Che m ica l a nd m icr obia l qua lit ie s of m or ning a n d e ve ning m ilk colle ct e d
fr om se le ct e d da ir y fa r m s in Chit t a gong Cit y of Ba ngla de sh
S Ak t er 1 , M AA Ga lib 2 , H k a bir 1 , SK N a t h 3 , K Afr in 3 , M S Sa r k e r 4 *
1
Depart m ent of Medicine and Surgery, Chit t agong Vet er inary and Anim al Sciences Universit y ,Chit t agong;
3
Depart m ent of Anim al Science and Nut rit ion; 4 Depar t m ent of Microbiology and Vet er inary Public Healt h,
Chit t agong Vet erinary and Anim al Sciences Universit y , Khulshi 4225, Chit t agong, 2 Depart m ent of Physiology
and Phar m acology, Haj ee Moham m ad Danesh Science and Technology Univer sit y, Dinaj pur, Bangladesh
Abst r a ct
This st udy was undert aken t o evaluat e t he nut rit ional and m icrobiological qualit ies of raw m ilk in t he
Chit t agong Cit y. Eight y sam ples of raw m ilk of cow were collect ed in t he m orning and evening from t he
surrounding farm s of Chit t agong Vet erinary and Anim al Sciences Universit y ( CVASU) , Chit t agong,
Bangladesh. The result s of com posit ional analysis evolved t hat fat , SNF, prot ein, lact ose, specific
gravit y, freezing point and m ineral were ( 3.94± 0.22% ) , ( 7.91± 0.17% ) , ( 3.11± 0.08% ) , ( 4.32± 0.10% ) ,
( 1.026± 0.00) , ( - 0.46± 0.007) , ( 0.68± 0.01% ) , respect ively. The fat % of evening m ilk was significant ly
higher ( p‹ 0.001) t han m orning m ilk. Rest of t he param et ers were not significant . Microbiological
enum erat ion revealed for t he count s of t ot al viable bact eria ( cfu/ m l) and coliform ( cfu/ m l) were
730500± 639 and 280± 1.36 in t he m orning m ilk and 628625± 566 and 326± 1.84 in t he evening m ilk,
respect ively. The result s of t he current st udy indicat ed t hat t he nut rit ional qualit y of evening raw m ilk
was higher t han in t he m orning raw m ilk.
Ke y w or ds: Morning m ilk, evening m ilk, qualit y, Chit t agong Cit y
Bangladesh Anim al Husbandr y Associat ion. All r ight s reser ved.
I n t r odu ct ion
Ba n g. J. An im . Sci. 2 0 1 5 . 4 4 ( 3 ) : 1 7 1 - 1 7 5
Chem ical
and
m icrobiological
analysis
is
an
Milk has been considered as ideal food for hum an
im port ant t ool t o m onit or t he qualit y of dairy
since long before t he recorded hist ory. Milk is
product s.
renowned as an ‘alm ost com plet e’ as well as
spoilage of dairy product s and t o ensure t he
nat ural nut rit ious food for all m am m als including
qualit y of m ilk requires essent ial and higher
hum an being ( Debnat h et al. 2014) . According t o
im port ance
Byron et al. ( 1974) , t he const it uent s of m ilk are
m et hods
wat er ( 87.20% ) , Prot ein ( 3.50% ) , Fat ( 3.70% ) ,
m onit oring, product ion and processing of m ilk.
m ilk sugar or lact ose ( 4.90% ) , ash ( 0.70% ) and
Fresh m ilk considered as a com plet e diet because
Dry m at t er ( 12.80% ) . These com ponent s m ay
it cont ains t he essent ial nut rient s as lact ose, fat ,
fluct uat e by t ype of breed, t ype of feed t hey
prot ein, m ineral and vit am ins in balanced rat io as
consum ed, st age of lact at ion, age of cow, season
com pared
et c and bet ween t he individuals of sam e breed
Yadollahi, 2008) . Cousin ( 1982) st at ed t hat t here
( Ghosh et al. 1965) . Milk is t he m ost desirable
were a lot of sources for bact erial cont am inat ion
food of high biological value and it present s
of m ilk like udder, skin surface, lit t er, floor, flies,
alm ost all ingredient s of food in exact proport ion
insect s and rodent s, wat er supply, m ilker’s hand,
and in any digest ible form . I t is im perat ive t o
ut ensils, at m osphere et c. Oliver et al. ( 2005)
st udy m ilk fat - prot ein rat io ( F/ P) in order t o
revealed t hat m ilk and m ilk product s from raw
assess
m ilk can port a range of m icroorganism s and can
nut rit ion,
nut rient s
conversion
and
Milk
on
have
to
adult erat ion
regulat ory
to
t he
t ake
ot her
can
causes
aspect s.
for
foods
t he
t he
Advanced
analysis,
( Shoj aei
and
m et abolism . The opt im um F/ P rat io is 1.2–1.4
be vit al sources of food borne diseases.
( Vladim ír et al. 2005) . Richardt ( 2004) , confirm s
Public healt h aut horit y is em ployed t he st andards
t hat
dict at es
of m ilk and dairy product s based on Bangladesh
subclinical ket osis whereas t he rat io lower t han
St andards ( BDS) . So it is im port ant t o evaluat e
1.1 t hat suspect ed rum en acidosis.
nut rit ional and m icrobiological qualit y of raw cow
*
t he F/ P rat io
higher
t han
1.5
Corresponding aut hor: sa m u n _ cva su @ya h oo.com
171
Ch e m ica l a n d m icr obia l qu a lit ie s of m ilk
m ilk. Therefore, t he present st udy was carried
colonies from an individual dilut ion was m ult iplied
out in order t o evaluat e t he nut rit ional and
by t he dilut ion fact or t o obt ain t he TVC and t ot al
m icrobial qualit ies of m orning and evening m ilk of
count was expressed as colony form ing unit s per
cow collect ed from t he surrounding farm s of
m illilit er ( cfu / m l) .
CVASU.
Colifor m coun t
M a t e r ia ls a n d M e t hods
The m edium used for coliform was Violet Red Bile
agar ( VRB) . I noculat ed plat es were incubat ed at
Pla ce a n d D u r a t ion
37° C for 24 hours. Then, t ypical pinkish and red
The st udy was carried out
in Dairy
science
Laborat ory belongs t o t he Depart m ent of Dairy
colonies were count ed and t ot al coliform was
calculat ed.
and poult ry Science at Chit t agong Vet erinary and
Anim al Sciences Universit y ( CVASU) , during a
period from
5t h Sept em ber t o 10t h Oct ober
D a t a r e cor din g a n d a n a lysis
SPSS ( Version- 16) st at ist ical soft ware was used
2013.
for
Collect ion of m ilk sa m ple
correlat ion
t he calculat ion of m ean,
coefficient ® ,
st andard error,
t - t est
and significant
value ( p) .
A t ot al num ber of 80 sam ples of raw m ilk were
Re su lt s
collect ed in t he m orning ( 40 sam ples) and in t he
evening ( 40 sam ples) . All t he sam ples were
collect ed
from
surrounding
cam pus
( Jalalabad,
farm s
Foy’s
lake
of
CVASU
area) .
The
nut rit ional and m icrobiological qualit ies of each
sam ple were analyzed. Raw m ilk sam ples were
collect ed from t he bulk sources of fluid raw m ilk
t hrough proper m ixing wit h t he help of plunger
and dipper at m orning and evening from each
farm . Soon aft er collect ion t he sam ples were kept
The average nut rit ional com posit ion of raw m ilk is
shown in Table 1. The fat , SNF, prot ein, lact ose,
specific
gravit y,
of
acid
producing
organism s
point
and
m ineral
cont ent of raw m ilk from different farm s were
3.94± 0.22% ,
4.32± 0.10% ,
7.91± 0.17% ,
1.026± 0.00,
3.11± 0.08% ,
- 0.46± 0.007
and
0.68± 0.01% , respect ively.
Ta ble
1.
Average
nut rit ional
com posit ion
and
t ransport ed t o t he laborat ory.
Param et ers
Mean± SE
M e t h ods for t e st in g r a w m ilk
Fat
3.94± 0.22
SNF
7.91± 0.17
Prot ein
3.11± 0.08
conduct ed. Before analysis each sam ple was pre
Lact ose
4.32± 0. 10
warm ed
Sp. Gravit y
1.026± 0.0008
Freezing point
- 0.46± 0.007
Mineral
0.68± 0.01
The collect ed m ilk sam ples were kept in t he
refrigerat or
at
for
chem ical
40° C
few
unt il
m inut es
propert ies
t he
at
t est s
600° C.
( specific
were
Physio-
gravit y,
fat
percent age, SNF percent age, prot ein percent age,
lact ose percent age, Freezing point and Mineral
percent age)
were
det erm ined
by
of
different farm raw m ilk ( Mean± SE)
int o t he ice box for ceasing t he growt h and
act ivit y
freezing
Lact ost er
N= 80 ( 40 at m orning + 40 at evening)
m achine ( Germ any) .
The
Tot a l Via ble Cou n t ( TVC)
m orning
m ilk
com posit ion
of
fat ,
SNF,
prot ein, lact ose, specific gravit y, freezing point
TVC were done as per recom m endat ion of APHA
( 1967) .
In
brief,
Bact o
agar
was
used
for
enum erat ion of SPC. Each raw m ilk sam ple was
prepared by
t en
fold dilut ion
using pept one
buffered wat er. To det erm ine t he SPC, using
st erile pipet t e t o t ransfer and t o spread of 0.1 m l
of each dilut ion on agar surface. I noculat ed
plat es were incubat ed at 37° C for 48 hours t o
facilit at e viable bact erial growt h. Aft er incubat ion,
t he
172
colonies
were
count ed.
The
num ber
of
and m ineral were 3.12± 0.05% , 7.63± 0.27% ,
2.97± 0.11% ,
4.13± 0.15% ,
1.026± 0.001,
-
0.45± 0.009 0.69± 0.01% , respect ively ( Table 2) .
On t he ot her hand, t he evening m ilk com posit ion
of fat , SNF, prot ein, lact ose, specific gravit y,
freezing point and m ineral were 4.75± 0.11% ,
8.19± 0.17% ,
3.25± 0.08% ,
4.50± 0.10% ,
1.027± 0.0009, - 0.47± 0.007 and 0.67± 0.02% ,
respect ively ( Table 2) . I n t he m orning m ilk, TVC
and
Coliform
count
were
730500± 639
and
Ak t e r e l a l. ( 2 0 1 5 ) Ba ng. J. Am in . Sci. 4 4 ( 3 ) : 1 7 1 - 1 7 5
280± 1.36, respect ively. But in t he evening m ilk it
prot ein rat ion of m orning and evening m ilk were
was 628625± 566 and 326± 1.84 ( Table 3) . Fat
1.05 and 1.46, respect ively ( Table 4) .
Ta ble 2 . Nut rit ional com posit ion of m orning and evening raw m ilk of different farm
Morning
Fat
SNF
Prot ein
Lact ose
Sp. Gravit y
F. point
Mineral
3.12± 0.05
7.63± 0.27
2.97± 0.11
4.13± 0.15
1.026± 0.001 - 0.45± 0.009
0.69± 0.01
4.75± 0.11
8.19± 0.17
3.25± 0.08
4.50± 0.10
1.027± 0.001 - 0.47± 0.007
0.67± 0.02
0.001
0.159
0.069
0.87
0.507
0.20
m ilking
Evening
m ilking
Significant
0.112
value
N= 80 ( 40 at m orning + 40 at evening)
Ta ble 3 . Microbial qualit y of different farm raw m ilk
TVC ( CFU/ m l)
Coliform ( CFU/ m l)
Morning m ilking
730500± 639
280± 1.36
Evening m ilking
628625± 566
326± 1.84
Significant value
0.150
0.082
N= 80 ( 40 at m orning + 40 at evening)
Ta ble 4 . Fat - prot ein rat io of m ilk
Morning m ilk
Fat
Prot ein
Fat - prot ein rat io
3.12
2.97
1.05
Evening m ilk
4.75
3.25
1.46
Morning and evening m ilk
3.94
3.11
1.26
D iscu ssion
3.80% prot ein and 4.80% lact ose. This variat ion
m ay be due t o t he variat ion of breed. The
Ph ysicoch em ica l pr oper t ie s
The average fat percent age of farm m ilk was
found t o be 3.94± 0.22% , which was support ed
by Debnat h et al. ( 2009) who dem onst rat ed t hat
t he but t er fat of m ilk from different sources from
Chit t agong m et ropolit an area varied from 3.52 t o
4.01. Judkins and Keener ( 1960) report ed t hat
t he average fat % of m ilk sam ple was 2.5 t o
8.0% . The st udy indicat ed t hat t he average SNF
cont ent of farm m ilk was 7.91± 0.17% , which was
slight ly lower t han t he findings of Debnat h et al.
( 2009)
who report ed
t hat
SNF%
from
farm
produced m ilk, vendor supplied farm m ilk, vendor
supplied rural m ilk and brand m arket m ilk were
8.33,
7.98,
7.85,
8.2% ,
respect ively
in
Chit t agong m et ropolit an area. The slight ly lower
SNF value m ight be due t o sm aller sam ple size.
I n t he present st udy, t he average prot ein and
lact ose cont ent of farm m ilk were 3.11± 0.08%
and
4.32± 0.10% ,
respect ively.
These
values
were lower t han t he values of Eckles et al.
( 1951) , dem onst rat ed t hat m ilk should cont ain
average
specific
gravit y
of
farm
m ilk
was
1.026± 0.00, which was support ed by Eckles et al.
( 1951) , I slam et al. ( 1993) and Debnat h et al.
( 2009) . The average freezing point and m ineral
cont ent
of farm
m ilk were - 0.46± 0.007 and
0.68± 0.01% , respect ively. According t o Eckles et
al. ( 1951) , m ilk should cont ain 0.65 % m inerals
and t he current st udy agreed wit h his finding.
The average fat percent age of evening m ilk was
significant ly ( P < 0.05) higher t han t he m orning
m ilk. I t was support ed by I qbal et al. ( 2005) . The
average SNF, prot ein, lact ose, specific gravit y,
freezing point and m ineral percent age of evening
m ilk was not significant ly ( p > 0.05) higher t han
t he m orning m ilk. This st udy was support ed by
I qbal et al. ( 2005) .
M icr obia l qua lit y
The
average
TVC
count
of
m orning
m ilk
( 730500± 639) was not significant ly higher t han
t he evening m ilk ( 628625± 566) ( Table 3) . The
result s of t his st udy correlat ed wit h t he findings
173
Ch e m ica l a n d m icr obia l qu a lit ie s of m ilk
of I knom ov et al. ( 1956) who report ed t hat t he
hazardous product which is likely t o be posing a
t ot al bact erial count s ranged from 1, 25,000 t o
serious healt h risk t o t he consum ers. Fat prot ein
9,000,000 per m l of m ilk depending on m ilking
rat io was in accept able range. Evening m ilk was
t echniques
of
found superior t han m orning m ilk due t o high
m ilk
was 100-
chem ical com posit ion. The governm ent t herefore
infect ion
occurred
and
cleanliness.
bact eria in asept ically
92,000
per
m l,
The
drawn
but
num ber
should
conduct
frequent
inspect ion
of
t he
subsequent ly from t he skin of anim als, m ilker’s
m arket ed m ilks t o check whet her t hey m eet t he
hand, cow shed and m ilking ut ensils. Lee et al.
m inim um legal st andards and should m onit or t he
( 1983) conduct ed an experim ent in Seoul of
overall
Korea and found t hat t he bact erial count in raw
product ion
m ilk ranged from 4 × 106 t o 2.7 × 107 per m l.
st andards for t he raw m ilks need t o be devised
This result indicat ed t hat t he average coliform
and appropriat e t raining should be given t o t he
count
raw m ilk producers in hygienic handling of m ilk.
of
m orning
m ilk
was lower
t han
t he
hygienic
condit ion
and
handling
surrounding
of
m ilk.
t he
Realist ic
evening m ilk but not st at ist ically significant . The
Ack now le dge m e n t s
variat ion in coliform count of t he m ilk m ay be due
t o t he hygienic m aint enance during m ilking. The
result s of t his invest igat ion were in agreem ent
wit h t he finding of Mut ukum ira et al. ( 1996) , who
found t he coliform bact eria was 326 t o 240 per
m l. Sait anu et
al. ( 1996)
experim ent ed and
Aut hors are grat eful t o t he academ ician and
st uffs
of
Depart m ent
of
Dairy and Poult ry
Science ( CVASU) and Owner of t he respect ed
farm s.
revealed t hat t he t ot al coliform count was of
Re fe r e n ce s
< 1000 CFU/ m l.
Am erican
Fa t - pr ot ein r a t io
Public
( 1967) .
Healt h
St andard
Associat ion
m et hods
( APHA)
for
t he
exam inat ion of dairy product s. Am erican
The
fat - prot ein
evening
m ilk
( F/ P)
was
rat io
of
1.26.
m orning
Richardt
and
Public Healt h Associat ion. I nc. 12t h Edn.
( 2004)
m easured t he F/ P rat io as an im port ant point er of
New York. P. 90 - 110.
Byron
HW,
Arnold
HJ,
Johan
AA
( 1974) .
anim al healt h. I t s value above 1.5 in dairy cows
Fundam ent als of dairy chem ist ry. 2nd Edn.
indicat ed
West port , Connect icut . The Avi Publishing
a
1.5
t im es
m ore
probabilit y
of
incidence of m ast it is, 7.5 t im es t endency t o
lam eness
and
3.5
t im es
m ore
incidence
to
Com pany, I nc. P. 2- 8.
Cousin
MA ( 1982) .
Presence and
act ivit y
of
ket osis. Vladim ir et al. ( 2005) dict at ed t hat t he
psychrot rophic m icroorganism s in m ilk and
proper F/ P rat io for Holst ein cows is 1.05 - 1.18.
dairy product s. Journal Food Prot ein. 45:
High values in t he first phase suggest ed a great
172- 207.
energy deficiency. Haas et al. ( 2004) included
Debnat h GK, Kober AKMH, Chanda GC ( 2009) .
t hat t he opt im um F/ P rat io is 1.2–1.4. Low values
Qualit y of Fluid Milk Available in Chit t agong
are prone t o subclinical rum en acidosis which can
Met ropolit an Area, proceedings of t he sixt h
put in danger t he reproduct ive perform ance of
annual
cows
Bangladesh. P.178- 182
and
increase
a
possible
expansion
of
scient ific
conference
of
CVASU,
disorders of m ineral m et abolism . The F/ P rat io
Debnat h GK, Kober AKMH, Chanda T, Chanda
higher t han 1.4 indicat ed t he sign of energy
GC, Bari MSA ( 2014) . Com parat ive St udy on
deficit and if ket one bodies are present , lead t o
t he Qualit y of Available Brand and Non
subclinical ket osis. The current st udy agreed wit h
Brand Fluid Milk Consum ed by t he People of
t his range.
Chit t agong Cit y of Bangladesh. I nt ernat ional
Journal of Nat ural Sciences, 4( 1) : 16- 20.
Con clu sion
Eckles C, Com bs C, Macy H ( 1951) . Milk and m ilk
Result s of t his st udy showed t he chem ical and
product s
m icrobial qualit ies of m ilk from different local
com pany, New York, Toront o, London. P.
farm s. The presence of bact erial populat ion in
raw m ilk indicat es defect during collect ion and
processing
of
m ilk.
The
presence
of
coliform s in m ilk are indicat ive of a pot ent ially
174
Edn.
Mcgraw- Hill
book
22- 23.
Ghosh SN, Krishnan CPA ( 1965) . I ndian Journal
t he
pat hogenic organism s and t he high count s of
4t h
of Dairy Science, 17: 190.
Haas
D,
Hofírek
B
( 2004) .
The
diagnost ic
im port ance of m ilk com ponent s for a hum an
Ak t e r e l a l. ( 2 0 1 5 ) Ba ng. J. Am in . Sci. 4 4 ( 3 ) : 1 7 1 - 1 7 5
and cow’s healt h. ( I n Czech) CUA Prague,
SP,
Jayarao BM,
Alm eida RA ( 2005) .
Foodborne pat hogens in m ilk and t he dairy
– 29.
farm environm ent : food safet y and public
I konom ov L, Lot ov I , Todorov D, Tankov G,
Dzhurov TS ( 1956) . Bact eriological st udies
of Hygiene of m ilk product ion of Bulgarian
cat t le
Breeding
Farm s.
SA,
Mido
Discovery
Y
healt h
im plicat ions.
Foodborne
Pat hogen
and Diseases 2 ( 2) : 115- 29.
Richardt
W
( 2004) .
Milk
com posit ion
as
an
Science
indicat or of nut rit ion and healt h. ( I n Czech)
Chem ist ry.
Sait anu I A, Chuanchuen KR, Nuanuarsuwan S,
Dairy
The Breeding. P. 26 –27.
Abst ract 19: 936.
I qbal
Oliver
Proceedings of cont ribut ions: Milk day. P. 26
( 2005) .
Publishing
Food
House,
New
Delhi,
Koowat ananukul C and Rugkhaw V ( 1996) .
Microbiological qualit y of raw cow m ilk. Thai
I ndia.
I slam MN, Hussain SMI , Mannan AKMA ( 1993) .
St udies on t he physical param et ers and
chem ical
qualit ies
of
m arket
m ilk
in
Journal of Vet erinary Medicine 26( 3) : 193214.
Shoj aei ZA, Yadollahi A ( 2008) . Physicochem ical
Mym ensingh t own ( Bangladesh) . Banglasesh
and
j ournal of Anim al Science. 13: 52.
Past eurized and UHT Milks in Shops. Asian
Judkins HF, Keener HA ( 1960) . Milk product ion
and processing. 4t h Edn, New York. P. 227-
Microbiological
Qualit y
of
Raw
Journal of Scient ific Research. 1: 532- 538.
Vladimír ČEJNA, Gustav CHLÁDEK (2005) . The
im port ance of m onit oring changes in m ilk
230.
Lee JT, Park SY, Korea I K, Kin HU ( 1983) . Qualit y
fat t o m ilk prot ein rat io in Holst ein cows
of raw m ilk in Korea. Korean Journal of
during
Dairy Science. 5 ( 1) : 22- 28.
Breeding, Mendel Universit y of Agricult ure
Mut ukum ira
AN,
Abraham sen
Feresu
RK
SB,
( 1996) .
Narbhus
JA,
Chem ical
and
lact at ion,
Depart m ent
of
Anim al
and Forestry in Brno, Zemědělská 1, 613 00
Brno, Czech Republic.
Microbiological Qualit y of raw m ilk produced
by
sm all
holder
farm ers
in
Zim babwe.
Journal of Food Prot ect ion. 59 ( 9) : 984- 987.
175