[meta] Wide review tracker #299
Description
As a requirement for publishing a specification as a Candidate Recommendation, the group:
must show that the specification has received wide review
To satisfy this requirement, we use this tracker issue as an evidence that wide review from horizontal groups has been received.
Scope
- Generic Sensor API
- Ambient Light Sensor
- Accelerometer
- Gyroscope
- Magnetometer
- Orientation Sensor
- Motion Sensors Explainer (as an informative document)
Use RfC Template.
Horizontal groups
- Wide review announcement
- Publish a pre-CR Working Draft used as a basis for wide review: announcement
- Review request: public-review-announce, Bcc: chairs
- Technical Architecture Group
- Document significant differences between the last review and current review: Changelog
- Review request: Sensor APIs w3ctag/design-reviews#207
- Feedback: Sensor APIs w3ctag/design-reviews#207 (comment) (see also TAG Teleconference – 09 January 2018 raw minutes)
- Proposed resolution: [meta] Wide review tracker #299 (comment) shared with TAG Sensor APIs w3ctag/design-reviews#207 (comment)
- Security
- Work through the Security and Privacy Questionnaire
- Review request: public-web-security
- Feedback: Sensor APIs w3ctag/design-reviews#207 (comment) (note: not formal Security IG feedback)
- Proposed resolution: addressed as part of [meta] Wide review tracker #299 (comment) shared with TAG Sensor APIs w3ctag/design-reviews#207 (comment)
- Privacy
- Work through the Security and Privacy Questionnaire
-
Work through the Privacy Checklist (optional) - Review request: public-privacy
- Feedback: Include Known Accelerometer Privacy Exposures in Accelerometer Document accelerometer#30 Include Known Gyroscope Privacy Exposures in Gyroscope Document gyroscope#27 (also discussed on PING 2 Nov call, PING TPAC F2F)
- Resolution: Include Known Accelerometer Privacy Exposures in Accelerometer Document accelerometer#30 (comment) Include Known Gyroscope Privacy Exposures in Gyroscope Document gyroscope#27 (comment)
Internationalization(not applicable)Work through the i18n ChecklistOpen a review request at https://github.com/w3c/i18n-activity/issues/
Accessibility(not applicable)Work through the a11y Questionnaire and a11y ChecklistSend a review request to public-apa@w3.org
Other groups
Other W3C Groups that have interactions with this work:
- WebAppSec WG
- Review request: public-webappsec
- Feedback: confusion: "The WebAppSec WG doesn't review other WGs specs"
- Web Platform WG
- Review request: public-webapps
- Feedback: none
- WebVR CG
- Review request: public-webvr
- Feedback: none
- CSS WG
- Review request: www-style
- Feedback: none
References:
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels