8000 Clarification on Team decision appeal · w3c/guide@efc1bee · GitHub
[go: up one dir, main page]
Skip to content

Commit efc1bee

Browse files
plehegarplehegar
committed
Clarification on Team decision appeal
1 parent 968ad8e commit efc1bee

File tree

2 files changed

+23
-20
lines changed

2 files changed

+23
-20
lines changed

‎process/charter.md‎

Lines changed: 5 additions & 3 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -90,7 +90,7 @@ Community Groups interested in transitioning to a Working Group are encouraged t
9090

9191
After consideration of the [charter assessment criteria](#charter-assessment-criteria) and a determination that the charter is well-formed (per the template and per Process section "[content of a charter](https://www.w3.org/policies/process/#WGCharter)"), the Technical Strategy Team Lead decides whether to initiate charter refinement.
9292

93-
#### 3.2.1 Technical Strategy Team decision to initiate charter refinement
93+
#### 3.2.1 Technical Strategy Team decision to initiate charter refinement {#cr-acceptance}
9494

9595
If the Technical Strategy Team decides to initiate charter refinment, it follows these steps:
9696

@@ -105,7 +105,7 @@ Record start of refinement
105105

106106
Any Formal Objection to a Team Decision to initiate charter refinement is not considered registered until the close of any Advisory Committee Review of that charter, and is registered against that W3C Decision.
107107

108-
#### 3.2.2 Technical Strategy Team decision not to initiate charter refinement
108+
#### 3.2.2 Technical Strategy Team decision not to initiate charter refinement {#cr-rejection}
109109

110110
If no Advisory Committee representative formally requested that the Technical Strategy Team initiate charter refinement, then no further action is required of the Technical Strategy Team.
111111

@@ -115,7 +115,7 @@ This rejection is a [Team Decision](https://www.w3.org/policies/process/#team-de
115115

116116
> **Note**: We do not expect to include operational details for handling these Formal Objections until we have gained experience.
117117
118-
### 3.3 Activities during refinement
118+
### 3.3 Activities during refinement {#during-refinement}
119119

120120
The Chartering Facilitator ​is responsible for seeking community consensus among those participating in the refinement process and making decisions reflecting that consensus. The Chartering Facilitator follows these steps during refinement:
121121

@@ -196,6 +196,8 @@ In this section we describe the operational aspects of extending or modifying th
196196

197197
The W3C Process describes the [charter extensions](https://www.w3.org/policies/process/#charter-extension) and when they may occur. No Advisory Committee review is required for short-term extensions.
198198

199+
Advisory Committee representatives may initiate an [Advisory Committee Appeal](ac-appeal.md) against a [Team decision](https://www.w3.org/policies/process/#charter-extension) regarding the extension of a Working Group or Interest Group charter.
200+
199201
The Technical Strategy Team expects a charter extension to be no more than 6 months. Otherwise the Group must [recharter](#recharter-request) or justification must be provided to explain the delay.
200202

201203
Short-term extensions cannot exceed a total of one year from the original charter end date.

‎process/index.md‎

Lines changed: 18 additions & 17 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -12,31 +12,32 @@ See also the [W3C Process for Busy People](https://github.com/w3c/wg-effectivene
1212

1313
- [Advisory Committee Representative FAQ](https://www.w3.org/Member/faq.html) *(Member-only)*
1414
- [Advisory Committee Representative home page](../../Member/)
15-
- [Appealing a W3C Decision](./ac-appeal.md)
15+
- [Appealing a W3C Decision](ac-appeal.md)
16+
- Appealing Team Decision: [declining to start charter refinement](charter.md#cr-rejection), [group charter extension](charter.md#extension-request)
1617
- [Alternate Advisory Committee Representatives](./alternate-ac.md)
17-
- [How to organize an Advisory Board or Technical Architecture Group election](./election.md)
18-
- [Request the start of a charter refinement](./charter.md#charter-refinement)
19-
- [W3C Member Submissions](./member-submission.md)
18+
- [How to organize an Advisory Board or Technical Architecture Group election](election.md)
19+
- [Request the start of a charter refinement](charter.md#charter-refinement)
20+
- [W3C Member Submissions](member-submission.md)
2021
- [Formal Objections and W3C Councils](../council/)
2122

2223
## Groups
2324

24-
- [How to transition work from a Community Group to a Working Group](./cg-transition.md)
25-
- [How to create a Working Group or Interest Group Charter](./charter.md)
26-
- [Announcing the start of Charter Refinement](./adv-notice.md)
27-
- [Policy on W3C Group Charter End Dates](./charter-extensions.md)
28-
- [< 8000 /span>How to close a work Group](./closing-wg.md)
29-
- [How to close a work Group - Implementation](./closing-wg-implementation.md)
30-
- [Horizontal Groups](./horizontal-groups.md)
25+
- [How to transition work from a Community Group to a Working Group](cg-transition.md)
26+
- [How to create a Working Group or Interest Group Charter](charter.md)
27+
- [Announcing the start of Charter Refinement](adv-notice.md)
28+
- [Policy on W3C Group Charter End Dates](charter-extensions.md)
29+
- [How to close a work Group](closing-wg.md)
30+
- [How to close a work Group - Implementation](closing-wg-implementation.md)
31+
- [Horizontal Groups](horizontal-groups.md)
3132
* Deliverables
32-
- [Obsoleting and Rescinding W3C Specifications](./obsolete-rescinded-supserseded.md)
33-
- [Joint deliverables](./joint-deliverables.md)
34-
- [How to license definitions and bindings](./binding-license.md)
35-
- [Non participant commitment](./non-participant-commitment.md)
36-
- [Patent Advisory Group procedures](./pag.md)
33+
- [Obsoleting and Rescinding W3C Specifications](obsolete-rescinded-supserseded.md)
34+
- [Joint deliverables](joint-deliverables.md)
35+
- [How to license definitions and bindings](binding-license.md)
36+
- [Non participant commitment](non-participant-commitment.md)
37+
- [Patent Advisory Group procedures](pag.md)
3738
- Participants
3839
- [Positive Work Environment at W3C: Code of Conduct](https://www.w3.org/policies/code-of-conduct/)
39-
- [Guidelines to suspend or remove participants from groups](./suspension.md)
40+
- [Guidelines to suspend or remove participants from groups](suspension.md)
4041
- [Antitrust and Competition Guidance](https://www.w3.org/policies/antitrust/)
4142

4243

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)
0