Rus chronicles as sources of international law

vol. 27 • 2022 • • Neighborhood and Consent Historiography and memory vol. 27 • 2022 Neighborhood and Consent Historiography and memory !"#$%&'% &HQWUXP%DGDĸ+LVWRU\F]Q\FK Warszawa 2022 !"#$%&'()$%*+$,''*#$-'*)(-#$ -RXUQDOHGLWHGE\ :RMFLHFK)DãNRZVNL :DUVDZ ²(GLWRULQ&KLHI :LHVãDZ'ãXJRNĕFNL *GDĸVN 7RPDV]-DVLĸVNL 3R]QDĸ $QGU]HM3OHV]F]\ĸVNL /XEOLQ $QGU]HM5DG]LPLĸVNL 7RUXĸ 6WDQLVãDZ5RVLN :URFãDZ  3DZHã'HUHFNL :DUVDZ ²$VVLVWDQW(GLWRU 7RPDV]3HãHFK :DUVDZ ²$VVLVWDQW(GLWRU (GLWRULDO%RDUG *HUG$OWKRII 0QVWHU 3KLOLSSH%XF :LHQ 3DWULFN*HDU\ 3ULQFHWRQ <YHV6DVVLHU 3DULV 5HYLHZHUV 0DWHXV]*ROLĸVNL$OHNVDQGHU3DURĸ3LRWU5RV]DN/HV]HN36ãXSHFNL 3URRIUHDGLQJ )HOL[%LHUPDQQ$QJHOD'HOLFKDWVLRV'DYLG+DUUROG*UHJRU\/HLJKWRQ6DUD(OLQ5REHUWV -RXUQDODFFHSWHGLQWKH(5,+3/86OLVW $UWLFOHV1RWHVDQG%RRNVIRU5HYLHZVKRXOGEHVHQWWR ´4XDHVWLRQHV0HGLL$HYL1RYDHµ)XQGDFMD&HQWUXP%DGDĸ+LVWRU\F]Q\FK .UDNRZVNLH3U]HGPLHŋFLH3/:DUV]DZD HPDLOUHGDNFMD#TPDQFRPSO ZZZTPDQFRPSO 3XEOLVKHGDQGILQDQFHGE\ .DFXOW\RI+LVWRU\8QLYHUVLW\RI*GDĸVN ,QVWLWXWHRI+LVWRU\8QLYHUVLW\RI6]F]HFLQ ,QVWLWXWHRI+LVWRU\8QLYHUVLW\RI:URFãDZ &HQWHURI+LVWRULFDO5HVHDUFK)RXQGDWLRQ ‹&RS\ULJKWE\&HQWHURI+LVWRULFDO5HVHDUFK)RXQGDWLRQ ,661 3ULQWHGLQ3RODQG 6XEVFULSWLRQV3XEOLVKHGLQ'HFHPEHU7KHDQQXDOVXEVFULSWLRQVUDWHLV LQ3RODQG]ãLQ(XURSH(85LQRYHUVHDVFRXQWULHV(85 6XEVFULSWLRQVRUGHUVVKRXGEHDGGUHVVHGWR &HQWHURI+LVWRULFDO5HVHDUFK)RXQGDWLRQ XO.UDNRZVNLH3U]HGPLHŋFLH3/:DUV]DZDHPDLOUHGDNFMD#TPDQFRPSO ZZZTPDQFRPSO &LWL+DQGORZ\:DUV]DZDXO6HQDWRUVND $FFRXQW 3ULQW ,%,6:URFãDZ LELV#LELVFRPSO WHO !"#$%#$& ,1HLJKERUKRRGDQG&RQVHQW                                          *XLGR9DQQLQL )URQWLHUVDUHQRWERUGHUV                                         5DIDã6LPLĸVNL 'LH*UHQ]H]ZLVFKHQGHP+HU]RJWXP3RPPHUQXQGGHU 'HXWVFKRUGHQVKHUUVFKDIWLQ3UHX‰HQLQGHQ-DKUHQ² (QWVWHKXQJ(QWZLFNOXQJ.RQIOLNWH                          $GDP6]ZHGD 'LSORPDF\RIWKHZHDNHUSDUWQHUV'XFDO0DVRYLDDQGWKH7HXWRQLF 2UGHUDIWHUWKH6HFRQG3HDFHRI7RUXĸ                     -DURVãDZ1LNRGHP 5HIOHFWLRQVRQWKH3ROLVK/LWKXDQLDQ8QLRQ                         2QWKHPDUJLQRI5REHUW)URVW·VERRN!"#$%&'()*$+,-.()/$('$0(123*4 5,."623,27$8(169#$:;$!"#$<2=,3>$('$."#$0(1,-"45,."623,23$?3,(37$@ABC4 @CDE2[IRUG                                                 ,,+LVWRULRJUDSK\DQG0HPRU\                                         $GULDQ-XVXSRYLþ 5XVFKURQLFOHVDVVRXUFHVRILQWHUQDWLRQDOODZ                        0LFKDã*QLDGHN=LHOLĸVNL ´3ULPRWHPSRUHµ²DOPRVWORVWFKURQLFOHE\ELVKRS(VNLO"7KHDWWHPSW RIDQHZUHDGLQJRIWKHRULJLQVRI'DQLVKKLVWRULRJUDSK\          -RDQQD6RELHVLDN %HWZHHQWZR(PSHURUV2QWKHH[FHVVHVRIWKHSROLWLFDOVXFFHVV* RI%RKHPLDQNLQJ9ODGLVODY,,                         :DZU]\QLHF.RZDOVNL %RUGHUVUREEHUVDQGWKH6ODYVLQ+,-.(),2$F21(3,.232$DQGLQ$!"#$G")(3,H1#$ ('$."#$0),#-.$('$I6=1J2K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$K$ $ ,,,&XUUHQW5HVHDUFK                                                  5REHUW*RF]Dã +LVWRULFDORXWOLQHRIMXVWZDUWKHRU\DQGLWVIXQGDPHQWDODVVXPSWLRQV LQPHGLHYDODQGODWHUHQDLVVDQFHWKRXJKW 6W$XJXVWLQH RI+LSSR6W7KRPDV$TXLQDV)UDQFLV6XiUH]6W5REHUW* %HOODUPLQH                                                  3LRWU%RURĸ(ZHOLQD,PLRãF]\N0DU]HQD.ãXVHN1DWDOLD3LRWURZVND $MXGJH·VVWDIIIURPWKHPDUNHWVTXDUHLQ%\WRP²DV\PEROLFHOHPHQW RIPHGLHYDOOHJDOFXOWXUH                                     -DNXE-DXHUQLJ /LRQVRI,OLRQDQG/LRQVRI$OELRQ7KH7URMDQP\WKLQ(QJOLVKKHUDOGU\ RIWKHWKFHQWXU\                                           ,9$QQRXQFHPHQWV                                                   -XOLXV]'RPDĸVNL =HQRQ.DãXŧDDZDUGHGWKH56&$#.$526-PHGDO                        ,9%RRN1RWLFHV                                                      ''()+'&$"-'"*-/5+B) /#.) 3%3"-B !"#$%&'()*%&+,%-((+$%.(+*).$%/ 01+2030045+SS=+77197>> (&&*6+78019887: %9(&&*6+01039;<78 -)(6+73=;1<>0?",$*=0300=01=3; $'5,$1-868329,ý 7+(7$'(86=0$17(8))(/,167,787(2)+,6725<32/,6+$&$'(0<2)6&,(1&(6 (J","4%'#72#34()1*$"14A 3--4,566%+7#$1%+!6&88889888:9;;=I9888: -4&) !+-"#'!A%&) /&) &"4-!%&) "0) '#$%-#/$'"#/A) A/2 ,Q7LPRIH\9*LPRQSXEOLVKHGDQDUWLFOHHQWLWOHG´:KDW (YHQWVZHUH5HSRUWHGE\WKH2OG5XV&KURQLFOH"µ/$FFRUG LQJWRKLVVWXG\SROLWLFDODQGPLOLWDU\HYHQWVPDNHXS RIWKH0),92)/$G")(3,H1# IURPWR RIWKH+/N24 .,23$G")(3,H1# IURPWR RIWKH526)#3.,23$G")(3,4 H1# IURPWR DQGRIWKHU,)-.$a(Y>()(*,23$G")(3,H1# V\QRGDO 06IURPWR +HVHSDUDWHGSROLWLFDODQGPLOLWDU\HYHQWVIURPHYHQWV DPRQJSULQFHO\IDPLOLHVZKLFKPDNHXSRIWKH0),92)/$G")(3,H1# RIWKH+/N2.,23$G")(3,H1#RIWKH526)#3.,23$G")(3,H1#DQGRIWKHU,)-.$ a(Y>()(*,23$ G")(3,H1# +H DOVR GLVWLQJXLVKHG WKHVH HYHQWV IURP FKDQJHV LQHFFOHVLDVWLFDOKLHUDUFKVZKLFKIRUPRIWKH0),92)/$G")(3,H1# RIWKH+/N2.,23$G")(3,H1#RIWKH526)#3.,23$G")(3,H1#DQGRIWKHU,)-.$ a(Y>()(*,23$G")(3,H1#$VLPLODUGLVWLQFWLRQLVPDGHIRUFKDQJHVLQFLW\PDJ () *79*LPRQ["2.$XY#3.-$P#)#$W#N().#*$O/$."#$%1*$W6-T$G")(3,H1#µ6WXGLHVDFURVV'LVFL SOLQHLQWKH+XPDQLWLHVDQG6RFLDO6FLHQFHVµ;9,,  SS>RSHQDFFHVVKWWSVFRUH DFXNGRZQORDGSGISGI@ 7%4?+#!3-&@?&7*)-*+&%/&3#,-%+#7(A&+*,*(+73&/%")$(-#%)&BC8CCD %%# $'5,$1-868329,ý LVWUDWHVVXFKDVWKHN(-2*3,=VDQGWKH./-,2.-=/VWKHODWWHULVQRWPHQWLRQHG LQWKH0),92)/$G")(3,H1#7$WKH$+/N2.,23$G")(3,H1#RUWKH526)#3.,23$G")(3,H1# EXWFRQVWLWXWHVRIWKHU,)-.$a(Y>()(*,23$G")(3,H1#$OOWKHVHFDWHJRULHVDUH UHODWHGWRWKHSROLWLFDOOLIHRI5XV:HVHHWKDWDVPXFKDVRIWKHQDUUD WLYHRIHDFKFKURQLFOHLVGHGLFDWHGWRSROLWLFDOLVVXHV7KHUHVXOWVRI*LPRQ·V DQDO\VLVVKRXOGQRWEHVXUSULVLQJ7KHILUVWVHQWHQFHLQWKH0),92)/$G")(3,H1#* LVDVIROORZV´7KHVHDUHWKHQDUUDWLYHVRIE\JRQH\HDUVUHJDUGLQJWKHRULJLQ RIWKHODQGRI5XVWKHILUVWSULQFHVRI.LHYDQGIURPZKDWVRXUFHWKHODQG RI5XVKDGLWVEHJLQQLQJµ07KHQDUUDWLYHVWUDWHJ\RIPHGLHYDOERRNPHQZDV VLPSO\WRSUHSDUHDKLVWRULFDOFROOHFWLRQWKDWZRXOGGHVFULEHWKHSROLWLFDOV\V WHPDQGVXFFHVVRI5XV 7KHSUREOHPRIDQQDOVDVTXDVLOHJDOGRFXPHQWVKDVEHHQGLVFXVVHGLQOLW HUDWXUHEXWQHYHULQFRPSOHWHIRUP:HKDYHRQO\VRPHPLQRUFRQWULEXWLRQV  *0(-2*3,=7KHWHUPFRPHVIURPWKHZRUG´SRVDGLWLµZLWKWKHPHDQLQJ´WRDSSRLQWµ ´WR QRPLQDWHµ ´WR DVVLJQµ %\ WKH UXOHU·V PDQGDWH WKH N(-2*3,=$ H[HUFLVHG DGPLQLVWUDWLYH PLOLWDU\ILVFDODQGMXGLFLDODXWKRULW\RYHUDVSHFLILFWHUULWRU\ZLWKLWVKHDGTXDUWHUVEDVHG LQD>)(*WRZQFHQWUH LPSOLFLWO\VPDOOHU>)(*$XQLWVDVZHOODVHQWLUHODQGVSURYLQFHV 7KLV FRXQVHOOLQJLQVWLWXWLRQZDVVHWXSWRVWUHDPOLQHWKHWHUULWRULDOPDQDJHPHQWRIWKHVWDWHDQG EHORQJHGJHQHWLFDOO\WRWKHLQVWLWXWLRQVRIWKHHDUO\IHXGDOPRQDUFK\KHQFHLQWKHWKFHQWXU\ WKHN(-2*3,=$GLGQRWRIILFLDWHLQWKHFDSLWDOFLWLHVZKHUHZHZRXOGHQFRXQWHUKLJKUDQNLQJ RIILFLDOV #K>WKH./-,2.-=/WKHYRLYRGH ²ZLWKLPSRUWDQWEXWQRWVRXQLYHUVDOFRPSHWHQFHV ²GLUHFWO\DWWDFKHGWRWKHSULQFH$ORQJZLWKSURJUHVVLQJUHJLRQDOIUDJPHQWDWLRQWKHSUROLI HUDWLRQRIWKHUR\DOG\QDVW\DQGWKHLQGHSHQGHQFHRIDQLQFUHDVLQJQXPEHUVRISULQFLSDOLWLHV WKHFRXQVHOOLQJLQVWLWXWLRQEHJDQWRZDQHLQLPSRUWDQFHXOWLPDWHO\GLVDSSHDULQJLQWKHWK* FHQWXU\)RUWKHHIIHFWLYHH[HUFLVLQJRIKLVRIILFHWKHN(-2*3,=$KDGDWKLVGLVSRVDODQDSSD UDWXVRIVXERUGLQDWHRIILFLDOV #K>WLYXQVGHWVN\VHWF +HDOVRSHUIRUPHGSROLFHDQGILV FDOIXQFWLRQV WD[FROOHFWRU ,QOLWHUDU\PRQXPHQWVWKHN(-2*3,=$LVUHIHUUHGWRDV´ҧӁҤӈӊҬӁӜ ҨӇҤҫҤµ´ӈӊҤӇҬҸӘҸӃҤҨӇҤҫӋµ´ҨӇҤҫӃҸҼҤӂµ6HH$3RSSH0(-2*3,=LQ6ãRZQLN6WDURŧ\WQRŋFL 6ãRZLDĸVNLFKYRO,9HG*/DEXGD=6WLHEHU:URFãDZ:DUV]DZD.UDNyZSS VHHKHUHLQIRUOLWHUDWXUH  *) *7\VLDWVN\ ӊӛӈӠӔҼҸҹӊӛӈӠӕӈҼҸҹ ,QWKHWKFHQWXU\WKLVZDVWKHJRYHUQRUFRPPDQG HURIWKHW\VLDFKL WKRXVDQG RIDWHUULWRULDOXQLW #K>ZHKDYHW\VLDFKLLQ3U]HP\ŋOLQ.LHYHWF  7\VLDWVN\ZDVDQRIILFLDOZLWKDQDGPLQLVWUDWLYHDQGVRPHWLPHVPLOLWDU\IXQFWLRQ,Q!"#$G")(3,4 H1#$('$+21/H"48(1"/3,2$WKLVWHUPZDVXVHGWKLUWHHQWLPHV ZHNQRZRIVXFKW\VLDWVN\DV<DUXQ 'PLWU\ 'HPLDQ HWF  ,Q QDUUDWLYH VRXUFHV VRPHWLPHV W\VLDWVN\ LV UHIHUUHG WR DV YRLYRGH LQWKHPHDQLQJRI´FRPPDQGHURIIRUFHVµ 6HH$-XVXSRYLþ(OLW\]LHPLKDOLFNLHMLZRã\ĸVNLHM P$ HV2-2H"$ W(923(P,HVyP$ c@`]C^@`DEdK$ F.6*,69$ N)(V(N(>)2',HV3# .UDNyZ   0RQRJUDILH 3UDFRZQL%DGDĸQDG']LHMDPL5XVL8QLZHUV\WHWX.D]LPLHU]D:LHONLHJRZ %\GJRV]F]\,,  SS²²²²²² +) *!"#$W6--,23$0),92)/$H")(3,H1#;$526)#3.,23$.#&.WUDQVODQGHG6+D]]DUG&URVV236KHU ERZLW]:HW]RU&DPEULGJH0DVVDFKXVHWWVS´ѺҬѸӅҧӬӈӊҸҧӇҬӂӠӃӜӃӛӒӚӁӬӊӚӅӊҼӋҫӋ ҬӈӊӜӆӅӘӁҤӇӋӈҼҤӠҶҬӂӁӠҼӊӅҧӚѮҸҬҧӬӃҤӕҤӆҬӇҧӬҬҼӃӠҰҸӊҸҸӅӊҼӋҫӋӇӋӈҼҤӠҶҬӂӁӠӈӊҤӊ ҬӈӊӜµ/ҤYUҬQW·ҬYVNҤLDOҬWӅSLV·LQ3ROQRH6REUDQLH5XVVNLNK/HWRSLVHǩYRO,0RVFRZFRO ,) *7*LPRQ+,-.(),H21$[),.,3>$('$X2)1/$W6-$cHK$@]]]4HK$@p]]d$,3$2$H(9N2)2.,Y#$N#)-N#H.,Y# /HLGHQ%RVWRQSS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ  +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %%$ WRWKLVWRSLFVXFKDXWKRUVDVIRUH[DPSOH,'%HOLDHY0,6XNKRPOLQRY* 11,DQLVK/9&KHUHSQLQDQGDVKRUWPHQWLRQLQ0.K$OHVKNRYVNLL* :HKDYHVRPHH[DPSOHVZKHUHVHOHFWHGSULQFHO\GRFXPHQWVZHUHDGGHGWR WKHDQQDOVLQH[WHQVR #K>WZRGRFXPHQWVLVVXHGE\9RORGLPLU9DVLONRYLFK//* DQGDOVRPRVWIDPRXVO\WKHWUHDWLHVRIDQGEHWZHHQ5XVDQG%\]DQWLXP  ,OLD0DLDNRYVNLLLQDERRNGHGLFDWHGWRWKHKLVWRU\RIDUFKLYHVLQ5XVVLDZURWH WKDW´GRFXPHQWVVHOHFWHGE\WKHSULQFHZHUHLQFOXGHGLQWRWKHDQQDOVLPPHGL DWHO\DIWHUWKHLULVVXLQJµ6LPRQ)UDQNOLQDUJXHGWKDW5XVFKURQLFOHVZHUHQRW SXUHO\OHJDOEXWTXDVLMXULGLFDOWH[WV´WKH5XVVLDQFKURQLFOHVDUHLQWKHPVHOYHV OHJDOGRFXPHQWVRIDNLQG7KH\DUHPRVWO\FXPXODWLYHDQQDOVFRPSLOHGIURP SUHYLRXVDQQDOVZLWKWKHDGGLWLRQRIUHFHQWHYHQWVQRWHG\HDUE\\HDU7KH\WKXV FRQVWLWXWHWKHRQO\IRUPRIFXPXODWLYHUHFRUGHLWKHUH[WDQWRUUHIHUUHGWRLQHDUO\ PHGLHYDO5XVVLDµ'PLWULL6/LNKDFKHYDOVRGUDZVDWWHQWLRQWRWKHSRVVLELOLW\ WKDWWKHYHU\DFWRIWKHFUHDWLQJRIDQHZDQQDOLVWLFWH[WKDGDGHJUHHRIOHJDO VLJQLILFDQFH/0$V7*LPRQKLJKOLJKWHG´WKHDQQDOVWKHPVHOYHVZHUHUHJDUGHG DVDPHDQVRISUHVHUYDWLRQRIMXULGLFDOO\VLJQLILFDQWLQIRUPDWLRQ·>«@KLVWRULFDO DQGMXGLFLDOWH[WVFRXOGEHWUDQVFULEHGVHSDUDWHO\EXWEHLQFOXGHGLQWRWKHVDPH PDQXVFULSWVµ:HGLVSRVHRYHUDVPDOOQXPEHURIZRUNVZKLFKWU\WRUHFRQ VWUXFWDSULQFHO\DUFKLYHLQFOXGLQJ1#.(N,-,EXWQRQHRIWKHPWULHGWRSUHSDUH DFRPSOHWHOLVWRIOHJDORU¶TXDVLOHJDO·DVSHFWVZLWKLQ5XVFKURQLFOHV 7KLVWH[WLVRQO\DVPDOOFRQWULEXWLRQWRWKHH[LVWLQJZRUNVDQGSURSRVHV DVOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQWYLHZLQJRIWKH5XV&KURQLFOHVOHWRSLVL2QHRIWKHTXHV WLRQVZHZRXOGOLNHWRSRVHLVKRZWKHVHOHJDOFROOHFWLRQVZHUHSHUFHLYHG E\WKHSHRSOHRIWKHLUWLPH"  *,'%HOLDHY)%$)2V3/="$Y,*2="$)6--=,="$1#.(N,-#,´9UHPHQQLN0RVNRYVNRJRREVKFKHVWYD LVWRULLLGUHYQRVWHLURVVLLVNLNKµ  SS  *0,)6XNKRPOLQRY$%*)#Y3#,$)6--=(,$1#.(N,-,$=2=$N29,2.3,=#$1,.#)2.6)3(9´8FKHQ\H]DSLVNL JRRWGHOHQLLD,PSHUDWRUVNRL$NDGHPLLQDXNµ,,,  SS  *11,DQLVK$a(Y>()(*-=2,2$1#.(N,-T$,$##$9(-=(Y-=,#$N#)#*#1=,$0RVFRZS  */9&KHUHSQLQW6--=2,2$,-.(),(>)2',,2$*($b:b$YK;$g6)-$1#=.-,,0RVFRZSS  *0.K$OHVKNRYVNLǩ0(Y#-.T$Y)#9#33/="$1#.;$:V$,-.(),,$-(V*23,,2$,$)#*2=.-,(33(,$N#)#)2O(.=, HG)%8VSHQVNLǩ0RVFRZSS (() *G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232K$G")(3,H2$W(923(Y,H,2327$HG''ćEURZVNL$-XVXSRYLþ* 03+7$ 61 YRO ;9, .UDNyZ²:DUV]DZD SS  >RSHQ DFFHVV KWWSVUFLQRUJSO&RQ WHQW:$BB,,B.URQLNDSGI@  *,/0DLDNRYVNLL%H"#)=,$N($,-.(),,$2)=",Y3(>($*#12$Y$FFFW;$%N/.$-,-.#92.,H"#-=(>($)6=(4 Y(*-.Y2SDUW0RVFRZS (*) *6')UDQNOLQ5,.#)2H/$23*$I(H69#3.2.,(3$,3$X2)1/$<#*,#Y21$W6--,2´6SHFXOXP$-RXUQDO RI0HGLHYDO6WXGLHVµ$9  S (+) *'6/LNKDFKHY0(#.,=2$*)#Y3#)6--=(,$1,.#)2.6)/7$0RVFRZS (,) *7*LPRQ+,-.(),H21$[),.,3>lS  *(JѷOHJ.XSFKLQV·NLǩљNWLWҤGӅNXPҬQWL*ҤOLWV·NӅ9ӅOLQV·NӅJӅNQLD]ӤYVWYҤ;,,,²SҬUVKӅӥ SӅOӅYLQL;,9VWӅOӤW·'ӅVOӤG]KҬQQLDWҬNVWL/YLY %'& $'5,$1-868329,ý ,QDFKDUWHUIURPUHJDUGLQJWKHVHSDUDWLRQRIWKH.LHYPHWURSROLWDQ DUFKGLRFHVHIURPWKH0RVFRZPHWURSROLWDQDUFKGLRFHVHDQGWKHFRQVHFUDWLRQ RI*UHJRU\7VDPEODNDVPHWURSROLWDQRI.LHYZHUHDG´DQGZHDUHRXUVHOYHV QRZKHDULQJDQGVHHLQJWKDWWKHFKXUFKLVJHWWLQJSRRUHUDQGWKH7VDUDQG WKHSDWULDUFKZLOOQRWJLYHDJRRGEXLOGHUIRUXVDQGWKHFKXUFKDFFRUGLQJ WRWKHFDQRQVZHSUHYLRXVO\HVWDEOLVKHGE\DQHFXPHQLFDOFRXQFLODVLWZDV LQWKHSDVWGXULQJWKHUHLJQWKHJUDQGSULQFH,]LDVODYRI.LHYZKHQWKHELVKRSV JDWKHUHGDWWKHHFXPHQLFDOFRXQFLODQGHVWDEOLVKHGWKHPHWURSROLWDQDWHRI.LHY DQGDOO5XV7KDWZHIRXQG>WKLV@LVJURXQGHGLQWKH5XV1#.(N,-TLQWKH.LHY 1#.(N,-TLQWKH9ODGLPLU1#.(N,-TDQGLQRWKHUVµ7KLVSDVVDJHUHIHUVGLUHFWO\WR WKHUHFRUGLQWKHVRFDOOHG.LHYLDQ/HWRSLVZKLFKXQGHUWKH\HDUZHUHDGV LQWKHFUXFLDOSDVVDJH ¶>«@7KH%LVKRSRI&KHUQLJRYVDLG¶,NQRZWKDWLWLV DOORZHGIRUELVKRSVZKHQWKH\JDWKHUWRHVWDEOLVKDPHWURSROLWDQ·>«@2QXIU\ >WKH%LVKRS@RI&KHUQLKLYVDLG´,NQRZWKDWZHDUHDOORZHGWRHVWDEOLVK>DPHW URSROLWDQ@EHFDXVHZHKDYHWKHKHDGRI6DLQW&OHPHQW$IWHUDOOWKH*UHHNV HVWDEOLVKPHWURSROLWDQVE\WKHKDQGRI6DLQW-RKQµ$QGVRDIWHUFRQVXOWDWLRQ WKHELVKRSVZLWKWKHKHDGRI6W&OHPHQWPDGH.OLPWKHPHWURSROLWDQµ +HQFHZHVHHWKDWIRUWKHSRSXODWLRQRI5XVEHIRUHWKHF6*#O3,=RI DFROOHFWLRQRIFRGLILHGODZ WKH5XVFKURQLFOHVZHUHDOVRDFROOHFWLRQRIOHJDO  * ÅѪ ӈҤӂҸ ӃӅ ӊҬӆҬӇӃӅ ӈӁӛӘҸӂӚ ӊӅ Ҹ ҧҸҫҸӂӚ ӘӊӅ ӔҬӇҼӅҧӜ ӈҼӋҫӬҬӊӜ Ҥ ӔҤӇӜ Ҹ ӆҤӊӇLҤӇӒӚ ӈӊӇӅҸӊҬӁӠ ҫӅҦӇҤҨӅ ҼӚ ӃҤӂӚ ӔҬӇҼҧҸ ӃҬ ҫҤӈӊӜ ӆӅ ӆӇҤҧҸӁӅӂӚ ӃҤӂӚ ҨӅҫҸӊӜӈӠ ӂҸӊӇӅӆӅӁҸӊҤҶҦӅӇӅӂӚӆӅӈӊҤҧҸӊҸҼҤҼӚҸӆҬӇҧӅӈҬҨӅӊҤҼӅҰӚҦӛӁӅӆӇҸҧҬӁҸҼӅӂӚҼӃӠҶҸ* ѪҶӠӈӁҤҧӬѮLҬҧӈҼӅӂӚӈӚҦӇҤҧӈӠҬӆҸӈҼӅӆҸҶҦӅӇӅӂӚҸӆӅӈӊҤҧҸӘҤӂҸӊӇӅӆӅӁҸӊҤѮLҬҧӋҸҧӈҬҸ ѹӋӈҸҟӅӀҾҟӓҼҳҧӃҽӀҾҟӁҳӃҟҾӀӃӅӀҳӅҢӕҼӧӅӀӁҳӃӏӧӍӕѴӆӃӃҷӖӍӕҢӕѩLҧҢӃҷӀҽӕҳ ҢӕїӀҼӀҦҳҽҧӂӃҷӀҽӕҳҢӕҳҾӖӍӕµ²ѷNUX]KQҤLDJUҤPӅWҤ$ѷNUX]KQҤLDJUҤPӅWҤ/LWӅYVNҤJӅ$ YҬOLNҤJӅ NQLD]LD љOҬNVҤQGUҤ9LWӅYWҤ ӅE ӅWGҬOҬQLL .LҬYVNӅǩ PLWUӅSӅOLL ӅW ѴӅVNӅYVNӅǩ L Ӆ SӅVWҤYOҬQLL YЦVҤQЦ.LҬYVNҤJӅPLWUӅSӅOLWҤ*ULJӅULLD7VҤPEOҤNҤLQљNW\ӅWQӅVLDVKĦҬVLDNЦLVWӅUĦL=ҤSҤGQӅǩ5ӅVVĦL 6ӅEUҤQQ\ҬLL]GҤQQ\ҬљUNKҬӅJUҤILFKҬVNӅLX.ӅPPLVVĦҬ,6YRO,6DLQW3HWHUVEXUJSQR  *,SҤW·ҬYVNҤLDOҬWӅSLV·FRO7KHHQWLUHLQHWHUHVWLQJSDVVDJHLVDVIROORZV´ќ ӊӅҰҬӁӬӊӅӆӅӈӊҤҧҸѪҶʠӈӁҤҧӚӂҸӊӇӅӆӅӁҸӊӅӂӚѮӁҸӂҤѺӂӅӁʠӊҸӕҤҧӚ×ҧҬҫӚҸҶӚѨҤӇӅӋҦҤҦӬҦӅ ӕҬӇӃӅӇҸҶҬӕӜӈҼҸӂӃҸҼӚҸҦӚ× ӈ >ӊӜ@ҼӃҸҰӃҸҼӚҸӑҸӁӅӈӅӑӜӊҤҼӚ˨ҼӅҰҬҧѹӅӋӈҼӅҸҶҬӂӁҸӃҬ ҦʠӘҬӊӜѴҧ Ӑ >ҧ@ҡӀ҂ҧӂҾҳңӀҢӗӃҷҳҳҧӁҳ Ӄ >ҷӀ@Ӂӕ©єұӕӃҢӧҦӧ˨ҷӀҦӀӃӅӀҳӅӗӃӕӓҧҦӓҧӃ࣒) ҧӁҳ Ӄ >ҷӀ@ӁӀҽӕҽҳӅӂӀӁӀҼҳӅҟӁӀӃӅҟҢҳӅҳªѪӈӃҸҫӅӘҤ ӈ ʠ҇ҬӇӃҸҨӅҧӜӈҼҸҬӆҸ ӈ >ҼӅ@ӆӚ× ʙӃӅӑӇҸҸћӬӁӅҨӅӇӅҫӜӈҼҸҸҬӆҸ ӈ >ҼӅ@ӆӚ҃Ҭʚҫ>Ӆ@ӇӚѸҬӇҬ˨ӈӁҤҧӜӈҼҸҸҬӆҸ ӈ >ҼӅ@ӆӚѡӅӋӑҸӂҸҸ ѝӟӇҨҸҸӈҼҸҸҬӆҸ ӈ >ҼӅ@ӆӚѠҬӂӜ˨ӃӚќӅӁӅҫҸӂҬӇӜӈҼҸҸ²҃ҬҫӅӇӚѵӅҧҨӅӇӅҫӜӈҼҸҸ²ѵҸӑӅӃӊӚ ѺӂӅӁҬӃӜӈҼҸҸ²ѴҤӃӅӋҸӁӚѹҬҼӅӈӊҤӃҬҬӈӊӜӊӅҨӅҧҶҤҼӅӃӬ˨ҼӅӈӊҤҧҸӊҸҬӆӈ ӆ Ɵ ӅӂӚӂҸӊӇӅӆӅӁҸӊҤ ҦҬҶӚӆҤӊӇҸҤӇӒҤӃӅӈӊҤҧҸӊӜӆҤӊӇҸҤӇӒӚӂҸӊӇӅӆӅӁҸӊҤҤӃҬӆӅҼӁӅӃҸҧӬӊҸӈʠӃҸӈӁӅӋҰҸҧӬӈ ӊӅҦӅӟҶҤӃҬӃҬҧҶʠӁӚҬӈҸҦӁ>Ӆ@Ҩ>Ӆ@ ӈ >ӁӅ@ҧ>Ҭ@ӃҸ˨ӅӋӈ>ҧʠ@ӊӅӬѺӅӑӜҸӃҸʸӆҤӊӇҸҤӇӒҤљәҬӁҸӈʠ* ҸӈӆӇҤҧҸӘҸҦӁ>Ӆ@ҨӅӈӁӅҧҸӘҸӈʠ*ʸӆҤӊӇҸҤӇӒҤҸӊӅҨҫҤӊҸӈʠӆӅҼӁӅӃҸҧӬҧӬҧҶʠӁҤʸѴҸӒҤҸӁҤʸ* ӂҸӊӇӅӆӅӁҸӊҤӇӅӋҼӅӆҸӈҤӃҸҬ˨ҼӅӃҬҫӅӈӊӅҸӊӜӃҤӂӚҦҬҶӚӂҸӊӇӅӆӅӁҸӊҤҧӚӈ>ҧʠ@ӊӬҸѺӅӑӜҸ ӈӁӅӋҰҸӊҸµʙӃӚҰҬӃҤӃʠӆӇӅӊӅӊʠҰҼӅӈӇ ҫ ӔҬҸӂӬ˨࣋ҾӀӌӂҳҳҫҧ҂ҧӂҾҳңӀҢӗӃҷҳҳ) ӂҧ Ӑ >ҧ@ ©єұӕ ӃҢӧҦҧ ҦӀӃӅӀҳӅӗ Ҿӕ× ӁӀӃӅҟҢҳӅҳ ҟ ңҼҟҢҟ Ӏӆ ҾҟӃӕ ҧӃӅӗ Ӄ>Ң࣒@Ӆ>Ӏ@ңӀ ѩҼҳҽҧҾӅҟ˨ҷӀҫҧӃӅҟҢ࣒ӅӗјӂӧӏҳӂӀӆҷӀӚӃ>Ң࣒@Ӆ>Ӏ@ңӀѥҢҟҾҟªѥӅҟҷӀӃңҟҦҟҢӓҧҧӁҳ Ӄ >ҷӀ@ӁҳӃҼҟҢӀӚӃ>Ң࣒@Ӆ>Ӏ@ңӀѩҼҳҽҧҾӅҟӁӀӃӅҟҢҳӓҟҽҳӅӂӀӁӀҼҳӅӀҽӕµ +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %'% SUHFHGHQWV0\PDLQJRDOLVQRWWRGHVFULEHDOOSUHFHGHQWVZKLFKZHFDQILQG LQ5XVVRXUFHVIURPWKWRWKHWKFHQWXU\ LWZLOOEHDVHSDUDWHSURMHFW  ,QWKHIROORZLQJZHZRXOGOLNHWRFRQFHQWUDWHRQDIHZVHOHFWHGH[DPSOHV PDLQO\IURPWKHWKFHQWXU\ZKLFKVHUYHDVWKHILUVW´LQWHUQDWLRQDOOHJDO SUHFHGHQWVµ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²/\DNKVDQG5XV²FRH[LVWHQFH7KHWH[WZLOOVKRZRQO\VHOHFWHGH[DP SOHVRILQWHUQDWLRQDOODZ,ZLOOFRQFHQWUDWHP\UHVHDUFKRQWKHWKFHQWXU\ EHFDXVHLQWKHVHWLPHVZHFDQREVHUYHWKHILUVWDWWHPSWVWRFUHDWHDODZ RUPD\EHZHVKRXOGVD\SUHFHGHQWV WRVHFXUHWKHLQWHUHVWVRIERWKVLGHV RIWKHFRQIOLFW 2QHRIWKHILUVWFRQIOLFWVEHWZHHQ3RODQGDQG5XVLVFRQQHFWHGZLWK WKHVRFDOOHG&KHUYHQWRZQV)URP´7KH7DOHRI%\JRQH<HDUVµZHNQRZ WKDWDERXW´  <DURVODYDQG0VWLVODYFROOHFWHGDODUJHIRUFHDQG PDUFKHGLQWR3RODQG7KH\UHFDSWXUHGWKHFLWLHVRI&KHUYHQDQGUDYDJHG WKH3ROLVKFRXQWU\VLGH7KH\DOVRFDSWXUHGPDQ\3ROHVDQGGLVWULEXWHGWKHP DVFRORQLVWVLQYDULRXVGLVWULFWV<DURVODYORFDWHGKLVFDSWLYHVDORQJWKH5RV· ZKHUHWKH\OLYHWRWKLVGD\µ7KHQDUUDWLYHIRUWKH\HDUVLPLODUO\DVIRU WKH\HDUGHVFULEHVDFHUWDLQKLVWRULFDOSURFHVVRIPRUHWKDQDWHQ\HDUV· GXUDWLRQ 7KH KLVWRULDQV VXSSRVH WKDW WKHVH FRQIOLFW HQGHG ZLWK VRPH  *!"#$W6--,23$0),92)/$G")(3,H1#l$Sќ*ӁӬӊ>Ӆ@ҒӇӅӈӁҧӚ*Ҹ*ѴӜӈӊҸӈӁҤҧӚ*ӈӅҦӇҤӈӊҤ* ҧӅҸ*ӂӃӅҨӚ*ҸҫӅӈӊҤ*ӃҤ*ѳ‫׸‬Ӓӛ*Ҹ*ҶҤӠӈӊҤ*ҨӇҤҫӛ*҇ҬӇҧҬӃӜӈҼӛӠ*Ӆӆ‫׸‬ӊӜ*Ҹ*ӆӅҧӅҬҧҤӈӊҤ*ѳ‫׸‬ҫӜӈҼӋӟ*ҶҬӂӁӟ* Ҹ*ӂӃӅҨӛ*ѳ‫׸‬Ӓӛ*ӆӇҸҧҬҫӅӈӊҤ*Ҹ*ӇҤҶҫӬӁҸҧӘҤ*ӠҒӇӅӈӁҤҧӚ*ӆӅӈҤҫӥ>ӈҧӅӠ@ӆӅ*ѹӚӈҸ*Ҹ*ӈӋӊӜ*ҫӅ*ӈҬҨӅ*ҫ>Ӝ@ӃҬ /ҤYUҬQW·ҬYVNҤLDOҬWӅSLV·FRO  *$-XVXSRYLþ´G"#)Y#3T$,$,3/$>)2*/$µ()$i>)(*/$H"#)Y#3T-=/,2µt$+,-.()/$('$."#$*(92,3$ ('$H"#)Y#3T$,3$."#$P),..#3$)#H()*$c@]."4@A."$H#3.6),#-dLQU)(9$G"#)Y#3T$!(P3-$.($G6)V(3$5,3#$HG 0 :RãRV]\Q &UDFRZ/HLS]LJ5]HV]yZ:DUVDZ   )UK]HLW 2VWPLWWHOHXURSDV ,,,  SS %'' $'5,$1-868329,ý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·VVRQLQWDNLQJFRQWURORI3RODQG<DURVODYWKH:LVHZDVWRUHFHLYH&KHUYHQWRZQV %HO]DQG%UHVW7KLVDJUHHPHQWZDVFRQILUPHGE\WKHPDUULDJHVRI.D]LPLHU]ZLWK'REURQHJD DQGRI,]\DVODY<DURVODYLFKZLWK*HUWUXGH 973DVKXWR9QHVKQLDLDSROLW\NDGUHYQHǩ5XVL0RV FRZS 6LPLODUO\*ULJRUL\'HPLGHQNR **'HPLGHQNR:2)(-12Y$<6*),ǩK$8#1,=,ǩ=3,2VT$ W6-Ħ;$326=(Y(4N(N6=,2)3,ǩ$32),-.KDUNLY$SS 6WHIDQ0.XF]\ĸVNLKDVDUJXHGWKDW WKHDJUHHPHQWZDVPDGHHDUOLHULQQRWLQJWKDWWKH3ROLVK5XVLDQWUHDW\RILQFOXGHG ´7KHPDWWHURIWKHPDUULDJHRI.D]LPLHU]2GQRZLFLHOZLWK'REURQHJD0DULDVLVWHU SRV VLEO\GDXJKWHU RI<DURVODYWKH:LVHZKLFKZDVHQWHUHGLQWRLQWKHILUVWPRQWKVRI 7KHPDWWHURIUHOHDVLQJ5XVLDQWDNHQFDSWLYHLQE\&KUREU\ 7KHPDWWHURIWKHPLOLWDU\DOOLDQFHDJDLQVW0DVãDZDQG/LWKXDQLDQSHRSOHV 7KHPDWWHURIUHJXODWLQJWKHVWDWXVRIWKH3ROLVK5XVLDQERUGHUUHJLRQ5XVSUHVXPDEO\ UHFHLYHGWKHVWURQJKROGVRIWKH%X]KDQVZLWK9ODGLPLU9RO\QVN3RODQGNHSWWKHWHUULWRU\RQ WKHOHIWEDQNRIWKH%XJ5LYHU%HO]DQG3U]HP\ŋOUHPDLQHGRQWKH3ROLVKVLGHµ 60.XF]\ĸVNL$ 6WRVXQNLSROVNRUXVNLHGRVFK\ãNXZLHNX;,,LQF.6*,2$V$*V,#JyP$X6)(N/$[-H"(*3,#J$b4b8::$PK:DU V]DZDS &I-XVXSRYLþ´G"#)Y#3T$,$,3/$>)2*/|l7SS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUH WKHUHLQ   *G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lSS  *:O,*#97*SS  *'HWDLOHGLQIRUPDWLRQDERXW.DOLV]FRQIOLFWVHH''ćEURZVNLI23,#1*W(923(P,HV$=)y1$ W6-,$c(=K$@`]@^@`DpdK$M,(>)2',2$N(1,./HV32.UDNyZ 0RQRJUDILH3UDFRZQL%DGDĸQDG']LH MDPL5XVL8.:, SS$-XVXSRYLþ!"#$G")(3,H1#$('$+21/H"48(1"/3,2$23*$+,-.(),H21$ G(11#H.,(3-$,3$<#*,#Y21$W6-T7$/HLGHQ%RVWRQSS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ  +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %'( WKHFRDOLWLRQRI'DQLOR5RPDQRYLFKDQG.RQUDGRI0DVRYLDZDVSUHSDULQJ WRDWWDFNWKH.DOLV]WKHWHUULILHGLQKDELWDQWVVWDUWHGLQVLVWHGRQQHJRWLDWLRQV ´3DNRVODYDVNHG'DQLORWRFRPHZLWKWKHPDIWHUKHKDGFKDQJHGKLVFORWKLQJ 'DQLORGLGQRWZLVK>WRFRPHDORQH@EXWKLVEURWKHUDGYLVHGKLPWRJRDQG OLVWHQWRWKHLUFRQYHUVDWLRQVLQFH.RQUDGGLGQRWWUXVW0VWLXM'DQLORGRQQHG 3DNRVODY·VKHOPHWDQGVWRRGEHKLQGERWKRIWKHP6WDQGLQJDWRSLWVUDPSDUWV >WKHFLW\·V@HOGHUVDGGUHVVHG>3DNRVODYDQG0VWLXM@´5HODWHWKHIROORZLQJWR JUHDW3ULQFH.RQUDG,VQ·WWKLV\RXUFLW\":H²LWVHOGHUV²KDYHEHFRPHZRUQ RXW>E\\RXUVLHJHRI@WKLVFLW\$UHZH>LQGHHG@IRUHLJQHUV>LQ\RXUVLJKW@":H DUH\RXUSHRSOHDQG\RXUEURWKHUV:K\GRQ·W\RXSLW\XV",IWKH5XVLDQVWDNH XVFDSWLYHZKDWJORU\ZLOO.RQUDGKDYH",IWKHEDQQHURI5XVLV>SODQWHG@RQ WKHFLW\UDPSDUWVZKRPDUH\RXKRQRULQJ",VLWQRW5RPDQ·VVRQVZKLOH\RX GLVJUDFH\RXUVHOI"1RZZHVHUYH\RXUEURWKHUEXWWRPRUURZZHDUH\RXUV 2QO\GRQRWOHW5XVZLQWKHJORU\'RQRWGHVWUR\WKHFLW\µ$QGWKH\VDLG PDQ\RWKHUWKLQJV>7KHQ@3DNRVODYUHSOLHG´.RQUDGZRXOGEHPRUHWKDQ ZLOOLQJWRVKRZ\RXKLVPHUF\EXW'DQLORLVYHU\DQJU\DQGZLOOQRWOHDYHXV XQWLOZHWDNHWKHFLW\µ7KHQKHEURNHRXWLQODXJKWHUDQGDGGHG´$QGKHUH KHLVLQSHUVRQ6SHDNZLWKKLPµ3ULQFH>'DQLOR@QXGJHGKLPZLWKWKHVKDIW RI KLV VSHDU DQG WRRN RII KLV KHOPHW 7KHUHXSRQ WKH\ FDOOHG GRZQ IURP WKHFLW\>UDPSDUWV@´:HZLOOVHUYH\RXRQO\PDNHSHDFHZHEHJ\RXµ%XW 'DQLORFRQWLQXHGODXJKLQJDQGFRQYHUVLQJZLWKWKHPIRUDORQJWLPH>7KHQ@ WDNLQJDORQJWZRHOGHUVKHZHQWWR.RQUDG>7KXV@.RQUDGFRQFOXGHGSHDFH ZLWKWKHPDQGWRRNKRVWDJHVIURPWKHP>'XULQJWKLVFDPSDLJQ@WKH5XVLDQV KDGFDSWXUHGPDQ\VHUYDQWVDQGER\DUV·ZLYHVµ  * !"#$ _21,H,2348(1"/3,23$ G")(3,H1#;$ !"#$ +/N2.,23$ G(*#& SDUW ,, WUDQVO *$ 3HUIHFN\ 0QFKHQ +DUYDUG6HULHVLQ8NUDLQLDQ6WXGLHV;9, SSÅѸҤҼӅӈӁҤҧ>Ӛ@ҰҬӇҬӕҬ ѠҤӃҸӁӅҧҸ©ѪҶӂӬӃҸҧӚӇҸҶӛӈҧӅҤӆӅҬҫҸӈӃҤӂҸªѠҤӃҸӁӅҧҸҰ>Ҭ@ӃҬӒӅӊӬҧ>Ӛ@ӘӟӇҬӕҬҬӂӅӋ ©ћӇҤӊ>Ҭ@ҸҫҸҫҤӈӁӛӘҸӘ>Ҹ@ҧҬӕҬҸӒӜªѵҬҧӬӇʠӘҬҦӅѴӜӈӊҸӅӋҬҧҸѮӅӃҫӇҤӊ>Ӛ@ѠҤӃҸӁ>Ӛ@ҰҬ ҧӚҶҬӂӜӃҤӈʠӘӅӁʚӂ>Ӛ@ѸҤҼӅӈӁҤҧӁӜҸӈӊҤҶҤӃҸӂҤѺӊӅʠәҸӂ>Ӛ@ҰҬӂӮҰҬӂ>Ӛ@ӃҤҶҤҦӅӇӅӁӬӒ>Ӛ@ ҸӇҬҼӅӋәҸӂ>Ӛ@Ҹӂ>Ӛ@©ѼҤҼӅӂӅӁҧҸӊҤҧҬӁҸҼӅӂӅӋҼӃʠӣӟѮӅӃҫӇҤӊӋ´ѺӚҸҨӇҤҫ>Ӛ@ӃҬӊҧӅҸӁҸ Ҭ>ӈӊӜ@"ѴӛҰ>Ҭ@ӂӮҰҸҸҶӃҬӂӅҨ>Ӛ@ӘҬҸҧӚҨӇҤҫӬӈҬӂ>Ӝ@ӔҸҸӃӅҨӅӈӊӇҤӃ>Ӝ@ӃҸӔҸҬӈӂӛ"ѵӅӁӟҫӥҬ ӊҧӅҸҬӈӂӛҤҧҤӘҤҦӇҤӊӥҤҬӈӂӛ҇ҬӂӅӋӅӃҤӈ>Ӛ@ӃҬҶ>Ӛ@ҰҤӁҸӊҤӈҸ"љәҬӃҤӈ>Ӛ@ѹӅӋӈ>Ӝ@ӆӁӬӃʠӊ>Ӝ@ ӊʚҼӅӋӟӈӁҤҧӅӋѮӅӃҫӇҤӊ>Ӛ@ӆӇӥҸӂҬӊ>Ӝ@"љәҬӇӅӋӈ>Ӝӈ@ҼҤҤҼӅӇӅҨӅҧӜӈӊҤӃҬӊӜӃҤҶҤҦӅӇӅӁӬӒ>Ӛ@ӊӅ ҼӅӂӅӋӕ>Ӝ@ӈӊӜӅӋӕҸӃҸӘҸ"ѵҬѹӅӂҤӃӅҧҸӕҬӂҤӁҸ"љӈҧӅӟӕ>Ӝ@ӈӊӜӅӋӃҸӕҸҰҸӘҸѵ>ӛ@ӃӬҦӇҤӊӅӋ ӊҧӅҬӂӅӋӈӁӅӋҰҸӂ>Ӛ@ҤҶҤӋӊӇҤӊҧӅҸҦӮҫҬӂ>Ӛ@ѵҬҫҤҹӈӁҤҧӛӇӅӋӈҸӆӅҨӅӋҦҸӊҸҨӇҤҫҤӈҬҨӅµªѪ ҸӃҤӂӃʚҨҤӈӁӅҧҬӈҤҨӁ>ҤҨӅӁ@ҤӒӮѸҤҼӅӈӁҤҧӅӋҰҬӇҬҼ>Ӛ@Әӟ©ѮӅӃҫӇҤӊ>Ӛ@ҦӛӇҤҫ>Ӛ@ӂ>Ҹ@Ӂ>Ӆ@ӈӊӜ ӅӋӕҸӃҸӁӜҧҤӂ>Ӛ@ӃӅѠҤӃҸӁӜӁӟӊ>Ӛ@ӣӬӁʚҬӈ>ӊӜ@ӃҤӈ>Ӛ@ӃҬӒӅәҬӊ>Ӝ@ʚӊҸӊҸӆӇӅӕ>Ӝ@ӃҬӆӇӥҬӂӚ ҨӇҤҫҤªѹӅӈӂӬʠҧ>Ӛ@ӈʠӇҬӕ>Ҭ@©љӈҬӈӊӅҸӊ>Ӝ@ӈҤӂ>Ӛ@ӂӅӁҧҸӊҬӈӃҸӂ>Ӝ@ªѮӃʠҶ>Ӝ@ҰҬӊӚӕҬҬҨӅ ʚӈҼӬӆҸәҬӂ>Ӝ@ҸӈӃʠӈӚӈҬҦҬӘҬӁʚӂ>Ӛ@ѷӃҸҰҬҼӁҸҼӃӅӋӘҤӈӚҨӇҤҫҤ©ѪӂӬҸӈӁӅӋҰ>Ӝ@ҦӅӋ ӃҤӘӟӂӅӁҸӂ>Ӛ@ӈʠѺӚӊҧӅӇҸӂҸӇӚªѷӃӅӂӅӋҰ>Ҭ@ӂӃʚҨӅӈӂӬҤҧ>Ӛ@Әӟӈ>ʠ@ҸӂӃӅҨӅҧӬӈӊӅҧҤҧ>Ӛ@ ӘӟӈӃҸӂҸӆӅʠ*ʚӊ>Ӛ@ӃҸӒ>Ӛ@ҫҧҤӂӮҰҤҸӆӇӥҬӒҤҼӚѮӅӃҫӇҤӊӅҧҸѪӈӚӊҧӅӇҸѮӅӃҫӇҤӊ>Ӛ@ӈӃҸӂҸ ӂҸӇӚҸӆӅʠӅӋӃҸӒ>Ӛ@ӊҤӁӚӇӅӋӈҸҦʚҦʠӒӮӆӅӁӅӃҸӁҸӂӃʚҨӅӋӕҬӁʠҫ>Ӝ@ҸҦӅʠӇҸӃӬµ²G")(3,H2$ _21,H,23(48(1,3,232lSS %') $'5,$1-868329,ý 'XULQJWKHFDPSDLJQLWLVVWDWHGWKDWWKH5XVLDQVFDSWXUHGPDQ\/\DNKV )RUWKDWUHDVRQZHDOVROHDUQVRPHZKDWODWHULQWKHVRXUFHRIWKHILUVW3ROLVK 5XVWUHDW\´7KH5XVLDQVDQGWKH/\DNKVSOHGJHGHDFKRWKHUWKDWLIWKHUHZHUH HYHUDIHXGEHWZHHQWKHPWKH/\DNKVZRXOGQRWSOXQGHU5XVLDQVXEMHFWVQRU ZRXOGWKH5XVSOXQGHUWKDWRIWKH/\DNKVµ:HFDQDVVXPHWKDWDVLQWKHFDVH RI5XV%\]DQWLQHWUHDWLHVWKHFRQWHQWVRIWKHDJUHHPHQWZHUHZULWWHQGRZQ 7KLVDFFRXQWFOHDUO\VKRZVWKDWWKHSUDFWLFHRIFDSWXULQJDQHQHP\·V´VXEMHFWVµ DQGWDNLQJWKHPWRRQH·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ãDZ,,DQG:ãDG\VãDZâRNLHWHN RQWKHRWKHU %ROHVãDZDQG.RQUDGZHUHDOVRVXSSRUWHGE\/HV]HNWKH%ODFN * $VDUHVXOWWKHODWWHUWZRLQYDGHGDQGSOXQGHUHG-D]GyZ7KH&KURQLFOHPHQ WLRQVWKHIROORZLQJOHJDOUHJXODWLRQIURP.DOLV]´7KH3ROHVKDGWKHIROORZLQJ ODZWKH\ZRXOGQHLWKHUFDSWXUHQRUEHDW>WKHLURSSRQHQW·V@VXEMHFWVEXWWKH\ ZRXOGUREWKHP>RIWKHLUEHORQJLQJV@$QGWKXVWKHFLW\ZDVWDNHQ7KH\FDS WXUHGPXFKSURSHUW\LQLWDQGUREEHGWKHLUVXEMHFWV>RIWKHLUEHORQJLQJV@µ ,KDYHWRPHQWLRQWKDWWKHGHVFULSWLRQRIWKH.DOLV]FDPSDLJQHQGHGZLWK UHIHUHQFHWRWKHFDPSDLJQRI9RORGLPHUWKH*UHDWDJDLQVW3RODQGWKHRQH LQZKLFKKHFRQTXHUHG&KHUYHQ3U]HP\ŋODQGRWKHUVWURQJKROGV´1RRWKHU SULQFH>H[FHSWWKH'DQLOR$-@KDGSHQHWUDWHGWKH3ROLVKODQGVRGHHSO\ H[FHSW9RORGLPHUWKH*UHDWZKRKDGEDSWL]HGWKHFRXQWU\µ  *7UDQVODWLRQIURP$-XVXSRYLþ!"#$G")(3,H1#$('$+21/H"48(1"/3,2l$S´ѺӚӊҧӅӇҸӘҤ ӂҬҰҸӈӅҦӅӟҼӁʠӊҧӅӋӇӅӋӈ>Ӝ@ҸӁʠӒӅҧҬҤәҬӆӅӈҬӂ>Ӝ@ҼӅӁҸҦӮҫҬӊ>Ӝ@ӂҬҰҸҸӂҸӅӋӈӅҦҸӔҤӃҬ* ҧӅҬҧҤӊҸLӁʠӒʚӂ>Ӛ@ӇӅӋӈҼӅҬӕҬӁʠҫҸӃҸӇӅӋӈҸӁʠҫ>Ӝ@ӈҼӅҬµ²$G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lS  *$6LZNRQ$G(99(3P#21."$('$:3.#)#-.-$,3$."#$W6-4M/V23.,3#$!)#2./$cHK2K$Eppd´6WXGLD&HUD QHDµ;,  SS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ 7KHZRUNRIIHUVDQHZRULJLQDOO\ DSSURDFKWRWKHWRSLF  *$-XVXSRYLþ!"#$G")(3,H1#$('$+21/H"48(1"/3,2l$S  *%ROHVãDZDQG.RQUDGZDVVXSSRUWHGE\/HV]HNWKH%ODFN  *G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232l$SS² *() *!"#$_21,H,2348(1"/3,23$G")(3,H1#lS´ѨҤҼӅӃ>Ӛ@ҰҬҦʠӘҬҧӁʠӒӅӒ>Ӛ@ӊҤҼӅҧӜӕҬӁʠҫҸ ӃҬҸӂҤӊҸӃҸҦҸӊҸЯӃӅӁӅӋӆʠӒӅӋҨӅӇӅҫӅӋҰ>Ҭ@ҧҶʠӊӅӋҸӆӅҸӂҤӘҤҧ>Ӛ@ӃҬӂ>Ӝ@ӊӅҧҤӇҤӂӃʚҨӅҸ ӁӟҫҸӆӅӁӅӋӆҸӘҤµ²G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lSS  *!"#$_21,H,2348(1"/3,23$G")(3,H1#lS´ѪҧӃҸҫӅӈӊҤӈӚӈӁҤҧӅӟҧӚҶҬӂӁӟӈҧӅӟҸӃӛҹ ҦʚҼӃʠӣӜӃҬҧӚӒӅҫҸӁӚҦӬҧӚҶҬӂӁӟӁʠҫ>Ӝ@ӈҼӅӋӟӊӅӁ>Ӝ@ҨӁӅӋҦӅҼӅӆӇӅӕҬќӅӁʚҫҸӂҬӇҤќҬӁҸҼӅҨӅ ҸҰҬҦӬҶҬӂӁӟҼӇ>Ӝ@ӈӊҸӁӚµG")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232l$SS +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %'* 7KH QH[W H[DPSOH UHJDUGV WKH IXQFWLRQLQJ DJUHHPHQW RU PD\EH ,VKRXOGVD\XQZULWWHQODZRUSULQFLSOHWKDWRQHUXOHUZLOOJDYHVKHOWHU WRDQRWKHUUXOHUZKHQWKHVHFRQGLVLQGDQJHU2IFRXUVHVXFKEHKDY LRXU LV QRWKLQJ XQQDWXUDO DQG ZH NQRZ D ORW RI VXFK VLWXDWLRQV #K> $QGUHZ,,NLQJRI+XQJDU\WRRNFDUHRI5RPDQ0VWLVODYRYLFK·VZLGRZ DQGKHUFKLOGUHQLQLQ0VWLVODYWKH'XPEJDYHKLVSDWULPRQ\ WR3ULQFH'DQLORDQGHQWUXVWHGKLVVRQ,YDQWRKLVFDUH6XFKH[DPSOHV LQWKHPLGGOHDJHVZHFDQPXOWLSO\EXW,ZRXOGOLNHWRSD\DWWHQWLRQ RQRQHVSHFLILFVLWXDWLRQZKLFKWRRNSODFHDIWHU0RQJROLQYDVLRQRI5XV LQ7KH5XVSULQFHVZDVORRNLQJDVKHOWHULQ+XQJDU\DQGLQ3RODQG ,Q&KURQLFOHRI+DO\FK9ROK\QLDQZHUHDGWKDW´>7KHQ@'DQLORVDLGWKDW LWZDVQRWVDIHIRUWKHPWRUHPDLQWKHUH>VR@FORVHWRWKHIRUHLJQHUVZKR ZHUHZDJLQJZDUDJDLQVWWKHPDQGVHWRXWIRUWKH0D]RYLDQODQGWR .RQGUDW·VVRQ%ROHVODY3ULQFH%ROHVODYJDYHKLPWKHFLW\RI:\V]JRUyG* DQGKHUHPDLQHGWKHUHXQWLOKHUHFHLYHGZRUGWKDWWKHLQILGHOVKDGOHIW WKHODQGRI5XV>7KHQ@KHUHWXUQHGWRKLVRZQODQGµ:HPXVWUHPHP EHUWKDWMXVWEHIRUH0RQJROVLQFXUVLRQ.RQGUDW0D]RZLHFNLDQGKLVVRQV VXSSRUWHG0LNKDLO9VHYRORGRYLFKDJDLQVW'DQLOR5RPDQRYLFK1HYHUWKH OHVVZKHQWKHVLWXDWLRQLQWKHVHSDUWRI(XURSHZHUHGLIILFXOW\KHKHOSHG RWKHUVUXOHUVHYHQHQHPLHVRUULYDOZKRZHUHLQQHHG,QWKHVHSDUWLFXODU FDVHKHJDYH ҧҫҤӈӊӜ FLW\WRWKHZKROHIDPLO\RI'DQLOR5RPDQRYLFK:H FDQRQO\DVVXPHWKDW:\V]JRUyG·VEHVWRZDOZDVWRPHHWDOOWKHQHHGV RIWKHKROGHUVRYHUDORQJHUSHULRGRIWLPH,VXSSRVHWKDWVXFKSUDFWLFHV ZHUHWUDGLWLRQDOLQWKH3LDVWVDQG5XULNLGVUHODWLRQVKLSV7KHVHLVVXH FRXOGEHDVHSDUDWHFDVHVWXG\VRZHZLOOJRWRWKHQH[WH[DPSOHRILQWHU QDWLRQDOODZ ,VKRXOGPHQWLRQDERXWYHU\LPSRUWDQWFLUFXPVWDQFHVZLWKKDGLQIOXHQFH RQWKH3ROLVK5XVUHODWLRQVKLS)URPWRFLUFDWKH0RQJRODUP\ FRQTXHUHGDOOWKHSULQFLSDOLWLHVRI5XV7KLVHYHQWZDVKLJKO\LQGLVWLQFW **) *G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232«SS *+) *,ELGHPV *,) *!"#$_21,H,2348(1"/3,23$G")(3,H1#lSÅѠҤӃҸӁӅҧҸҰ>Ҭ@ӇҬҼ>Ӛ@Әӟ˨ҼӅ©ӃҬҫӅҦӇӅ ӃҤӂ>Ӛ@ ӈӊӅҤӊҸ ҶҫҬ ҦӁҸҶ>Ӛ@ ҧӅӟӟәҸӒ>Ӛ@ ӃҤӈ>Ӛ@ ҸӃӅӆӁҬӂҬӃ>Ӝ@ӃҸҼӅӂ>Ӛ@ª ҸҫҬ ҧӚQ ҶҬӂӁӟ ѴҤҶӅҧҬӔ>Ӝ@ҼӅӋӟҼӚћӅӁҬӈӁҤҧӅӋҼӚUѮӅӃҫӇҤӊӅҧӅӋӈ>ӛ@Ӄ>Ӆ@ҧҸҳҢҦҟӃӅӗҧҽӈҷҾ࣒ұ>ӗ@іӀҼҧӃҼҟҢӗ ңӂҟҦ>ӕ@їӖӓҧңӀӂ࣌Ҧ>ӕ@ҸҦӛӈ>ӊӜ@ӊӅӋҫӅӃ>Ӝ@ҫҬҰҬҧӬӈӊӜӆӇӥҤ˨ҼӅӈӅӘӁҸӈӮӊ>Ӝ@ҸҶӜҶҬӂӁҸ ӇӅӋӈ>Ӝӈ@ҼӅҬҦҬҶҦӅҰ>Ӝ@ӃӥҸҸҧӚҶҧӇҤӊҸӈʠҧӚҶҬӂӁӟӈҧӅӟµG")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lS  *6HH%'*UҬNӅYљ,X,DNXEӅYVNLǩ=ӅOӅWҤLDѷUGҤLҬҬSҤGҬQLҬ0RVFRZ²/ҬQLQJUҤG *9HUQDGVN\<(3>(1/$,$W6-$0RVFRZ'*.KUXVWDOHY5XV·RWQҤVKҬVWYLLDGӅ´LJҤµ² >>K$b:::$YK6DLQW3HWHUVEXUJ'*.KUXVWDOHYW6-T$:$9(3>(1T-=(#$32-"#-.Y,#$c`]^C]$>>K$b:::$YKd* 6DLQW3HWHUVEXUJ ZLWKDOLVWRIUHOHYDQWOLWHUDWXUH -/,)HQQHOO!"#$G),-,-$('$<#*,#Y21$W6--,2$ @`]]^@A]p/RQGRQ'&KULVWLDQQ$+,-.()/$('$W6--,27$G#3.)21$Q-,2$23*$<(3>(1,2YRO,:33#)$ X6)2-,2$')(9$0)#",-.()/$.($."#$<(3>(1$X9N,)#2[IRUG %'! $'5,$1-868329,ý LQ5XVFKURQLFOHV,QKLVDQDO\VLVRIWKHVHHYHQWV&KDUOHV+DOSHULQZURWH WKDW ´5XVVLDQ ZULWLQJ IURP WKH 0RQJRO SHULRG FOHDUO\ VKRZV D UHMHFWLRQ RIWKHIDFWRIFRQTXHVW>E\7DWDUV@µ,QWKHROGHVWFKURQLFOHV #K>WKH+21/H"4 8(1"/3,23$G")(3,H1# ZHILQGVRPHVFUDSVRIWKHDXWKHQWLFDFFRXQWVRIWKHVLW XDWLRQLQ5XV$JRRGH[DPSOHLVDODWHUHFRUGDERXW5XVSULQFHV·MRXUQH\ WR6DUDLRU.DUDNRUDP´IRUWKHLUSDWULPRQLHVµ7KHUHWKHSULQFHVUHFHLYHG \DUOLTV 0RQJROSDWHQWV IURPWKH.KDQWKRXJKVRPHRIWKHPHYHQGLHG GXULQJWKLVYHQWXUHIRUH[DPSOH0LNKDLORI&KHUQLJRY  LQ :HDOVRKDYHYHU\LQWHUHVWLQJUHFRUGVRIWKHVHWULSV$WWKHHQGRI 'DQLOR5RPDQRYLFK " WUDYHOOHGWR%DWX  ,QWKH+21/H"48(14 "/3,23$G")(3,H1#ZHUHDG´7KHQFHKHZHQWWR%DW\M>ZKRZDV@RQWKH9RO JDZLVKLQJWRSD\KLPKRPDJH>7KHUH@DYDVVDORI-DURVODY>9VHYRORGRYLĀ FDOOHG@6RQJXUDSSURDFKHGKLPDQGVXJJHVWHGWKDWVLQFH'DQLOR·V¶EURWKHU· -DURVODYKDGZRUVKLSSHGDEXVKKHVKRXOGDOVR%XW>'DQLOR@UHSOLHGWKDW WKH'HYLOZDVVSHDNLQJWKURXJKKLVOLSVDQGWKDW*RGZRXOGVKXWWKHP VRWKDWQRRQHZRXOGKHDUZKDWKHVDLG$QGDWWKDWPRPHQWKHZDVVXP PRQHGE\%DW\MDQGZDVWKXVGHOLYHUHGE\*RGIURPWKHLUJRGOHVVGHYLOU\ DQGVRUFHU\+HERZHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLUFXVWRPDQGHQWHUHG>%DW\M·V@WHQW %DW\MLQTXLUHGZK\'DQLORKDGQRWFRPHWRKLPEHIRUHWKLVEXWZDVQHYHU WKHOHVVSOHDVHGWKDWKHGLGFRPHQRZ7KHQ%DW\MLQTXLUHGZKHWKHU'DQLOR GUDQNEODFNPLONZKLFKZDVIHUPHQWHGPDUH·VPLONDQGZDVWKHLU>IDYRXU LWH@GULQN'DQLOR>FRQIHVVHG@WKDWKHKDGQRW\HWWULHGLWEXWZRXOGGULQN LWLIKHZLVKHGWRZKLFK%DW\MUHSOLHGWKDW'DQLORZDVDOUHDG\RQHRIWKHP /)%)0%1%2²DQGVKRXOGWKHUHIRUGULQNWKHLUEHYHUDJH'DQLORGUDQN>WKHPLON@ ERZHGLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHLUFXVWRPDQGVDLGWKDWKHZRXOGQRZJRDQG SD\KRPDJHWRWKH*UDQG3ULQFHVV%DUDNĀLNRYDDQG%DW\MVDLG¶JR·µ  */LWHUDWXUHUHYLHZVHH-/,)HQQHOOS!"#$!21#$('$M2./T-$:3Y2-,(3$('$a()."4X2-.$W6-T$23*$ :.-$W#'1#&,(3$,3$."#$G")(3,H1#-$('$."#$!",).##3."^','.##3."$G#3.6),#-T´5XVVLD0HGLDHYDOLVµ,,,   SS²*03URKRURY3ӅYҬVW·ӅQҤVKҬVWYLL%Ҥ./,2$LQ6OӅYҤU·NQL]KQLNӅYLNQL]KQӅVWL'UҬYQҬǩ5XVL YRO,;,²SҬUYҤLDSӅOӅYLQҤ;,9Y/ҬQLQJUҤGSS  *-&K+DOSHULQW6--,2$23*$."#$_(1*#3$+()*#;$!"#$<(3>(1$:9N2H.$(3$<#*,#Y21$W6--,23$+,-4 .()//RQGRQS  * !"#$ _21,H,2348(1/3,23$ G")(3,H1#l S  ´ʙӊ>Ӛ@ӊӅӋҫӅӋ Ұ>Ҭ@ ӆӇӥҸҫҬ ҼӚ ћҤӊӛҬҧҸ ӃҤ ќӅӁҨӅӋDH ӒӅӊʠӘӍ ӈʠ ҬӂӅӋDJ ӆӅҼӁӅӃҸӊҸD ѸӇҸӘҬҫ>Ӛ@ӘӟDL Ұ>Ҭ@ ҒӇӅӈӁҤҧӁӟ ӕ>Ҭ@Ӂ>ӅҧӬ@ ҼӅӋ ѺӚӃӜҨӅӋӇӅҧҸ ӇҬҼ>Ӛ@ӘӟF ҬӂӅӋ ¶ћӇҤӊ>Ӛ@H ӊҧӅҹ ҒӇӅӈӁҤҧӜ ҼӁҤӃʠӁ>Ӛ@ӈʠ ҼӅӋӈӊӅӋ Ҹ ӊӅҦӬ ҼӁҤ_ӃʠӊҸӈʠ·ѪӇҬӕ>Ҭ@ҬӂӅӋ¶ѠӥҤҧӅӁӚҨӁҤҨӅӁҬӊ>Ӝ@ҸҶӜӅӋӈӊӜӊҧӅҸӒ>Ӛ@_ћ>ӅҨ@ӚҶҤҨӇҤҫҸRӅӋӈӊҤS ӊҧӅҤ Ҹ ӃҬ ӈӁӛӘҤӃӅ ҦӮҫҬӊ>Ӝ@ ӈӁʚҧӅ ӊҧӅҬ· Ѫ ҧӚ ӊӚҸ ӕҤӈ>Ӛ@ ӆӅҶӃҤӃӚ Ҧӛӈ>ӊӜ@ ћҤӊӛҬӂ>Ӝ@Z ҸҶҦҤҧӁҬӃӚћ>Ӆ@Ҩʚӂ>Ӝ@Ҧӛӈ>ӊӜ@ҸҶӁӅҨ>Ӆ@ҸӒ>Ӛ@ҦӬӘҬӃӥҤ\ҸҼӅӋҫҬӘ>Ӝ@ӈӊҧҤѪӆӅҼӁӅӃҸҧӈʠӆӅ ӅҦӛӕҤӟDE ҸӒ>Ӛ@ Ҹ ҧӚӃҸҫҬ ҧ>Ӛ@DG ҧҬҰӟ ҬҨӅ ӇҬҼ>Ӛ@Әӟ ҬӂӅӋ ¶ѠҤӃҸӁӅ ҇ҬӂӅӋ ҬӈҸ ҫҤҧ>Ӝ@ӃӅ ӃҬӆӇҸӘҬӁӚҤӃ>ӛ@ӃӬҸҰҬDҬӈҸӆӇҸӘҬӁӚҤӊӅҫӅҦӇӅҰҬѸӥҬӘҸӁҸFӕҬӇӃӅҬӂӅӁӅҼӅӃҤӘҬ ӆҸӊӥҬҼӅҦӛӁӬҹHҼӅӋӂӅӋҶӜ"·ѷӃӅӂӅӋҰ>Ҭ@ӇҬҼ>Ӛ@Әӟ¶ѠӅӈҬӁӬҬӈӂӜӃҬӆҸӁӚӃӅҰҬӊӛҧҬӁҸӘӜN ӆӥӟ·ѷӃ>Ӛ@ҰҬӇҬӕ>Ҭ@¶ѼӛӅӋҰҬQӃҤӘ>Ӝ@ҰҬѼҤӊҤӇҸӃ>Ӛ@ѸӥҹSӃҤӘҬӆҸӊӥҬ·ѷӃӜҰҬҸӈӆҸҧӜ ӆӅҼӁӅӃҸӈʠ ӆӅ ӅҦӛӕҤӟ ҸӒ>Ӛ@ ҸҶӂӅӁҧҤ ӈӁӅҧҤ ӈҧӅʠ ӇҬӕ>Ҭ@ ¶ѪҫӅӋ[ ӆӅҼӁӅӃҸӊҸӈʠ\ ҧҬӁҸҼӅҹ ҼӃʠҨӛӃҸћҤӇҤҼӕҸӃӅҧҸ·ѹҬӕ>Ҭ@¶ѪҫҸ·µ²$G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lSS +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %'" %DVHGVROHO\RQWKLVVKRUWUHFRUGZHFDQUHDGDERXWWKHQHZRYHUORUGVKLS WKDWWKH0RQJROVKHOGRYHU5XV'DQLORVKRXOGSD\WULEXWHDQG%DWXQDPHG KLP¶="(1(N· DVODYH҄ӅӁӅӆ ZKLFKLQWKLVFRQWH[WPHDQVDVXEMHFWRI%DWX $WWKHHQGRIWKHPHHWLQJ%DWXWROG'DQLORWKDWKHZDVRQHRIWKHP²D7DWDU $OOWKHVXEMHFWVRI'DQLOR HVVHQWLDOO\DOOWKH5XVUXOHUVDQGWKHLUVXEMHFWV  EHFDPH7DWDUV IURPEXUHDXFUDWLFSRLQWRIYLHZLQFOXGLQJ%DWXDOOVXEMHFWV RI0RQJRO(PSLUH²ZKRKROG\DUOLTV²ZHUH7DWDUVLQFOXGLQJDOOWKHQDWLRQV FRQTXHUHGE\WKHP²WKHSHRSOHRI5XVWKH+DQ&KLQHVHHWF 7KHVHSHRSOH ZHUHVXEMHFWWRWKH7DWDUV·¶ZLOO· $QHZ¶QDWLRQDOLW\·RI5XVSHRSOHFKDQJHGDORWLQUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ 5XVZLWKRWKHUUXOHUV$V7DWDUVWKH\FDQXVH0RQJROVPLOLWDU\VXSSRUWEXW DOVRWKH\ZHUHREOLJDWHGWRNQXFNOHXQGHUWKHIRUHLJQSROLF\RINKDQ ,QWKDWQHZUHDOLW\ZHUHDGDERXWYHU\LQWHUHVWLQJHYHQWV´>7KHQ@WKHUH ZDVDIDPLQHLQDOOWKHODQGVDPRQJWKH5XVLDQVWKH3ROHVWKH/LWKXDQL DQVDQGWKH-DWYLQJLDQV7KHQWKH-DWYLQJLDQVVHQWWKHLUHQYR\VWR>3ULQFH@ 9RORGLPHUZKRDGGUHVVHG>KLP@WKXV¶2XU/RUG3ULQFH9RORGLPHU:HKDYH FRPHWR\RX>LQWKHQDPHRI@DOOWKH-DWYLQJLDQVSODFLQJRXUKRSHLQ*RG DQGLQ\RXU>FRQWLQXHG@JRRGKHDOWK0DVWHU'RQRWOHWXVGLHRIVWDUYD WLRQEXWIHHGXVIRU\RXURZQEHQHILW6HQGXV\RXUJUDLQIRUVDOHDQGZH ZLOOJODGO\EX\LW:KDWHYHU\RXGHVLUHEHLWZD[VTXLUUHOEHDYHURUEODFN PDUWHQVNLQVRU>HYHQ@VLOYHUZHZLOOJLYHLWWR\RXJODGO\·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¶,QYDLQGRHVKHGHQ\>WKLV@IRUKHKLPVHOIKDVNLOOHG\RXUPHQ·µ0/*  *'HWDLOHGDQDO\VHVRIPRRWHGLVVXHVHH$-XVXSRYLþM2-f2f-$,3$W6-T;$F(H,21$F.)2.#>/$ ('$0(P#)LQ<(3>(1-$23*$G#3.)214X2-.#)3$X6)(N#;$0(1,.,H217$XH(3(9,H7$23*$G61.6)21$W#12.,(3-$HG$9 0DLRURY5+DXWDOD/RQGRQ1HZ<RUNSS +() *!"#$_21,H,2348(1"/3,23$G")(3,H1#lSÅѸӅӊʚӂ>Ӝ@ҰҬӁӬӊӬҨӅӁʚҫ>Ӛ@Ҧӛӈ>ӊӜ@ӆӅҧӈҬҹ ҶҬӂӁҸҸҧӇӅӋӈҸҸҧӁʠӒӅӒ>Ӛ@ҸҧӁҸӊҧӬҸҧʠӊҧʠӣҬӒ>Ӛ@ѸӅӈҬӂ>Ӝ@ҰҬ˨ӊҧʠӣӬӆӅӈӁҤӘҤӆӅӈӁӛ ӈҧӅҤҼќӅӁʚҫҸӂҬӇӅҧҸӊҤҼӅӇҬ_ҼӅӋӕҸ©ѝ>Ӆ@ӈ>ӆӅ@ҫ>Ҹ@ӃҬҼӃʠҰҬќӅӁʚҫҸӂҬӇҬӆӇӥҬӒҤӁҸҬӈӂӛҼ ӊҬҦӬʚӊ>Ӛ@ҧӈӬӒ>Ӛ@˨ӊҧʠӣӜӃҤҫӬӟӕҸӈʠӃҤћ>ӅҨ@ӚҸӃҤӊҧӅҬҶҫӅӇӅҧӥҬѝ>Ӆ@ӈ>ӆӅ@ҫ>Ҹ@ӃҬӃҬӆӅӂӅӇҸ ӃҤӈ>Ӛ@ӃӅӆҬӇҬҼӅӇӂҸӃҤӈ>Ӛ@ӈҬҦӬӆӅӘӁҸҨ>Ӆ@ӈ>ӆӅ@ҫ>Ҹ@ӃҬҼӃҤӂ>Ӛ@ҰҸӊӅӈҧӅҬӆӇӅҫҤҧҤӊ>Ӛ@Ҥӂӛ %'# $'5,$1-868329,ý +RZZHVHH7KHQH[WSDVVDJHRIWKHDXWKRU·VVRXUFHWH[WEHJLQVZLWKJUHDW SUHFLVLRQ´$IWHUWKDW\HDUµ7KLVSKUDVHLQGLFDWHVWKHQH[W\HDUDFFRUG LQJWRWKH0DUFKVW\OH 0DUFK)HEUXDU\ 7KHERRNPDQ ZURWHDERXWWKHIDPLQHLQ5XV3RODQGDQGDPRQJWKH<RWYLQJLDQVDWWKDW WLPH7KHODVWRIWKHVHDVNHG9ODGLPLUWRVHOOWKHPVRPHRIWKHLUUHVHUYHV :KLOHWKH\ZHUHEHLQJWUDQVSRUWHGWR3XãWXVNWKHSULQFHRI9ODGLPLU·VPHQ ZDVNLOOHG.RQUDG,,RI&]HUVNZDVDFFXVHGRIFRPPLWWLQJWKHGHHG+LV JXLOWZDVFRQILUPHGE\%ROHVãDZ9WKH&KDVWHZKLFKUHVXOWHGLQDQH[SHGL WLRQWR0D]RYLD(YHQWXDOO\WKHFRQIOLFWHQGHGZLWKDSHDFHWUHDW\EHWZHHQ 9ODGLPLUDQG.RQUDG00 :HVHHWKHSDVVDJHWROGXVWKDW9RORGLPHUVHQWIUHLJKWZLWK´JRRGPHQ ӈӚӁӟҫ>Ӝ@ӂҸҶҫӅҦӇӛӂҸ ZKRPKHWUXVWHGµ,QPHGLHYDO5XVWUDGHZDV GHDOWQRWRQO\E\IUHHSHRSOHEXWDOVRE\SHRSOHZKRZHUHGHSHQGVRIUXO HUV2IWHQVXFKSHRSOHZHUHQRWRQO\PHUFKDQWVRIWKHSULQFHEXWDOVR WKH\ZHUHKLVHQYR\V6RPHWLPHVLWKDSSHQHGWKDWPHUFKDQWVZKRGLG QRWGHSHQGRQWKHSULQFHWUDQVSRUWHGWKHJRRGVEHORQJLQJWRWKHUXOHUV RUER\DUV$VZHFDQVHH.RQUDGWKH,,RI&]HUVNRU KLVVXEMHFWVQRW VLPSO\NLOOHGPHUFKDQWVEXWNLOOHG´JRRGPHQµRI9RORGLPHU9DV\ONRYLFK ZKLFKLQWKDWWLPHPD\KDYHSHUIRUPHGQRWRQO\UROHRIPHUFKDQWVEXWDOVR HQYR\VVHQWWRWKH<RWYLQJLDQV7KHVHVDPHDWWDFNHGGLUHFWO\WKHSULQFH RI9RORGLPHUZKRKDGWRUHDFW%HIRUHZHJRIRUZDUGZLWKFRQFOXVLRQZH VKRXOGPRRWDYHU\LPSRUWDQWLVVXH:HGRQRWKDYHDQ\&\ULOOLFGRFXPHQW ZKLFKGHWDLOHGGHVFULEHWUDGHEHWZHHQ5RPDQRYLFKLDQGWKH3LDVWV,QWRWDO ӇҤҫҸҼӅӋӆҸӂ>Ӛ@҇ҬҨӅӁҸҧӚӈӒӅӕҬӘӜҧӅӈҼӅӋӁҸҦӅҦӇӅҧӚӁҸӕӇӚӃӛӒ>Ӛ@ӁҸҼӅӋӃӚҦӬӁҸӁ>Ҹ@ ӈӇҬҦӇҤӁ>Ҹ@Я_ӂӛӇҤҫҸҫҤӂӛªќӚӁʚҫҸӂҬӇ>Ӛ@ҰҬҸҶћҬӇҬӈӊӥҤӆӅӈӁҤҼӃҸӂ>Ӛ@ҰҸӊӅҧӁӅҫҸʠӒ>Ӛ@ ӆӅћӅӋҨӅӋӈӚӁӟҫ>Ӝ@ӂҸҶҫӅҦӇӛӂҸҼӅӂӅӋҧӬӇʠҸҫӅӋәҸӂҰҬҸӂӚӆӅћӅӋҨӅӋҸӊҤҼӅҧӚҶӛҫӅӘҤ ӃҤѵҤӇӅҧӜѪӆӅҸҫӅӘҤӆӅѵҤӇ>Ӛ@ҧҸѪҫӅӋәҸӂ>Ӛ@ҰҬҸӂ>Ӛ@ҸӆӇӥҸҫӅӘҤӆʚҫ>Ӛ@ҨӅӇʚҫ>Ӛ@ӆӅҫ>Ӛ@ _ѸӅӁӊӅҧҬӈҼӜӊӅӋҰ>Ҭ@ҸӈӊҤӘҤӃҤӃӅӕ>Ӝ@ӅӆӅӕҸҧҤӊҸӈӅҦӬҸӊҤҼӅҸҶҦҸӊӛҦӛӘҤҧӈҸӆʚҫ>Ӛ@ ҨӅӇӅҫʚӂ>Ӝ@ҧӃӅӕҸҰҸӊӅӆӅҹӂҤҧ>Ӛ@ӘҬҤӁʚҫ>Ӝ@ҸӆӅӊӅӆҸӘҤќӚӁʚҫҸӂҬӇ>Ӛ@ҰҬҸӈҼҤӘҬӈҬҨӅ ҧҬӁ>Ӝ@ӂҸӒӅӊʠӅӋҧӬҫҤӊҸҼӊӅӈҬӅӋӕҸӃҸӁ>Ӛ@ҤҼӚѮӅӃҫӇҤӊӅҧҸҦӇҤӊӋӈҧӅҬӂӅӋӈӁҤӘҬӊҤҼӅ ӇҬҼҤҬӂӅӋ©ѸӅҫ>Ӛ@ӊҧӅҸӂ>Ӝ@ҨӅӇӅҫʚӂ>Ӝ@ҸҶҦҸӊӛӂӅҸӁӟҫҸҬЯӁӟҦӅӊҧӅҸӂ>Ӝ@ӆӅҧҬӁҬӃӥҬӂӜ ҸӁҸҸӃӅҨӅѼӛҧӬҫҤҬӘӜҧӚӊҧӅҬҸҶҬӂӁҸӆӅҧӬҰӜªѮӅӃҫӇҤӊ>Ӛ@ҰҬӈʠҶҤӆӇӬ©˧ӃҬҸҶҦҸҧҤӁ>Ӛ@ Ҥ ҸӃӅҨӅ ӃҬ ҧӬҫҤӟ ҼӊӅ ҸҶҦҸӁ>Ӛ@ª ѷӁ>Ӝ@Ӄӛ Ұ>Ҭ@ ӆӅҧӬҫҸӁ>Ӛ@ ќӅӁʚҫҸӂҬӇӅӋ ӅӋҹ ҬҨӅ ҼӃʠҶ>Ӝ@ ћӅӁҬӈӁҤҧӚӃҤӈ>ӛ@ӃʚҧӔҤӈҧӅҬҨӅӃҤѮӅӃҫӇҤӊҤӊҤҼӅӇҬҼҤ©ћҬҶӁӬӆҤӊҸӈʠӆӇҸӊ>Ӝ@ҤӈҤӂ>Ӛ@ӊҸ ҸҶҦҸӁ>Ӛ@ӊҸӊҧӅҤӁӟҫҸªµ²$G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lSS  *G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lS +*) *&I0+UXVKHYVN\.KUӅQӅOӅJӤLDSӅGӤǩ*ҤOLWV·NӅ9ӅOLQV·NӅӥOӤWӅSLVӤ´=ҤSLVNLQҤXNӅYӅJӅ WӅYҤULVWYҤӤPҬQӤ6KҬYFKҬQNҤµ;/,  S* ++) *G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232lSS +,) *&KURQLFD*DOLFLDQR9ROLQLDQD«S  * %9 3HUNKDYNR F)#*3#Y#=(Y(#$ )6--=(#$ =6N#H"#-.Y(7$ 0RVFRZ  S  GLVFXVVLRQ RIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ   *,ELGHPS  *,ELGHPS +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %'$ GXULQJWKDQGWKFHQWXULHVWKHUHDUHDERXWGRFXPHQWVIURP5XVWHU ULWRU\$V63DVKLQKDVQRWHGKRZHYHUWKH\DUHQRWHYHQO\GLVWULEXWHG WKURXJKRXWWKLVSHULRGWKHUHDUHNQRZQGRFXPHQWVIURPWKHWKFHQ WXU\IURPWKHWKIURPWKHWKDQGGRFXPHQWVIRUWKHWK* FHQWXU\DORQH%\DQDORJLHVZLWKRWKHUVSDUWRI5XVZHFDQDVVXPHWKDW VXFKGRFXPHQWVH[LVWHG)RUH[DPSOHZHKDYHIHZ&\ULOOLFFKDUWHUVIURP WKFHQWXULHVZLWKUHJDUGVWRWKHSURYLGHVHFXULW\RIPHUFKDQWVE\RWKHU VLGHRIDJUHHPHQW9HU\LQWHUHVWLQJLV¶'UDIWWUHDW\RI6PROHQVNZLWK5LJD DQG*RWODQG WKHVRFDOOHGWUHDW\RIWKHXQNQRZQ6PROHQVNSULQFHRU FROOHFWLRQ. ·IURPWKHSHULRG:HFDQUHDGWKHUHLQGHWDLO DERXWULJKWVRI¶JXHVWV·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´ҨӅӈӊӜµLQWKH0LG GOH$JHVWKLVWHUPPHDQWPHUFKDQWVRPHRQHZKRWUDGHVLQDQRWKHUFLW\ RUFRXQWU\ IRUP&KDUWHURI3ULQFH<DURVODY><DURVODYLFK@WR WKHSHRSOHRI5LJDDERXWIUHHSDVVDJHIRUJXHVWV LQWKHPLGGOHDJHWKLV WHUPPHDQWPHUFKDQWV DFFRUGLQJWR0HQJX7LPXUZRUG FRPPDQG  IURP&KDUWHURI3ULQFH$OH[DQGHU*OHERYLFKSULQFHRI6PR OHQVNFRQILUPLQJWKHULJKWVRIWKHIUHHPRYHPHQWRIPHUFKDQWVEHWZHHQ  *,QDGGLWLRQWKHUHDUHRYHUELUFKEDUNPDQXVFULSWVSUHVHUYHGIURPWKHWKFHQWX U\ KWWSJUDPRW\UXELUFKEDUN 6HH663DVKLQW6--=,#$*(=69#3./$b::^b8::$Y#=(YK$?H"#O3(#$ N(-(O,#7$7LXPHQ·S60.DVKWDQRY%O-"H",#$.#3*#3HJ,$)2VY,.,,2$*(=69#3.,)(Y23,,2$Y$=23H#1,4 2),,2="$-)#*3#Y#=(Y(,$W6-,LQ8(-.(H"32,2$XY)(N2$Y$,-.(),H"#-=(,$)#.)(-N#=),Y#K$g$B]41#.,,6$8K!K$02-"6.( HG71']KDNVRQ($0HO·QLNRYD0RVFRZSS  *0)(#=.$GRJRYRUD6PROHQVNDV5LJRǩL*RWODQGRP WDNQD]\YDHP\ǩ**(>(Y()$3#,VY#-.3(>($-9(4 1#3-=(>($=3,2V,27$,1,$-N,-(=$gdLQ0RQXPHQWD3DODHRJUDSKLFD0HGLL$HYL6HULHV5RVVLFDYRO,5#-$ N16-$23H,#33#-$H"2).#-$)6--#-K$U(3*-$*#-$Q)H",Y#-$963,H,N21#-$*#$W,>27$b::#4b:8#$-,\H1#-HG3*RQQHDX $,YDQRY$.X]QHWVRY%UHVSROSS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ  ,() *&I%93HUNKDYNRF)#*3#Y#=(Y(#$)6--=(#$=6N#H"#-.Y(«SS  *_)29(.2$#N,-=(N2$N(1(H=(>($:2=(Y2$329#-.3,=6$2)=",#N,-=(N2$N,V"-=(>($,$)2.92329$W,>,$($9,)#$ ,$.()>(Y1#LQ0RQXPHQWD3DODHRJUDSKLFD0HGLL$HYL«SS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUH WKHUHLQ  ,*) *F1(Y2)T$*)#Y3#)6--=(>($,2V/=2$c@@^@p$YYKdYRO0RVFRZSS%93HUNKDYNR F)#*3#Y#=(Y(#$)6--=(#$=6N#H"#-.Y(«S ,+) **UDPRWDNQLD]LD,DURVODYD>,DURVODYLFKD@5L]KDQDPRVYRERGQRPSXWLGOLDJRVWHǩSR0HQJX !#9,)(Y,$-1(Y6$cN(Y#1#3,,6dLQ0RQXPHQWD3DODHRJUDSKLFD0HGLL$HYL«SS GLVFXVVLRQ RIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ  %(& $'5,$1-868329,ý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´>7KHQ@WKHUHZDV DIDPLQHLQDOOWKHODQGVDPRQJWKH5XVLDQVWKH3ROHVWKH/LWKXDQLDQVDQG WKH-DWYLQJLDQVµ,QVXFKFDVHV.RQUDGWKH,,ZRUNHGIRUKLVVXEMHFWV,WDOVR GLGQRWFKDQJHDQ\WKLQJHLWKHUEHFDXVHWKHFULPHKDGEHHQFRPPLWWHGDQG 9ODGLPLUZDQWHGWRSXQLVKWKHYLRODWRU,QWKHEHJLQQLQJKHZDQWHGWRXVH GLSORPDWLFPHDQVEXWDIWHUKHUHDOLVHGWKDWWKHMXGJHRIWKHODQGLV.RQUDG WKHVHFRQGKHGLGQRWZDQWWRGRDQ\WKLQJDQGDIWHUWKHZRUGVRI%ROHVãDZ WKH9´,QYDLQGRHV>.RQUDG@GHQ\>WKLV@IRUKHKLPVHOIKDVNLOOHG\RXU PHQµKHZDVIRUFHGWRUHDFW(QYR\VZKRZHUHUHSUHVHQWDQWVRI9ODGLPLU GLHGRQ.RQUDG·VODQG,I9ODGLPLUZDQWHGWRVDYHKLVSRVLWLRQLQH\HVRIKLV VXEMHFWVWKHUHDFWLRQQHHGHGWREHIDVW$SDUWIURPWKDWDFFRUGLQJWRWKH5XV ODZWKHSHUSHWUDWRUVVKRXOGEHSXQLVKHG7KHSODFHRIFULPHZDVSODFHG LQDQRWKHUODQGDQGWKHPDLQFXOSULWZDVWKHSULQFHVRWKHFKRLFHZDVREYL RXV²ZDU7KH&KURQLFOHRI+DO\FK9ROK\QLDQKDVVDYHGRQLWVSDJHVDSUHF HGHQWKRZUHDFWLQVXFKDVLWXDWLRQ 4*4*4 * $V,UHPDUNHGDWWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHWH[WLWLVRQO\PLQRUFRQWULEXWLRQ ,UHDOLVHWKDWGHWDLOHGZRUNRQWKLVWRSLFUHTXLUHVDVHSDUDWHSURMHFWZLWK VKRXOGHQGZLWKDERRNDQGGDWDEDVH,WKDVWREHVDLGWKDWLQPRGHUQVWDWHV ODZLVIRXQGLQVWDWXWHVDQGVXERUGLQDWHUHJXODWLRQVDQGEH\RQGWKDWDOVR LQWKHGHFLVLRQVRIFRXUWVDQGRWKHUDXWKRUL]HGERGLHVZKRDUWLFXODWHWKHVH GRFXPHQWV·PHDQLQJ,GHQWLILFDWLRQRIWKHVRXUFHVLVXQSUREOHPDWLF+RZ ,,) *_)29(.2$=3,2V,2$-9(1#3-=(>($Q1#=-23*)2$_1#O(Y,H"2$-$N(*.Y#)V"*#3,#9$N)2Y2$-Y(O(*3(>($ SHUHGYL]KHQLLDNXSWVRYPH]KGX5LJRǩL6PROHQVNRPLQ0RQXPHQWD3DODHRJUDSKLFD0HGLL$HYL« SS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ   *_)29(.27$Y/*2332,2$(.$,9#3,$=3,2V,2$U#*()2$kW(-.,-12Y,H"2m7$-$N(*)Y#)V"*#3,#9$N)2Y2$-Y(O(*4 QRJRSHUHGYL]KHQLLDNXSFRYPH]KGX6PROHQVNRP5LJRǩL*RWODQGRPLQ0RQXPHQWD3DODHRJUDSKLFD 0HGLL$HYL«SS GLVFXVVLRQRIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHUHLQ  +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %(% HYHUPRUHSUREOHPDWLFLVLGHQWLI\LQJODZLQWKHHDUO\0LGGOH$JHVZKHQ WKHUHZHUHWZR¶OHJDOV\VWHPV·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g21,-V$2>)##9#3.-SUHFHGHQWVPD\ GHYHORSLQWRUXOHVFRPSOHPHQWLQJWKHOHJDOV\VWHP$VIRU>)29(./FKDUWHUV DQGRWKHUZULWWHQVRXUFHV5XVFKURQLFOHVDOVREHFDPHDFFHVVLEOHWRDQ\RQH ZKRFRXOGUHDG 7KH ODZ LQ 1#.(N,-, FROODWHV SUHFHGHQWLDO QRUPV ZLWK UHIHUHQFH WR UHOD WLRQVEHWZHHQWKHSULQFHVRILQGLYLGXDOSULQFLSDOLWLHVDVZHOODVWRLQWHUQD WLRQDOUHODWLRQVZKLFKLQWKH0LGGOH$JHVZHUHVLPSO\UHODWLRQVEHWZHHQ PRQDUFKV7KHVHIXUWKHUSURYLVLRQVWRRNWKHIRUPRIWUDGLWLRQ²NQRZOHGJH ZDVGUDZQIURPWKH1#.(N,-TDERXWKRZDSDUWLFXODULVVXHKDGEHHQUHVROYHG LQ WKH SDVW ,Q WKLV FDVH ZH VHH WKH PDMRU DXWKRULW\ 2Q WKH RQH KDQG WKHVRXUFHSRVVHVVHGLWVRZQDXWKRULW\RQWKHRWKHUKDQGLWDOVRHQJDJHG WKH DXWKRULW\ RI WKH DQFHVWRU WR ZKRVH GHFLVLRQV RQH FRXOG UHIHU LQ WKLV FDVHRQHFDQHYHQGLVWLQJXLVKVHYHUDOSULQFHVZKRHQMR\HGVSHFLDOYHQHUD WLRQDPRQJGHVFHQGDQWVVXFKDV9ODGLPLUWKH*UHDW²WKHDFWXDOIRXQGHU RIWKHLQVWLWXWLRQDOVWDWH²DORQJVLGH<DURVODYWKH:LVH9ODGLPLU0RQRPDNK DQG²IRUWKH5RPDQRYLFKOLQH²5RPDQ0VWLVODYRYLFK 3UHFHGHQWLDOODZ LQFRQWUDVWWRFRGLILHG ¶QRUPDWLYH· ODZLVPRUHIOXLGDQGRIIHUVDEURDGHU VFRSHIRULQWHUSUHWDWLRQLWZDVWKHUHIRUHPRUHVXLWHGWRWKHOHYHORILQWHU QDWLRQDOUHODWLRQVZKHUHQHJRWLDWLRQDQGFRPSURPLVHSOD\HGDQHVVHQWLDO UROH 0RUHRYHU LQ WKLV DSSURDFK WR WKH UHODWLRQVKLS EHWZHHQ PRQDUFKV WKHLPSOHPHQWDWLRQLQ5XVRIWKH%\]DQWLQHFRQFHSWRIUXOHUVDVDIDPLO\ KHDGHGE\WKHHPSHURUPD\KDYHSOD\HGDUROH+RZHYHULWLVDOVRLPSRUWDQW WRQRWHWKDWW6-=2,2$N)2Y*2$LWVHOIZDVDJHQHUDOFROOHFWLRQ$VDUHVXOWWKHXVH %(' $'5,$1-868329,ý RISUHFHGHQWZLWKLQWKHIUDPHZRUNRISRVVLEOHOHJDOLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVZDV DOVRXQDYRLGDEOHLQWKHODZDVLWDSSOLHGWRLQGLYLGXDOV7KLVV\VWHPEULHIO\ GHVFULEHGDERYHFKDQJHGDOLWWOHDIWHUWKH0RQJROFRQTXHVWRI5XVZKHQ WKH5XULNLGVEHFDPHGHIDFWRO2-f2fVWKH0RQJROUHSUHVHQWDWLYHV$WWKLV SRLQWDQRWKHUUXQJLQWKHKLHUDUFK\RISRZHUDSSHDUHGWKHNKDQE\ZKRVH ZLOO /2)1/= WKHSULQFHVH[HUFLVHGSRZHULQWKHLURZQODQGV2QHHIIHFWRIWKLV FKDQJHZDVWKHLQWHQVLYHGHYHORSPHQWRIORFDOODZZLWKLQLQGLYLGXDOSULQFL SDOLWLHVDVLVHYLGHQWIURPWKHVHFRQGKDOIRIWKHWKLUWHHQWKFHQWXU\ (@,-+(7,QPHGLHYDO5XVWKHUHZHUHWZR¶OHJDOV\VWHPV·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ǩ 0DUN .K 0(Y#-.T$ Y)#9#33/="$ 1#.;$ :V$ ,-.(),,$ -(V*23,,2$ ,$ )#*2=.-,(33(,$ N#)#)2O(.=,HG)%8VSHQVNLǩ0RVFRZ9HV·PLU %HOLDHY,YDQ')%$)2V3/="$Y,*2="$)6--=,="$1#.(N,-#,´9UHPHQQLN0RVNRYVNRJRREVK FKHVWYDLVWRULLLGUHYQRVWHLURVVLLVNLNKµ9  SS &KHUHSQLQ /HY 9 W6--=2,2$ ,-.(),(>)2',,2$ *($ b:b$ YK;$ g6)-$ 1#=.-,, 0RVNYD  ,]GDWHO·VWYRѴӅӈҼӅҧӈҼӅҨӅѿӃҸҧҬӇӈҸӊҬӊҤ &KULVWLDQ'DYLGQ$+,-.()/$('$W6--,27$G#3.)21$Q-,2$23*$<(3>(1,2YRO,:33#)$X6)2-,2$ ')(9$0)#",-.()/$.($."#$<(3>(1$X9N,)#2[IRUG%ODFNZHOO  *$-XVXSRYLþM2-f2f-$,3$W6-T;$F(H,21$F.)2.#>/$('$0(P#)LQ<(3>(1-$23*$G#3.)214X2-.#)3$ X6)(N#;$0(1,.,H217$XH(3(9,H7$23*$G61.6)21$W#12.,(3-$HG$90DLRURY5+DXWDOD/RQGRQ1HZ<RUN SS +",& 73+%)#7A*,& (,& ,%"+7*,& %/& #)-*+)(-#%)(A& A(K %(( G")(3,H2$_21,H,23(48(1,3,232K$G")(3,H2$W(923(Y,H,232$HG'DULXV]'ćEURZVNL$GULDQ -XVXSRYLþ0RQXPHQWD3RORQLDH+LVWRULFDVHULHVQRYD;9,.UDNyZ:DUV]DZD 3$8 'ćEURZVNL'DULXV]I23,#1*W(923(P,HV$=)y1$W6-,$c(=K$@`]@^@`DpdK$M,(>)2',2$N(1,./HV4 32.UDNyZ$9$/21 0RQRJUDILH3UDFRZQL%DGDĸQDG']LHMDPL5XVL 8.:,  'HPLGHQNR*ULJRUĦǩ*,DURVODY0XGULǩ9HOLNLǩNQLD]·5XVĦQDXNRYRSRSXNLDUQLǩQDULV .KDUNLY3UDYR )HQQHOO-RKQ/,!"#$G),-,-$('$<#*,#Y21$W6--,2$@`]]^@A]p/RQGRQ/RQJPDQ )HQQHOO -RKQ /, S!"#$ !21#$ ('$ M2./T-$ :3Y2-,(3$ ('$ a()."4X2-.$ W6-T$ 23*$ :.-$ W#'1#&,(3$ ,3$."#$G")(3,H1#-$('$."#$!",).##3."^','.##3."$G#3.6),#-T´5XVVLD0HGLDHYDOLVµ,,,  SS )UDQNOLQ6LPRQ'5,.#)2H/$23*$I(H69#3.2.,(3$,3$X2)1/$<#*,#Y21$W6--,2´6SHFXOXP $-RXUQDORI0HGLHYDO6WXGLHVµ$9  SS *LPRQ7LPRIH\9["2.$XY#3.-$P#)#$W#N().#*$O/$."#$%1*$W6-T$G")(3,H1#6WXGLHV DFURVV'LVFLSOLQHLQWKH+XPDQLWLHVDQG6RFLDO6FLHQFHV;9,,  SS >RSHQDFFHVVKWWSVFRUHDFXNGRZQORDGSGISGI@ *LPRQ7LPRIH\+,-.(),H21$[),.,3>$('$X2)1/$W6-$cHK$@]]]4HK$@p]]d$,3$2$H(9N2)2.,Y#$N#)4 -N#H.,Y#/HLGHQ%RVWRQ%ULOO *UҬNӅY%RULV',DNXEӅYVNLǩљOHNVDQGU,X=ӅOӅWҤLDѷUGҤLҬҬSҤGҬQLҬ0RVFRZ /ҬQLQJUҤG,]GDWHO·VWYR$NDGHPLL1DXN6665 +DOSHULQ&KDUOHV-W6--,2$23*$."#$_(1*#3$+()*#;$!"#$<(3>(1$:9N2H.$(3$<#*,#Y21$W6-4 -,23$+,-.()//RQGRQӂ,QGLDQD8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV>UHSULQWHGLWLRQ@ ,DQLVK1LNRODǩ1$a(Y>()(*-=2,2$1#.(N,-T$,$##$9(-=(Y-=,#$N#)#*#1=,$0RVFRZ,PSHU DWRUVNRHREVKFKHVWYRLVWRULLLGUHYQRVWHLURVVLLVNLNK ,SҤW·ҬYVNҤLDOҬWӅSLV·LQ3ROQRH6REUDQLH5XVVNLNK/HWRSLVHǩYRO,,6DLQW3HWHUVEXUJ ,PSHUDWRUVNDLD$UNKHRJUDILFKHVNDLD.RPPLVVLLD -XVXSRYLþ$GULDQM2-f2f-$,3$W6-T;$F(H,21$F.)2.#>/$('$0(P#)LQ<(3>(1-$23*$G#3.)214X2-.4 #)3$X6)(N#;$0(1,.,H217$XH(3(9,H7$23*$G61.6)21$W#12.,(3-$HG$OH[DQGHU90DLRURY 5RPDQ+DXWDOD/RQGRQ1HZ<RUN5XWOHGJHSS -XVXSRYLþ$GULDQ´G"#)Y#3T$,$,3/$>)2*/$µ()$i>)(*/$H"#)Y#3T-=/,2µt$+,-.()/$('$."#$*(92,3$ ('$G"#)Y#3T$,3$."#$P),..#3$)#H()*$c@]."4@A."$H#3.6),#-dLQU)(9$G"#)Y#3T$!(P3-$.($G6)4 V(3$5,3#$HG0DUFLQ:RãRV]\Q&UDFRZ/HLS]LJ5]HV]yZ:DUVDZ )UK ]HLW2VWPLWWHOHXURSDV,,, SS -XVXSRYLþ$GULDQ(OLW\]LHPLKDOLFNLHMLZRã\ĸVNLHMZF]DVDFK5RPDQRZLF]yZ ² @`DEdK$F.6*,69$N)(V(N(>)2',HV3#.UDNyZ$9$/21 0RQRJUDILH3UDFRZQL %DGDĸQDG']LHMDPL5XVL8QLZHUV\WHWX.D]LPLHU]D:LHONLHJRZ%\GJRV]F]\,,  -XVXSRYLþ$GULDQ!"#$G")(3,H1#$('$+21/H"48(1"/3,2$23*$+,-.(),H21$G(11#H.,(3-$,3$<#*,4 #Y21$W6-T7$/HLGHQ%RVWRQ%ULOO .DVKWDQRY6HUJHǩ0%O-"H",#$.#3*#3HJ,$)2VY,.,,2$*(=69#3.,)(Y23,,2$Y$=23H#1,2),,2="$ -)#*3#Y#=(Y(,$W6-,LQ8(-.(H"32,2$XY)(N2$Y$,-.(),H"#-=(,$)#.)(-N#=),Y#K$g$B]41#.,4 ,6$8K!K$02-"6.(HG7DW·MDQD1']KDNVRQ(OHQD$0HO·QLNRYD0RVFRZ ,D]\NLUXVVNRǩNXO·WXU\SS .KUXVWҤOҬY'HQLV*W6-T$,$9(3>(1T-=(#$32-"#-.Y,#$c`]^C]$>>K$b:::$YKd6DLQW3HWHUVEXUJ (YUD]LLD