Books
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Is dialogue always the productive political and communicative tool it is widely conceived to be? ... more Is dialogue always the productive political and communicative tool it is widely conceived to be? Resisting Dialogue reassesses our assumptions about dialogue and, in so doing, about what a politically healthy society should look like. Juan Meneses argues that, far from an unalloyed good, dialogue often serves as a subtle tool of domination, perpetuating the underlying inequalities it is intended to address.
Meneses investigates how “illusory dialogue” (a particular dialogic encounter designed to secure consensus) is employed as an instrument that forestalls—instead of fostering—articulations of dissent that lead to political change. He does so through close readings of novels from the English-speaking world written in the past hundred years—from E. M. Forster’s A Passage to India and Jeanette Winterson’s The Passion to Indra Sinha’s Animal’s People and more. Resisting Dialogue demonstrates how these novels are rhetorical exercises with real political clout capable of restoring the radical potential of dialogue in today’s globalized world. Expanding the boundaries of postpolitical theory, Meneses reveals how these works offer ways to practice disagreement against this regulatory use of dialogue and expose the pitfalls of certain other dialogic interventions in relation to some of the most prominent questions of modern history: cosmopolitanism at the end of empire, the dangers of rewriting the historical record, the affective dimension of neoliberalism, the racial and nationalist underpinnings of the “war on terror,” and the visibility of environmental violence in the Anthropocene.
Ultimately, Resisting Dialogue is a complex, provocative critique that, melding political and literary theory, reveals how fiction can help confront the deployment of dialogue to preempt the emergence of dissent and, thus, revitalize the practice of emancipatory politics.
-
Deepening and widening a furrow first plowed by Jacques Rancière and Slavoj Žižek, Resisting Dialogue marks a refusal to underwrite ‘postpolitics’ as politics by insisting that unspeakable political ambition take its place, without apology, so that our voyage from a troubled modernist literature to the Anthropocene maps, simultaneously, a continuous trajectory and a jarring, disjunctive continuity.
— Grant Farred, Cornell University
-
Resisting Dialogue draws on literature to develop a fresh vocabulary of political activism and thetic force. Contrarianism, deadlock, impasse, silence, resilience, persistence, the power of unexceptional figures of history to block and oppose the status quo—these immobilizing postures acquire a make-over as acts of agency that contest the eclipse of political agency besetting progressive theories of the Political.
— Emily Apter, author of Unexceptional Politics: On Obstruction, Impasse and the Impolitic
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Articles, Book Chapters (Selected)
Afropolitan Literature as World Literature , 2020
This chapter explores the strengths and weaknesses of an Afropolitan approach to environmental ju... more This chapter explores the strengths and weaknesses of an Afropolitan approach to environmental justice as a solution to the depoliticization caused by the irruption of neoliberal development in certain rural communities in Africa. In particular, it examines South African author Zakes Mda's novel The Heart of Redness (2000) as an illustration of the difficulties for the Xhosa people in the fictional village of Qolorha to balance the historical tensions that divide them and the possibility to protect their relationship with the land they inhabit. Appearing at the center of this dispute is the protagonist of the novel, Camagu, a man from Johannesburg who decides to return to newly democratized South Africa after living in the United States for thirty years. An outsider to the village, Camagu emerges as a self-nominated mediator in search of a solution that fits both parties.
Camagu’s presence, however, introduces a new element of imbalance in the village, as his conservationist yet nostalgic views of his home country merge with his disdain with the neoliberal culture that he escaped. In renovating his attachment to South Africa in terms of a commitment to oppose a development plan in the village, Camagu’s bond with Qolorha, its people, and its land can be described as an environmental kind of Afropolitanism that is neither simple nor exempt of its own pitfalls and contradictions.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Tbe Routledge Companion to Literature and the Global South, 2023
This chapter reconsiders the relationship between the Global South and the neoliberal regime impo... more This chapter reconsiders the relationship between the Global South and the neoliberal regime imposed on it by the Global North as the latest element in a succession of interrelated historical interventions that include colonization, imperialism and global capitalism, and globalization. It begins by exploring how, while asymmetrical, this relationship is co-constitutive, rather than merely one based on the North's global hegemony over the rest of the planet. At material, financial, and onto-political levels, the existence of the Global North is simply impossible without the Global South, and vice versa. Over time, however, as neoliberalism becomes increasingly pervasive across the world, a horizontal multiplication of relationships has replaced the original North-South distribution of power rooted historically in the colonizer-colonized binary. The chapter then explores the work of Mohsin Hamid and, in particular, his novel How to Get Filthy Rich in Rising Asia for its ability to dismantle via a number of narrative strategies the figure of homo oeconomicus, i.e., the model subject at the core of the neoliberal regime, as a horizontal intervention, that is, from the South out. This dismantling, ultimately, results in the creation of a planetary solidarity based on the rejection of globalized neoliberalism's individualism and the development of a relational kind of subjectivity.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Teaching Postcolonial Environmental Literature and Media (MLA Options), 2022
This chapter reflects on how I teach the continuities between visual images and texts to study th... more This chapter reflects on how I teach the continuities between visual images and texts to study the representation of environmental disaster in courses on postcolonial and global literature. Instead of employing photographs and other material to illustrate literary texts, I place works in both media at the same level in order to prompt a reflection on the interrelation between textual narratives and the visual politics that govern them. In particular, I describe how I employ this approach to teach Indra Sinha’s novel Animal’s People and the 1984 disaster in Bhopal that it reimagines. The essay begins by describing the necessary preparation to theorize visual images and texts together, then describes the critical benefit of this exercise, and finally explores some of the difficulties that I have encountered, offering solutions for some of them.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
European Review, 2021
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Afropolitan Literature as World Literature, 2020
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Journal of Modern Literature, 2017
Losing his job as a history teacher causes the narrator and protagonist of Graham Swift’s Waterla... more Losing his job as a history teacher causes the narrator and protagonist of Graham Swift’s Waterland (1983) to reflect on the past and chronicle the death of a local boy during his teenage years. In doing so, Tom Crick also offers what seems to be a redeeming account of his paternal family’s role in the Fens, the land dominated over the centuries by his maternal ancestors, the Atkinsons. In telling their story, however, he exercises the same exclusion that once relegated the Cricks to the historical periphery. Self-appointed family chronicler, Crick imposes narrative representation as the only way to exert one’s historical agency. Yet his half-brother Dick’s suicide, which emerges as an impenetrable silence, brings the account to an abrupt end, revealing the representational inadequacy of Crick’s project of historical restoration while, ironically, inaugurating a new horizon of possibility for the narrator’s life.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
The Paradox of Authenticity in a Globalized World (New York: Palgrave), 2014
In "The Part About Fate," one of the five sections of his widely acclaimed novel 2666, Roberto Bo... more In "The Part About Fate," one of the five sections of his widely acclaimed novel 2666, Roberto Bolaño deploys a parodic translation effect that emulates the singular way in which certain popular American crime movies are translated and dubbed into (Spain's) Spanish, reproducing ill-sounding idioms and expressions that once appeared strange to the Spanish speaker and now have become part of a specific cultural sub-code. "The Part About Fate," then, presents in the original Spanish edition a secondary level of meaning based on parody that the Spanish-speaking reader can recognize as authentic despite the fact that it originated as a result of mistranslation or of what is commonly known as "translatorese." In this chapter, I examine a number of examples of this parodic translation effect. Then, I compare them to their official English translation, highlighting the passages in which the translation is unable to show the parodic spirit that underlies the language of the novel's section. In the last part I conclude that this exercise in parody not only adds to the multiple, rich layers of meaning that overlap in the novel's sections such as the blind academicism of the critics or the excessively digressive subterfuge the novel becomes at times, but it also stresses the importance of transnational questions of language in making 2666 an inter-national, post-global narrative.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Journal of Graphic Novels and Comics, 2014
In this article, I propose the label 'inter-national comics' as an alternative to 'interna-tional... more In this article, I propose the label 'inter-national comics' as an alternative to 'interna-tional comics'. As it is currently understood, the notion of ‘international comics’ places a particular emphasis on the foreignness of works produced in other countries to the detriment of their reception by new readerships. Thus, the hyphenated 'inter-national comics' allows us to rethink the reciprocal relationship between the foreignness of a comic from another country and the locality of its new readership, bringing to the fore the exchange between nations that the hyphen emphasises. This 'inter-national' relationship, in addition, manifests formally within the very pages of certain works. This is the case of two world-renowned comics such as David B.'s Epileptic (2006) and Juan Díaz Canales and Juanjo Guarnido's Blacksad (2005), which I read here as spaces in which a veritable encounter between nations occurs.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Short Film Studies, 2013
This article examines the metanarrative devices deployed by the film to create, through contrast,... more This article examines the metanarrative devices deployed by the film to create, through contrast, a sense of endless anticipation to a loss eternally deferred.
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
CFPs
Seminar CFP for ACLA 2025
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Public Writing
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Edge Effects, 2021
Viruses know no borders, yet COVID-19 is often framed in national terms. This piece outlines the ... more Viruses know no borders, yet COVID-19 is often framed in national terms. This piece outlines the limits of pandemic nationalism and imagines a way forward.
https://edgeeffects.net/pandemic-nationalism
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Translation (Selected)
Tweed’s, 2012
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Reviews
Modern Fiction Studies 59.1, 2013
Bookmarks Related papers MentionsView impact
Uploads
Books
Meneses investigates how “illusory dialogue” (a particular dialogic encounter designed to secure consensus) is employed as an instrument that forestalls—instead of fostering—articulations of dissent that lead to political change. He does so through close readings of novels from the English-speaking world written in the past hundred years—from E. M. Forster’s A Passage to India and Jeanette Winterson’s The Passion to Indra Sinha’s Animal’s People and more. Resisting Dialogue demonstrates how these novels are rhetorical exercises with real political clout capable of restoring the radical potential of dialogue in today’s globalized world. Expanding the boundaries of postpolitical theory, Meneses reveals how these works offer ways to practice disagreement against this regulatory use of dialogue and expose the pitfalls of certain other dialogic interventions in relation to some of the most prominent questions of modern history: cosmopolitanism at the end of empire, the dangers of rewriting the historical record, the affective dimension of neoliberalism, the racial and nationalist underpinnings of the “war on terror,” and the visibility of environmental violence in the Anthropocene.
Ultimately, Resisting Dialogue is a complex, provocative critique that, melding political and literary theory, reveals how fiction can help confront the deployment of dialogue to preempt the emergence of dissent and, thus, revitalize the practice of emancipatory politics.
-
Deepening and widening a furrow first plowed by Jacques Rancière and Slavoj Žižek, Resisting Dialogue marks a refusal to underwrite ‘postpolitics’ as politics by insisting that unspeakable political ambition take its place, without apology, so that our voyage from a troubled modernist literature to the Anthropocene maps, simultaneously, a continuous trajectory and a jarring, disjunctive continuity.
— Grant Farred, Cornell University
-
Resisting Dialogue draws on literature to develop a fresh vocabulary of political activism and thetic force. Contrarianism, deadlock, impasse, silence, resilience, persistence, the power of unexceptional figures of history to block and oppose the status quo—these immobilizing postures acquire a make-over as acts of agency that contest the eclipse of political agency besetting progressive theories of the Political.
— Emily Apter, author of Unexceptional Politics: On Obstruction, Impasse and the Impolitic
Articles, Book Chapters (Selected)
Camagu’s presence, however, introduces a new element of imbalance in the village, as his conservationist yet nostalgic views of his home country merge with his disdain with the neoliberal culture that he escaped. In renovating his attachment to South Africa in terms of a commitment to oppose a development plan in the village, Camagu’s bond with Qolorha, its people, and its land can be described as an environmental kind of Afropolitanism that is neither simple nor exempt of its own pitfalls and contradictions.
CFPs
Public Writing
https://edgeeffects.net/pandemic-nationalism
Translation (Selected)
Reviews
Meneses investigates how “illusory dialogue” (a particular dialogic encounter designed to secure consensus) is employed as an instrument that forestalls—instead of fostering—articulations of dissent that lead to political change. He does so through close readings of novels from the English-speaking world written in the past hundred years—from E. M. Forster’s A Passage to India and Jeanette Winterson’s The Passion to Indra Sinha’s Animal’s People and more. Resisting Dialogue demonstrates how these novels are rhetorical exercises with real political clout capable of restoring the radical potential of dialogue in today’s globalized world. Expanding the boundaries of postpolitical theory, Meneses reveals how these works offer ways to practice disagreement against this regulatory use of dialogue and expose the pitfalls of certain other dialogic interventions in relation to some of the most prominent questions of modern history: cosmopolitanism at the end of empire, the dangers of rewriting the historical record, the affective dimension of neoliberalism, the racial and nationalist underpinnings of the “war on terror,” and the visibility of environmental violence in the Anthropocene.
Ultimately, Resisting Dialogue is a complex, provocative critique that, melding political and literary theory, reveals how fiction can help confront the deployment of dialogue to preempt the emergence of dissent and, thus, revitalize the practice of emancipatory politics.
-
Deepening and widening a furrow first plowed by Jacques Rancière and Slavoj Žižek, Resisting Dialogue marks a refusal to underwrite ‘postpolitics’ as politics by insisting that unspeakable political ambition take its place, without apology, so that our voyage from a troubled modernist literature to the Anthropocene maps, simultaneously, a continuous trajectory and a jarring, disjunctive continuity.
— Grant Farred, Cornell University
-
Resisting Dialogue draws on literature to develop a fresh vocabulary of political activism and thetic force. Contrarianism, deadlock, impasse, silence, resilience, persistence, the power of unexceptional figures of history to block and oppose the status quo—these immobilizing postures acquire a make-over as acts of agency that contest the eclipse of political agency besetting progressive theories of the Political.
— Emily Apter, author of Unexceptional Politics: On Obstruction, Impasse and the Impolitic
Camagu’s presence, however, introduces a new element of imbalance in the village, as his conservationist yet nostalgic views of his home country merge with his disdain with the neoliberal culture that he escaped. In renovating his attachment to South Africa in terms of a commitment to oppose a development plan in the village, Camagu’s bond with Qolorha, its people, and its land can be described as an environmental kind of Afropolitanism that is neither simple nor exempt of its own pitfalls and contradictions.
https://edgeeffects.net/pandemic-nationalism