Papers by Benjamin Gilbert
Ecological theory produces opposing predictions about whether differences in the timing of life h... more Ecological theory produces opposing predictions about whether differences in the timing of life history transitions, or ‘phenology’, promote or limit coexistence. Phenological separation is predicted to create temporal niche differences, increasing coexistence, yet phenological separation may competitively favour one species, increasing fitness differences and hindering coexistence. We experimentally manipulated relative germination timing, a critical phenological event, of two annual grass species,Vulpia microstachysandV. octoflora, to test these contrasting predictions. We parameterized a competition model to estimate within-season niche differences, fitness differences, and coexistence, and to estimate coexistence when among-year fluctuations of germination timing occur. Increasing germination separation caused parallel changes in niche and fitness differences, with the net effect of weakening within-year coexistence. Both species experienced a competitive advantage by germinatin...
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 2017
Ecological drift causes species abundances to fluctuate randomly, lowering diversity within commu... more Ecological drift causes species abundances to fluctuate randomly, lowering diversity within communities and increasing differences among otherwise equivalent communities. Despite broad interest in ecological drift, ecologists have little experimental evidence of its consequences in nature, where competitive forces modulate species abundances. We manipulated drift by imposing 40-fold variation in the size of experimentally assembled annual plant communities and holding their edge-to-interior ratios comparable. Drift over three generations was greater than predicted by neutral models, causing high extinction rates and fast divergence in composition among smaller communities. Competitive asymmetries drove populations of most species to small enough sizes that demographic stochasticity could markedly influence dynamics, increasing the importance of drift in communities. The strong effects of drift occurred despite stabilizing niche differences, which cause species to have greater popula...
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Global Ecology and Biogeography, 2015
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Forest Ecology and Management, 2017
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
The American Naturalist, 2016
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Global Ecology and Biogeography, 2020
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Functional trait data for transplants and individuals of the resident community within blocks. Bl... more Functional trait data for transplants and individuals of the resident community within blocks. Blocks consisted of a “no competition plot”, a “competition plot”, and a control plot of the resident community and varied in their soil moisture. The traits measured include specific leaf area, leaf dry matter content, height, stem specific density, and plant biomass. All traits were measured at the end of the growing season. See the README file and description of Methods in the paper for metadata
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
The American Naturalist, 2020
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Epidemics, 2019
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Oikos, 2018
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Functional Ecology, 2018
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
The American naturalist, 2018
The order of species arrival at a site can determine the outcome of competitive interactions when... more The order of species arrival at a site can determine the outcome of competitive interactions when early arrivers alter the environment or deplete shared resources. These priority effects are predicted to be stronger at high temperatures, as higher vital rates caused by warming allow early arrivers to more rapidly impact a shared environment. We tested this prediction using a pair of congeneric aphid species that specialize on milkweed plants. We manipulated temperature and arrival order of the two aphid species and measured aphid population dynamics and milkweed survival and defensive traits. We found that warming increased the impact of aphids on the quantity and quality of milkweed, which amplified the importance of priority effects by increasing the competitive exclusion of the inferior competitor when it arrived late. Warming also enhanced interspecific differences in dispersal, which could alter relative arrival times at a regional scale. Our experiment provides a first link be...
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Conflicting hypotheses predict how traits mediate species establishment and community assembly. T... more Conflicting hypotheses predict how traits mediate species establishment and community assembly. Traits of newly establishing individuals are predicted to converge, or be more similar to the resident, preexisting community, when the biotic or abiotic environment favors a single best phenotype, but are predicted to diverge when trait differences reduce competitive interactions. We tested these competing hypotheses using transplant seedlings in an old-field environment, and assessed the contribution of inter- and intra-specific transplant trait variation to community-level patterns. Using a soil moisture gradient and resident plant removals, we determined when traits of newly-establishing plants converge or diverge from the resident community by calculating community weighted mean traits for transplant and resident communities. We saw evidence of environmentally- and competitively-driven trait shifts that resulted in both trait convergence and divergence from the resident community, whose traits reflect the combined effects of both drivers. Leaf dry matter content (LDMC) of transplants diverged in the presence of competition, whereas plant height and stem-specific density (SSD) showed the opposite pattern, converging with the resident community in their presence. Specific leaf area (SLA) shifted with competition but did not reflect resident community SLA. All transplant traits were influenced by soil moisture, often in an interaction with competition, indicating that the strength of convergence or divergence is contingent on the abiotic environment. Intraspecific differences in transplant traits among treatments were evident in three of four traits; intraspecific height and SLA trends mirrored transplant community-level trends, whereas intraspecific shifts in SSD were distinct from community-level trends. Our study shows competition between plant species may cause traits of newly establishing plants to converge with the resident community, as frequently as it selects for trait divergence. These opposing effects of competition suggest that it plays a pervasive role in both intraspecific and species-level trait differences among communities
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Evolution, 2018
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Ecology and evolution, Apr 1, 2017
The ecological niche is a multi-dimensional concept including aspects of resource use, environmen... more The ecological niche is a multi-dimensional concept including aspects of resource use, environmental tolerance, and interspecific interactions, and the degree to which niches overlap is central to many ecological questions. Plant phenotypic traits are increasingly used as surrogates of species niches, but we lack an understanding of how key sampling decisions affect our ability to capture phenotypic differences among species. Using trait data of ecologically distinct monkeyflower (Mimulus) congeners, we employed linear discriminant analysis to determine how (1) dimensionality (the number and type of traits) and (2) variation within species influence how well measured traits reflect phenotypic differences among species. We conducted analyses using vegetative and floral traits in different combinations of up to 13 traits and compared the performance of commonly used functional traits such as specific leaf area against other morphological traits. We tested the importance of intraspecif...
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Proceedings. Biological sciences, May 25, 2016
Patch size and isolation are predicted to alter both species diversity and evolution; yet, there ... more Patch size and isolation are predicted to alter both species diversity and evolution; yet, there are few empirical examples of eco-evolutionary feedback in metacommunities. We tested three hypotheses about eco-evolutionary feedback in a gall-forming fly, Eurosta solidaginis and two of its natural enemies that select for opposite traits: (i) specialization and poor dispersal ability constrain a subset of natural enemies from occupying small and isolated patches, (ii) this constraint alters selection on the gall fly, causing phenotypic shifts towards traits resistant to generalist and dispersive enemies in small and isolated patches, and (iii) reduced dispersal evolves in small, isolated populations. We sampled patches in a natural metacommunity and found support for all hypotheses; Eurosta's specialist wasp parasitoid attacked fewer galls in small and isolated patches, generating a selection gradient that favoured small galls resistant to predation by a dispersive and generalist ...
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Ecology, 2005
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Ecology Letters, 2014
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Modern coexistence theory is increasingly used to explain how differences between competing speci... more Modern coexistence theory is increasingly used to explain how differences between competing species lead to coexistence versus competitive exclusion. Although research testing this theory has focused on deterministic cases of competitive exclusion, in which the same species always wins, mounting evidence suggests that competitive exclusion is often historically contingent, such that whichever species happens to arrive first excludes the other. Coexistence theory predicts that historically contingent exclusion, known as priority effects, will occur when large destabilizing differences (positive frequency-dependent growth rates of competitors), combined with small fitness differences (differences in competitors’ intrinsic growth rates and sensitivity to competition), create conditions under which neither species can invade an established population of its competitor. Here we extend the empirical application of modern coexistence theory to determine the conditions that promote priority...
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Plant Ecology, 2016
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Uploads
Papers by Benjamin Gilbert