:1 of Ap: ::Itorol Rereo'd: or:d Bc World 47(3): 194-201 (2008)
BRA 2008
DOl: 0.3827/IBRA. I .47.3.07
A l RESEARCH ARTICIll
I B R A
Detection and characterization of
Kodamaea ohmeri associated with small
hive beetle Aethina tumida infesting honey
bee hives.
Nicole D Benda", Drion Boucias°, Baldwyn Tort0 3 and Peter Teal'.
LJDA ARS, Center for Med cal, Agricultural, and Veterinary Entomology, 1600-1700 S.W. 23rd Drive, Ca new lie, FL 32608, USA.
n titute of Food and Agricultural Sciences, Department of Entomology and Nematology, University of Florida, 110620, Gainesville,
F! 3261 1, USA.
International Centre of Insect Physiology and Ecology, P0. Box 30772-00)00, Nairobi, Kenya.
Received 20 November 2007, revised manuscript received 8 April 2008, accepted for publication 8 April 2008.
Corresponding author. Email: Nicole.Benda©ars.usda.gov
Summary
Honey bee colony infestation by the small hive beetle (SHB) is associated with fermentation of hive materials. Pollen, beetles, and robbing
bees (ten of each) were collected from hives infested with SHB in both Florida and Kenya. Plating of homogenized bodies of beetles and
bees and comb swabs resulted in smooth cream-colored yeast colonies that formed pseudomycelial cells as they aged. Fatty acid profiles
of yeast isolates from Florida and Kenya most closely matched the profiles of Candida krusei and C. sake, respectively. However, the DNA
sequence of the 28S and 5.8S-ITS2 of both the Florida and Kenya isolates were, 99-100 % homologous to Kodamaea ohmeri. The ITS I
region differed between the two geographic strains. The two strains produced similar volatile profiles which were attractive to SHB and
contained compounds also found in honey bee alarm pheromone.
Detección y caracterización de Kodarnoea o/irneri asociada a la
infestación de colmenas de abejas por el pequeño escarabajo de
las colmenas Aethina turn/do.
Resu men
La infestación de las colmenas de abejas por el pequeno escarabajo de las colmenas (PEC) está asociada a la fermentación de los
materiales de las colmenas. Se recolectó polen, escarabajos y abejas pilladoras de colmenas infestadas con PEC en Florida y Kenia. El
cultivo en placas de homogeneizados del cuerpo de los escarabajos y de las abejas, y de frotis de los cuadros resultó en colonias de
levaduras de color crema que formaron células pseudomiceliales cuando crecieron. El perfll de ácidos grasos de los aislados de
levaduras de Florida y Kenia se aproximó mucho al de Candida krusei y C. sake, respectivamente. Sin embargo, las secuencias de ADN
de las regiones 28S y 5,8S-ITS2 de los aislados de Florida y Kenia fueron 99- 100% homologas a Kodamaea ohmeri. La region ITS I fue
diferente segUn su origen geográfico. Las dos variedades produjeron perflles volátiles similares que son atractivos para el PEC y
contenIan compuestos que también se encuentran en la feromona de alarma de las abejas.
Keywords: Aethina tumido, small hive beetle, Apis mellifera, FKodamaea ohmerl, yeast, volatile attraction
195
Yeast of SHB / honey bee association
Introduction
Materials and Methods
Yeasts occupy a wide variety of habitats where sugars are
available, such as flowers, insect honeydew, and certain plant
material. Insects present in these habitats may acquire (and
vector) the various yeasts. Yeasts have been found in association
with a broad range of insects, including lacewings, bees, and
beetles. In many cases, consistent yeast / insect associations are
observed over a large geographical region. The insect appears to
benefit nutritionally from these yeasts, and it has been suggested
by Suh et al. (2005) that their presence allows insects to survive
on nutrient-limited substrates. Yeasts have commonly been found
in the digestive ti-act of sap beetles (family: Nitidulidae) that feed
on flowers, decaying fruit, fermenting plant juices, and mushrooms
(Lachance and Bow/es, 2002; Suh et al., 2004; Suh, et al., 2006).
The yeasts associated with flower-feeding nitidulids, including
species of Metschnikowia, Wickerhamiella, and Kodamaea
(Lachance and Bowles, 2002: Lachance et 0/., 1999; Lachance et
al., 1998), are distinct from those yeasts (various Candida species)
associated with mushroom feeding sap beetles such as Pa//odes
spp. (Suh et al., 2006). Significantly, yeast-associated fermentation
volatiles attract certain nitidulids (Nout and Bartelt, 1998;
Williams et 0/., 1992) and serve as oviposition cues for these
beetles (Phelan and [in, /991).
Recently, the small hive beetle (SHB) ,Aethina tumida
(Coleoptera: Nitidulidae), a nest parasite of honey bees native to
Africa, has invaded the United States and Australia (Neumann
and Elzen, 2004). The European honey bee used for pollination in
the USA is particularly susceptible to SHB. The beetles feed on
the pollen, brood, and honey, and infestations destroy the colony.
Fermentation of honey in the comb is associated with mass SHB
infestation. From initial sampling of infested hives and SHB, we
isolated a yeast species and identified it as Kodamaea ohmeri. The
yeast grows prolifically on honey bee combs infested with SHB
and this growth produces volatiles attractive to SHB (Torto et al.,
2007). Interestingly, the volatiles overlap with those identified as
alarm pheromone components of honey bees. It is unknown
whether SHB or the honey bee is responsible for the
introduction of these yeasts into the hive. Because yeasts are
commonly found in flowers, bees, and nitidulids, and because
either can become contaminated during the common behavioural
interactions between honey bees and SHB, either or both routes
of entry are feasible.
Reliable procedures to detect and identify K. ohmeri in various
biological samples are necessary to further define the interactions
of this yeast with SHB and honey bees. Herein, we describe how
K. ohmeri was detected in samples from hives of both European
and African honey bees and associated SHB and identified using a
combination of morphological, molecular, and chemical characters.
Isolation and cultivation of the yeast in infested hives
Yeast samples were collected from SHB from four European
honey bee hives maintained at the Centre for Medical,
Agricultural and Veterinary Entomology USDA-ARS (Florida), and
from four African honey bee hives maintained at the International
Centre of Insect Physiology and Ecology (ICIPE) (Kenya). SHB
larvae and adults were removed from an infested hive and
surface-sterilized by immersion in 70% ethanol for —30 seconds
followed by two rinses in sterile water. Homogenates of washed
beetles were prepared in sterile water and resulting suspensions
streaked for isolation on Sabouraud Dextrose Agar plus 1% yeast
extract (SDAY). In addition to insect homogenates, a series of
honey and pollen samples were collected from the infested hive
and inoculated on plates. Sampling tools (metal spatula, forceps,
micropestle) were sterilized with alcohol between individual
samples. Inoculated plates were incubated at 28°C for 1-3 days.
Individual yeast colonies were selected and sub-cultured on
SDAY and incubated at 28°C. Selected isolates were inoculated
into Durham tubes containing autoclaved bee pollen broth (1%
aqueous pollen) and incubated at 3°C for five days.The gasproducing [-27 isolate produced a colony morphology
characteristic of the majority of yeast colonies observed in the
initial isolation.To typify growth on different media types, the [-27
isolate was plated on pollen agar (1% pollen plus 1.5% agar), Lee's
agar, Czapek-Dox broth, malt extract agar, M40Y agar (a high
sucrose, osmotic-stress medium), and moistened autoclaved
pollen. Inoculated plates were incubated at 28°C for 7-10 days.
Fatty acid profile typing
Selected isolates representative of the major colony phenotype
detected from both larval and adult SHB homogenates were subcultured on SDAY (two isolates each from Florida and Kenya
hives). Cells were harvested (80 mg wet weight) and treated
chemically to extract and convert the fatty acids present in the
cell wall or cell membrane fractions to fatty acid methyl esters
(FAMEs). Total cellular fatty acid methyl esters were subjected to
gas chromatographic (GC) analysis. Resulting profiles were
analyzed with the Microbial Identification System (MIDI Inc.) that
matched the test organism's profiles to the available yeast FAME
databases using Sherlock Version 4.5 software (Anonymous,
1993). Similarity indices were calculated: indices of 0 to 0.3, 0.3 to
0.6, and 0.6 to 1.0 were considered as poor, possible, and
excellent matches, respectively.
DNA extraction and PCR amplification
Eight isolates from the Florida hives and two isolates from the
Kenya hives were inoculated in SMY (sabour and maltose with
yeast extract) broth and incubated overnight at 26°C. Cells were
pelleted and DNA was extracted using the Masterpure'° Yeast
DNA purification kit (Epicentre, Madison, WI). The quantity and
quality of the DNA preparations were evaluated using ethidium
bromide-stained agarose gels. Aliquots of DNA were amplified
with a mixture of Taq DNA polymerase (Promega) and PFU
polymerase (Stratagene), using the primers 181 and AB28 for
the ITS-5.8S (Curran, et 0/., 994) and NL- I and NL-4 primers
for the 5' divergent domain (the Dl /D2 region) of the LSU
196
Benda, Boucias, Torro, Teal
rDNA (Kurtzman and Robnett, 1997). PCR products were
extracted using QlAquick PCR extraction kit (Qiagen) and each
PCR-amplicon bidirectionally sequenced using an ABI Prism DNA
Sequencer at the Interdisciplinary Center for Biotechnology
Research Core Facility at the University of Florida, Gainesville, FL.
DNA sequences were compared to those deposited in GenBank
with BLAST (blastn) using the default settings.
Volatile production, collection, and analysis
To compare the yeast strains collected in Florida and Kenya, beecollected pollen (20 g) was inoculated with the L-27 clone from a
Florida hive and an A-I clone from the Kenya hive. To compare
the effect of substrate, three different sterilized media (20 g each)
were inoculated with the L-27 strain (collected from SDAY plates,
diluted in sterile water): I) moistened pollen, 2) moistened
commercial pollen substitute BeePro ® (Mann Lake; Hackensack,
MN, USA) and 3) SDAY (Sabouraud Dextrose Agar plus 1%
yeast extract).
Inoculated and non-inoculated plates were sealed with
Parafllm® and incubated at 28°C for 7 days. After incubation, the
Parafllm® seals and lids were removed and each plate was placed
in a glass aeration chamber (46 cm long x 19 cm wide) (Torto et
al., 2007). Volatiles were collected by passing charcoal-filtered and
humidified air at 0.5 ]/minute over the plate in the aeration
chamber and then through a Super-Q adsorbent trap (30 mg,
Alltech; Nicholasville, KY USA), which trapped the volatiles, for I
hour at room temperature. Chemicals were eluted from traps
with 150 p1 methylene chloride and 174 ng of butyl butyrate
were added as an internal standard to 40 p1 of the extract.
Samples (I p1) were analyzed by gas chromatography on a HP
6890 equipped with a HP-I column (30 m x 0,25 mm ID x 0.25
pm;j &W Scientific; Folsom, California, USA) linked to a HP 5973
mass spectrometer using electron impact mode (70 eV, Agilent;
Palo Alto, CA, USA), with helium as the carrier gas. Samples
were injected in splitless mode at an injector temperature or
240°C, and a split valve delay of 0.5 minutes.
The oven temperature was held at 35°C for I minute, then rorsc.:l
at 10°C / minute to 230°C and held at this temperature for IC
minutes. The ion source temperature was 230°C. Volatile
compounds were identified by comparison of their
chromatographic retention times and mass spectra to those
of commercially available standards analyzed on the same
instrument.
CFU!l0 mg pollen. Interestingly, the robber bees (N= 10)
collected from SHB damaged hives contained yeasts at levels that
ranged from 150 to more than
10 CFU / bee.
Isolates derived from isolation plates grew on various
mycological media as well as Lee's agar, pollen agar, and
moistened pollen. Scant growth was observed when these
cultures were plated on either Czapeks-Dox or M40Y agar plates.
Young —4 day old SDAY cultures appeared as uniform creamcolored, smooth colonies (Fig. IA). These colonies contained
globose to ellipsoidal multi-polar budding yeast cells, ranging from
2-7 pm in diameter, with the majority of cells under 4 pm in
diameter (Fig. 2B). As the cultures aged, pseudomycelial cells
formed, changing the colony morphology (Fig. I B). Within five
days post-inoculation, crenellated colonies with an undulate
surface formed on SDAY plates. The pseudomycelium consisted
of chains of cylindrical cells 2-3 pm in diameter (occasionally
swollen larger) by 9-20 pm in length (Fig. 2C) Small raised scars
Smooth colony phenotype (A) of the L-27 isolate
incubated for 3 days at 26°C on SDAY Differential interference
contrast (DIC) micrograph of cells (B) harvested from smooth
colony. Note presence of numerous ovoid to oblong shaped
yeast cells. Bar represents 10 microns.
Fig I.
Results
'
t\
Yeast prevalence and morphology
Preparations of larval and adult SHB, comb material (pollen,
honey), and associated robber bees (from heavily infested hives)
produced a lawn of uniform yeast colonies within 36 h when
plated on SDAY Spot dilution plating of these preparations
demonstrated that the number of yeast colonies varied among
the different samples. All of the SHB larvae (N= 10) sampled from
heavily infested hives consistently harboured yeasts (I 03 101
colony forming units or CFU I larvae) whereas 8 of 10 adult SHB
harboured fewer yeasts (10- 100 CFU / adult). The presence of
yeast in pollen samples was variable and ranged from 0 to 100
,
—
ut
t
C
'C- ''
e
n
. L
,
•—
c
"
Fig 2. The
\
:'
C- --
'
t',
-
-
L-27 cultures after 7 days on SDAY at 26°C produce
a matte-like, wrinkled colony phenotype (A, B). DIC images of
the cells (C, D) reveal the presence of elongate hyphal bodies
intermixed with round oblong cells. In certain field, the base
of these cells appeared to be swollen (D). Bars represent
15 microns.
197
Yeast of SHB / honey bee association
Summary of FAME profiles of the Florida ([-28) and Kenya (A- I) yeast isolates. Note the difference in library match
between these geographical isolates. RI retention time.
Table I.
Yeast L-28
RT
1.652
1.753
7.185
8.715
9.995
0.067
10.37
11.733
3.364
13.457
13.846
14.228
6.055
Peak Name
SOLVENT PEAK
Percent
14:0
15:0
16:1 Cis 7 (w9)
16:1 Cis 7 (co7)
16:0
17:1 Cis 9 ((o8)
18:2 CIS
0.65
0.21
0.39
5.32
13
0.98
9,12118:0a
20.02
Summed
Feature 8*
18:0
Summed
Feature 10*
18:0 20H
13.815
57.82
0.98
13.906
14.301
14.674
Peak Name
SOLVENT PEAK
Percent
14:0
16:1 Cis9(w7)
6:0
17:1 Cis9(w8)
18:2 CIS
9, 12/18:Oa
Summed
Feature8*
18:0
Summed
Feature 10*
1.49
10.09
6.3
0.91
25.29
43.15
1.65
1.12
0.35
0.27
Library Results
0704, Candida krusei
YST28
krusei krusei*
3.80
YSTCLN
3.80
Yeast A-I
RT
2.323
2.583
2.646
7.705
10.546
10.846
12.2
Library Results
0763, Candida sake
YST28
3.80
0.828, Candida krusei
*Summed features consist of the following fatty acids, which could not be separated. Summed Feature 8: 18:1 CIS9 ((09) and/or
I 8: I (w8); Summed Feature 10: I 8: I Cis 9 DMA and/or an unknown (ECL I 8.21 8).
on pseudomycelial cells indicated the prior formation of yeast
cells and / or the prior points of attachment for branches.
Adjacent cells were separated by constrictions, not by formal
septal structures. The K. ahmeri strains isolated from the hives
reproduced asexually by multilateral budding. Attempts at
crossing different isolates on MEA malt extract agar plates did
not result in ascospore formation.
Fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) analysis
MIDI anaysis associated both the Florida (L-27, L-28) and Kenya
(A- 1, A-2) isolates with species in the genus Candida (Table I).
Fatty acid profiles generated from cultures of the L-27 and [-28
strains were most similar to the profiles of the Candida krusei
reference (similarity indices 0.704 and 0.828). The profiles of
Kenya isolates A- I and A-2 were most similar to the profiles of
C. sake and C. va/ida (similarity index 0.763 and 0.62 I).
DNA analysis
PCR-amplification of the 28S (D 102) and ITS 1-5.8S-ITS2 of the
Florida L-27 isolate produced 509 bp and 377 bp fragments (Fig.
3). The 28S and ITS I -5.8S-ITS2 DNA sequences for the [-27
isolate have been submitted to the GenBank database and
assigned accession numbers AY9 11384 and AY9 11385
respectively. The ITS I 5.8S-ITS2 DNA sequence for the A-I
isolate has also been submitted to GenBank (accession number
of both the
EU569326). BLAST searches (Altschul et al., 1997)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
3. Eth dium bromide stained gel of the Florida [-27 (lanes 2,
3), and the Kenya A-I (lanes 4,5) and A-2 (lanes 6, 7) amplified
with primers for the DI /D2 region of the 28S rDNA (lanes 2, 4,
6) and the ITS I-5.8S-ITS2 rDNA (lanes 3, 5, 7). Lane I contains
molecular weight markers (100-1000 bp).
Fig
partial 28S and ITS I-5.8S-ITS2 sequences produced matches with
extremely low Expect (E) values. The 509 bp D I /D2 sequence
was identical to the culture established from the type strain of
Endamycapsis ohmeri ( Kodamaea ohmeri) (GenBank U45702),
as well as other strains of K. ahmeri (AF335976, AY26782 I,
AY267824), and to an unidentified yeast (AF335975). Since
98
Benda, Boucias, Torto, Teal
L- 27 a-AD 28
A-la-AB28
TGTTTCCGTAGGTGCC TGCGGAAG GATCATTCATAATATTC TTACACAC TGTTTTT 60
TGTTTCCGTAGGTGAACCTGCGGAAGGATCAT TAACATTAATTTACTACACACTGTTTTT
60
************************************** * ** **************
L-27a-AB28
A-la-AB28
TTACAACAAAACAAACATATCTAATCTATAAAT CTACGTTTTAAAATTCTTAAAACTTTC 120
TTAAAACTTTC 118
*************** *******
* ** ***
L-27a-AB28
A-la-AB28
CAACGGATCTCTTGGTTCTCGCATCGATGGA ACGCAGCGATGCGATACGTAATA 180
CAACGGATCTCTTGGTTCTCGCATCGATGGA ACGCAGCGATGCGATACGTAATA 178
************************************************************
L-27a-AB2S
A-la-AB28
CGAATCGCAGCTCTCGGAATCATCGAATCTTTG CGCACATTGCACCATTGGGTATTCC 240
CGAATCGCAGCTCTCGGAATCATCGAATCTTTGAACGCACATTGCACCATTGGGTATTCC 238
**************************** ********************************
L-27a-AB28
A-la-AB28
CAATGGTATGCTTGTTTGAGCGAATACTTCCCTA ATCCTCACGGATTGTATTGTGTTTGC 300
CAATGGTATGCTTGTTTGAGCGAATACTTCCCTAA TCCTCACGGATTGTATTGTGTTTGC 298
**** ********************************************************
L-27a-AB28
A-la-AB28
ACGAAAATAATGACGACAGTACTCTACAAAACG GTACCGTCAGTACGCTCATTTTTTTTC 360
ACGAAAATAATGACGACAGTACTCTACAA CGGTACCGTCAGTACACTCATTTTTT
358
********************************************** *********** *
L-27a--AB28
A-la-AB2S
CTC 355
TCA 361
Fig 4.
Alignment of the ITS I -5.8S-ITS2 sequence of the Florida ([-27) and Kenya (A- 1)yeast isolates. The shaded region in the ITS2
region demonstrates the heterogeneity between the geographical isolates. The underlined sequence represents the small subunit
5.8S rDNA.
U45702 is the type sequence, these results suggest that the yeast
conserved 5.8S gene had 80% homology to available C. sake
we found associated with SHB honey bee hive infestation is K.
sequences. Furthermore, the Dl /D2 region of different C. sake
ohmeri. Other similar sequences may be from misidentified
28S genes had little homology to the corresponding A I
cultures. For example, although the two C. membronifociens
sequence.
sequences Aj508563 and AB304737 were identical to the 28S
DNA sequence of L-27, the identities of these strains are suspect, Analysis of volatiles released from yeast
as they do not match the C. membronifoc/ens type sequence
Yeast samples from both the Florida and Kenya hives ([-27 and
(U45792). Since the 28S sequences from the Kenya A-I and A-2
A- 1)released a complex ofvolatiles when grown on media
isolates were identical to the 28S sequence of the Florida L-27
containing pollen. These included: 3-hydroxy-2-butanone, 2- ethyl
strain, these isolates were also grouped with K. ohmeri. Because
propionate, 3-methyl-butan- I -ol, 2-methyl-butan I -ol, ethyl-2both the 28S and ITS 1-5.8S-ITS2 DNA sequences of the different methyl propionate, 2-methylpropyl acetate, ethyl butyrate, ethylisolates were identical within country of origin, isolates of the
2-hydroxy propionate, isopentyl acetate, 2-methylbutan- I -yl
Florida [-27 and Kenya A-I were deposited at the Agricultural
acetate, 2-heptanone, ethyl pentanoate, 3-octanone, 2-octanone,
Research Service Culture Collection (accession number NRRL 1ethyl hexanoate, ethyl 3-hexenoate, hexyl acetate, and ethyl
48473).
heptanoate (Fig. 5). As shown in Fig. 5, the ratios of the
Further confirming the identity of [-27 as K. ohmeri, the 5.8S
compounds released by [-27 and A-I were essentially identical.
sequence was 99-100% homologous to various K. ohmeri
SDAY media inoculated with yeast released only 3-methyl-butan(AY 168786, AF2 19004, AF2 I 8977) and several unidentified yeast
I -ol and 2-methyl-butan I -ol, and the amounts released were
isolates (AF5362 I I, AF536209). The ITS2 and 5.8S regions and
significantly lower than those released by yeast growing on media
the short sequences of the flanking I 8 and 28S subunits of the
containing pollen (Table 2). Interestingly, these same volatiles were
Florida and Kenya isolates were highly similar (Fig. 4). However,
collected from yeast growing on Bee-Pro plus SDAY media and
the ITS region of the [-27 sequence was distinct from both
non-inoculated Bee-Pro plus SDAY media. SDAY media alone
Kenya isolates, varying by 13 base pairs and 2 deletions.
produced none of the volatiles identified as being released by
Interestingly, it was the Kenya ITS I sequences that had 100%
yeast (Table 2).
homology to available K, ohmeri BLAST database sequences.
Comparing the results of the FAME and BLAST analyses, the
Florida [-27 sequence of the highly conserved 5.8S gene had only
78% homology to available C. krusei sequences. Furthermore, the
DI /D2 region of different C. krusei 28S genes (AY305680,
AY305674) had little homology to corresponding sequences
generated from the SHB yeasts. The Kenya A-I sequence of the
Yeast of SHB
199
I honey bee association
a,
C
0
a
a,
0
U
a)
a)
0
12.00
9.00
6.00
0
Time (min)
Fig 5. Representative
total ion chromatograms of Super Q volatile extracts of control and yeast-inoculated media. A) Sterilized
bee-collected pollen control, B) sterilized bee-collected pollen inoculated with yeast (A- I) from larvae of the SHB from African
honey bee colonies in Kenya, and C) sterilized bee-collected pollen inoculated with yeast (L-27) from larvae of the SHB from
European honey bee colonies in Florida. I- 3-hydroxy-2-butanone, 2- ethyl propionate, 3- 3-methyl-butan- I -ol, 4- 2-methyl-butan- I ol, 5- ethyl-2-methyl propionate, 6-2-methylpropyl acetate, 7- ethyl butyrate, 8- ethyl-2-hydroxy propionate, 9- isopentyl acetate,
10- 2-methylbutan- I -yl acetate, I I - 2-heptanone, 12- ethyl pentanoate, 13- 3-octanone, 14- 2-octanone, 5- ethyl hexanoate, I 6butyl butyrate, the internal standard.
ethyl 3-hexenoate, 17- hexyl acetate, 18- ethyl heptanoate, 19- unknown, 20- unknown. IS
Volatiles collected from SDAY media either inoculated with yeast or not and containing various supplements. (+++)
indicates high levels of compound; (++) indicates amounts less than 50% of +++, (+) indicates amounts less than 20% of +++
and (-) indicates no detectable amount.
Table 2.
Compound
SDAY+
Yeast+
SDAY+
Yeast
Pollen
SDAY+
Yeast+
+
Bee-Pro
+
+
+
+
+
+
Pollen
3-hydroxy-2-butanone
+++
+
Eth yl propionate
3-methy1-1-butanol
+++
++
+
2-m ethyl -l-butanol
EthyI-2-methylpropionate
+++
2-methylpropyl acetate
Ethyl butanonate
+++
Ipentyl acetate
2-methyl- I -butanol acetate +++ +++
ptanone
+++
Ethyl pentanoate
++±
3-octanone
+++ 2-octanone
Ethyl-2-hydroxy propionate
Ethyl hexanoate
Ethyl-3-henenoate______
Hexyl acetate
Ethyl heptanoate
+++
+++
SDAY+
SDAY+
+
+
Bee-Pro
SDAY
200
Benda, Boucias, Torto, Teal
Discussion
In general, the samples from honey bee hives heavily infested with yeasts (and other microorganisms) are found in healthy hives,
SHB yielded a lawn of morphologically consistent yeast colonies.
but only K. ohmer/ was present at the height of SHB infestation.
Similar samples from healthy hives yielded several species of
What prevents other yeasts from growing under these
filamentous fungi and yeasts (N. Benda, unpublished). The
circumstances is not understood and calls for investigation.
predominant colony phenotype detected in the SHB hives (and
identified as K. ohmeri) was similar to that of the K. ohmeri isolate
described by Suh and Blackwell (2005). Failure to induce
ascospore formation by crossing different isolates is consistent
with observations by Suh and Blackwell (2005). These
researchers found no ascospore formation when crossing various
We thank E. R. Dickstein (Bacterial Identification and Fatty Acid
K. ohmeri strains. The sequences AJ508563 and AB304737 were
Lab, University of Florida) for conducting the MIDI analysis: the
identical to the 28S DNA sequence of L-27, and therefore should
UF ICBR Sequencing Facility: Dusti Purcell, Alfredo Platinetty,
be assigned to K. ohmeri rather than C. membranifaciens. The
Steve Willms (U.S. Department of Agriculture Center for
problem is almost certainly the result of a nomenclatural
Medical, Agricultural, and Veterinary Entomology), and Eluid Mull
problem, but because there is no mechanism for third-party
(International Center of Insect Physiology and Ecology) for
annotation of GenBank entries, the original submitters have been
technical assistance: and the advice of Cletus P Kurtzman
notified and must be relied on to make the corrections.
(Microbial Genomics and Bioprocessing Research, USDA-ARS).
Isolates sampled from the SHB infested European honey bee
hives and from the SHB infested African honey bee hives
produced distinct FAME profiles that were matched with different
yeasts. These results highlight strain differences between the
isolates from Florida and Kenya. It should be noted that minor
changes in nutrient inputs has been reported to modulate fatty
ALTSCHUL, S F, MADDEN, T L; SCHAEFER A A; ZHANG,J H; ZHANG, Z;
acid profiles (Kellogg et al., 1999). This, and the absence of large
MILLER, W; LIPMAN, D (1997) Gapped BLAST and PSI-BLAST; a new
generation of protein database search programs. Nucleic Acids Research
numbers of insect-associated yeasts in the FAME database, may
25(17); 3389-3402.
account for differences in the FAME profiles and in the
ANONYMOUS (1993) Microbial Identification System operating manual (Version 4)..
differences between the FAME and BLAST search results of the
Microbial ID Inc.; Newark DE, USA.
strains we isolated. The marked differences at sites in the ITS I
CURRAN,j; DRIVER, F; BALLARD,) W 0; MILNER, R (1994) Phylogeny of
region of the DNA sequence provide additional support of strain
Metorhizium - analysis of ribosomal DNA-sequence data. Mycolog i
cal Research
differences between the Florida and Kenya isolates.
98; 547-552.
Limited sampling has demonstrated an association between
KELLOGG,) A; BANKERT D A; CHATURVEDI V (1999) Variation in Microbial
Identification System accuracy for yeast identification depending on
the yeast, SHB, and honey bee hive in two distant locations
commercial source of Sabouraud dextrose agar)ournal of Clinical Microbiology
(Florida, USA and Nairobi, Kenya). The yeast growing on pollen
37(6):2080-2083.
sources produces bee alarm pheromones that serve to recruit
KURTZMAN, C P; ROBNEUi C J (1997) Identification of clinically important
additional SHB (Torto et al., 2007). Interestingly, the yeast
ascomycetous yeasts based on nucleotide divergence in the 5' end of the
produced these attractants only when grown on media containing
large-subunit (26S) ribosomal DNA gene.)ournol of Clinical Microbiology 35(5);
pollen and not on media containing the commonly used pollen
1216-1223.
substitute Bee-Pro, which lacks pollen. Pollen collected by bees
LACHANCE M A; BOWLES,) M (2002) Metschnikowio orizorsensis and
Metschnikowio dekortorum, two new large-spored yeast species associated with
may contain factors required for the yeast to produce the alarm
florjcolous beetles, FEMS Yeast Research 2(2); 81-86.
pheromones and other volatiles attractive to beetles.
LACHANCE, M A; BOWLES, j M; STARMER, W T; BARKER, S F (1999) Kodomoeo
j
How the yeast initially enters the hive is not well understood.
kokoduensis and Coridido tolerons, two new ascomycetous yeast species from
Potentially, adult beetles originating from heavily damaged hives or
Australian Hibiscus flowers. Conodion )ournol of Microbiology 45(2); 172-177.
from some unknown substrate inoculates the healthy hives with
LACHANCE, M A; ROSA, CA; STARMER, W T; SCHLAG-EDLER B; BARKER,] S F;
yeast residues. Association of K. ohmeri with two other nitidulid
BOWLES, J M (1998)
Wickerhamiella oustroliensis, Wickerhamiella cocticolo,
species has been documented (Suh and Blackwell, 2005). Other
Wicker6omiello occidentolis, Condido drosophilae and Condida lipophila, five new
yeasts may also be associated with SHB. The quantification and
related yeast species from flowers and associated Insects. lnternotiarial)ournal
of Systematic Bacteriology 48; 1431-1443.
identity of these other yeasts and the quantification of K. ohmeri
NEUMANN, P; ELZEN. P (2004) the biology of the small hive beetle (Aethirsa
on SHB should be resolved. Although many insect-yeast
tumido, Coleoptera; Nitidulidae); Gaps in our knowledge of an invasive species.
associations have been identified, the type of interaction
Apidologie 35(3): 229-247.
(mutualism, commensalism, or even competitive) is rarely
NOUTi M J R; BARTELT R (1998) Attraction of a flying nitidulid (Carpophilus
understood. Understanding the relationship between SHB and
humerolis) to volatiles produced by yeasts grown on sweet corn and a cornK. ohmeri will help in developing control strategies for SHB. The
based mediumjournol of Chemicol Ecology 24(7): 1217-1239.
attractiveness of yeast-inoculated pollen to SHB (Torto et al.,
PHELAN, P L; LIN, H C (1991) Chemical characterization of fruit and fungal
volatiles attractive to dried-fruit beetle, Corpophilus hemipserus (L)
2007) indicates a relationship beneficial to the beetle. Other
(Coleoptera, Nitidulidae).)ournal of Chemical Ecology 17(6); 1253-1272.
Acknowledgements
References
Yeast of SHB
I honey bee association
SUH, S 0; BLACKWELL, M (2005) Four new yeasts in the Candela mesentenca
dade associated with basidiocarp-feeding beetles. Mycologio 97( l): 67-177.
SUH, S 0; MCHUGH, j V; BLACKWELL M (2004) Expansion of the Condida
tanzowoensis yeast dade: 16 novel Condido species from basidiocarp-feeding
beetles. International Journol of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology 54:
2409-2429.
SUH, S 0; NGUYEN, N H; BLACKWELL, M (2005) Nine new Candida species near
C. membronifociens isolated from insects. Mycological Research 109: 1045-1056.
SUH, S 0; NGUYEN, N H; BLACKWELL, M (2006) A yeast dade near Cosdido
kruisii uncovered: nine novel Condido species associated with basidioma-feeding
beetles. Mycological Research 110: 1379-1394,
TORTO, B; BOUCIAS, D G; ARBOGAST, RI; TUMLINSON, J H; TEAL, P E A
(2007) Multitrophic interaction facilitates parasite-host relationship between
an invasive beetle and the honey bee. Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences of the United States of America 104(20); 8374-8378.
WILLIAMS, RN; BLACKMER,J L; RICHMOND, D 5; ELLIS, M 5 (1992) Nitidulidae
(Coleoptera) diversity in three natural preserves in Portage County, Ohio. Ohio
Journal ef Science 92(4): 82-87.
201