics of polymerization of partially
neutralized acrylic acid in inverse suspensions. Macromol Symp
2000;150:251–257.
21. Dowding PJ, Vincent B. Suspension polymerization to form polymer
beads. Colloids Surf A Physicochem Eng Asp 2000;161:259–269.
22. Solhi L, Atai M, Nodehi A, Imani M, Ghaemi A, Khosravi K. Poly(acrylic acid) grafted montmorillonite as novel fillers for dental
adhesives: Synthesis, characterization and properties of the adhesive. Dental Mater 2012;28:369–377.
23. Muyonga JH, Cole CGB, Duodu KG. Fourier transform infrared
(FTIR) spectroscopic study of acid soluble collagen and gelatin
from skins and bones of young and adult Nile perch (Lates niloticus). Food Chem 2004;86:325–332.
24. Xue T, Wilkie CA. Thermal degradation of Poly(styrene-g-acrylonitrile). Polym Degrad Stabil 1997;56:109–113.
25. Brock J, Creecy C, McGinity JW, Peppas NA. Synthesis and properties of lightly crosslinked poly((meth)acrylic acid) microparticles
prepared by free radical precipitation polymerization. Polym Bull
2006;17:11–20.
SELF-CURING HYDROPHILIC BONE CEMENTS FOR PROTEIN DELIVERY