The `Image#phasecor` result is kind of ambigous, how to deal with it? #373

Nakilon · 2023-10-22T03:47:04Z

Nakilon
Oct 22, 2023

I'm trying to use #pharecor again like I did for another project ~2 years ago but I still fail to understand the result of this function.
For example, here are two images:

If we compare under names a2 and a3:

require "ruby-vips"
require "mll"
...
Vips::Image.bandrank(MLL::nest_list[ a2.phasecor(a3).scaleimage, 5, ->_{ _.rank(20,20,399)-10 } ].to_a, index: 4).write_to_file "temp.png"

we can interpretate this as "the a3 matches a2 if we shift it right and a bit down". Now what if we swap them?

Vips::Image.bandrank(MLL::nest_list[ a3.phasecor(a2).scaleimage, 5, ->_{ _.rank(20,20,399)-10 } ].to_a, index: 4).write_to_file "temp.png"

we see that the resulting image was reflected, ok, then we assume there is the "negative axis quarter". Does it mean that we shift only up to half of the image size? Let's test a bigger shift:

Vips::Image.bandrank(MLL::nest_list[ a1.phasecor(a5).scaleimage, 5, ->_{ _.rank(20,20,399)-10 } ].to_a, index: 4).write_to_file "temp.png"

nope! it's detected the shift farther than a half.
Now the question is: How do we recognize it's a shift "3/4 right and a bit down" and not "1/4 left and a bit down"?
Previously when I faced this problem I was taking 4 variants [dx,dy], [dx-width,dy], [dx,dy-height], [dx-width,dy-height], cropping out the intersecting part and used an heuristic such as .min_by{ ... (a_crop - b_crop).avg } but isn't there a better way?

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Uh oh!

The `Image#phasecor` result is kind of ambigous, how to deal with it? #373

Uh oh!

{{title}}

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

{{editor}}'s edit

{{editor}}'s edit

Uh oh!

Replies: 0 comments

Select a reply

Uh oh!

The Image#phasecor result is kind of ambigous, how to deal with it? #373

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

Nakilon Oct 22, 2023

Replies: 0 comments

The `Image#phasecor` result is kind of ambigous, how to deal with it? #373

Nakilon
Oct 22, 2023