Caroline, or Change

Caroline, or Change
Music	Jeanine Tesori
Lyrics	Tony Kushner
Book	Tony Kushner
Productions	2003 Off-Broadway 2004 Broadway 2018 West End 2021 Broadway revival
Awards	Laurence Olivier Award for Best New Musical

Caroline, or Change is a musical with music by Jeanine Tesori and lyrics and book by Tony Kushner. The score combines spirituals, blues, Motown, classical music, and Jewish klezmer and folk music.

The show ran both Off-Broadway and on Broadway as well as in London.

Production history

Workshops & Off-Broadway

The musical was first workshopped in 1999 at New York's Off-Broadway Public Theater. Director George C. Wolfe continued to workshop the musical at the Public Theater, where it opened on November 30, 2003, and closed on February 1, 2004.

Original Broadway Production

It transferred to Broadway at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre on May 2, 2004, and closed on August 29, 2004, after 136 performances and 22 previews. The musical starred Tonya Pinkins in the title role, Anika Noni Rose as Emmie Thibodeaux, Harrison Chad as Noah Gellman, Veanne Cox as Rose Stopnick Gellman and Chandra Wilson as Dotty Moffett (all both off-and on-Broadway). The choreographer was Hope Clarke; scenic design by Riccardo Hernandez; costume design by Paul Tazewell; and lighting design by Jules Fisher and Peggy Eisenhauer. Despite its relatively short run, it was critically acclaimed and nominated for six Tony Awards, including Best Musical.

Original London Production

Opening in October 2006, a London production at the National Theatre on the Lyttelton stage, also directed by Wolfe, ran in repertory with Marianne Elliot's production of Thérèse Raquin to January 2007. The production did not transfer to the West End but did win the Olivier Award for Best New Musical. The opening night cast in London starred Tonya Pinkins as Caroline. Other cast members included Pippa Bennett-Warner as Emmie Thibodeaux, Anna Francolini as Rose Stopnick Gellman, Hilton McRae as Mr. Stopnick, Perry Millward, Jonny Weldon and Greg Bernstein alternating as Noah, Clive Rowe as the dryer/bus Joy Malcolm, Ramona Keller, and Nataylia Roni, as the Radio.

2018 London Revival

A revival was produced at the Minerva Theatre, Chichester as part of Daniel Evans' inaugural season as artistic director of Chichester Festival Theatre, running from 6 May to 3 June 2017. The production was directed by Michael Longhurst, starred Sharon D. Clarke as Caroline and received critical acclaim earning five star reviews. The production transferred with Clarke to the Hampstead Theatre, London from 12 March to 21 April 2018. The production transferred to the West End at the Playhouse Theatre, where it began playing on 20 November 2018, and ran until 2 March 2019, once again starring Clarke.

2021 Broadway Revival

A Broadway revival by Roundabout Theatre Company based on the Chichester production initially was announced to start previews on March 13, 2020 and open on April 7, 2020, at Studio 54. On March 12, 2020, the show suspended production due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Rescheduled previews began October 8, 2021 and it officially opened on October 27 and ran through January 9, 2022. Direction was by Michael Longhurst with choreography by Ann Yee. The revival starred Sharon D. Clarke and Samantha Williams (Emmie).

Regional theatre

Pinkins and Anika Noni Rose (Emmie Thibodeaux) reprised their roles in late 2004 at the Ahmanson Theatre, Los Angeles, California and in January to February 2005 at the Curran Theatre, San Francisco, California. Its premiere in The Washington, D.C., area at The Studio Theatre in 2006, starring Julia Nixon and Max Talisman, received rave reviews, and won The Helen Hayes Awards for Outstanding Lead Actress, Resident Musical (Nixon), and Outstanding Resident Musical. The Chicago premiere at the Court Theatre in fall 2008 earned four Jeff awards for director Charles Newell, Musical Director Doug Peck, star E. Faye Butler, and best production of a musical at a large scale theater.

Other regional productions have included Main Street Theater, Houston, in January 2008 with Tamara Siler; Center Stage, Baltimore, Maryland, in December 2008 to January 2009 with E. Faye Butler; the Guthrie Theatre, Minneapolis, Minnesota, April to June 2009, the Gallery Players, Brooklyn, N.Y., January to February 2010, The Human Race Theatre Company, Dayton, Ohio November 4–20, 2011, and Syracuse Stage (Syracuse, New York) February 1-February 26, 2012. In 2017, the Round House Theatre in Bethesda, Maryland staged it as part of a season with a focus on Tony Kushner plays. Its Colorado regional premiere took place April 5 to May 5, 2019, at the Aurora Fox Arts Center, directed by Kenny Moten and starring Mary Louise Lee as Caroline.

A 2012 production by Acting Up Stage Company in Toronto, Ontario, garnered Dora Mavor Moore Awards for Outstanding Production of a Musical, Sterling Jarvis (principal actor), Arlene Duncan (principal actress) and Outstanding Musical Direction (Reza Jacobs). A new production by Acting Up Stage Company, now called The Musical Stage Company, in Toronto, Ontario played January 31 to February 16, 2020, starring Jully Black as Caroline and Canadian soprano Measha Brueggergosman as The Moon at the Elgin and Winter Garden Theatres.

Plot

Act One

On a hot day in 1963 in Lake Charles, Louisiana, Caroline, a Black maid who works for the Gellman family for $30 a week, launders clothes in the basement ("16 Feet Beneath The Sea"). Caroline keeps herself sane in the basement by imagining the items in the basement as people ("The Radio"/"Laundry Quintet"). The Gellmans' 8-year-old son Noah, whose mother has recently died of cancer, is attracted to Caroline, a no-nonsense single parent ("Noah Down The Stairs"). Caroline allows Noah to light her one cigarette each day, a secret they can share ("The Cigarette"). Caroline puts the laundry in the dryer and sings about her four kids and cleaning houses for 22 years ("The Dryer"/"I Got Four Kids").

Noah's new stepmother Rose cannot give Caroline a raise, but tells her to take some extra food home to her kids ("Caroline, There's Extra Food"); Caroline declines. Noah's father Stuart, despondent since his wife's death, tells Noah he has lost his faith ("There is No God, Noah"). Noah confesses that he hates Rose ("Rose Stopnick Can Cook"). Rose confesses to her father, Mr. Stopnick, that she is unhappy as well ("Long Distance").

After work, Caroline argues with her friend Dotty about each other's lifestyles ("Dotty and Caroline"). The moon rises as they wait for a bus ("Moon Change"). They discuss the recent mysterious destruction of a statue of a Confederate soldier at the courthouse ("Moon Trio"). The bus arrives with devastating news: President Kennedy has been assassinated ("The Bus"/"That Can't Be").

Rose tells Noah to stop leaving money in his pants pockets, and that any money Caroline finds in his laundry will be hers to keep ("Noah and Rose"). The Gellman family reminisces about the good President Kennedy did for the Jews and Dotty reminisces about the good he intended to do for African Americans ("Inside/Outside"/"JFK"). On the front porch of her house, Caroline tells her teenage daughter Emmie that the president is dead. Emmie says she does not care, because JFK never fulfilled his promises to the Black community ("No One Waiting"/"Night Mama"). Noah, awake in his bedroom, asks Caroline what laws she would pass if she were president ("Gonna Pass Me a Law"/"Noah Goes To Sleep").

Rose tells Caroline she is allowed to keep any money she finds in Noah's pants, to supplement her salary and teach Noah a lesson ("Noah Has a Problem"). Noah and his father, Stuart, have trouble bonding ("Stuart and Noah"). Noah, aware of Caroline's situation, purposefully leaves his candy and comic book money in his pockets, as well as 75 cents ("Quarter in the Bleach Cup"). Caroline feels bad about keeping it, but does so, out of necessity. Caroline brings the money to Emmie, Jackie, and the adorable little Joe who discuss all the things they can do and things they can buy with it ("Caroline Takes My Money Home"/"Roosevelt Petrucius Coleslaw").

Act Two

As Christmas approaches Caroline, ironing clothes in the basement, remembers her ex-husband, who was kind and thoughtful until he became abusive ("Santa Comin' Caroline"/"Little Reward"/"1943"). Rose tells Caroline to keep any money Stuart leaves in his clothes as well but Caroline snaps at Rose saying she does not need her pity or money and threatens her with the iron ("Mr. Gellman's Shirt"/"Ooh Child"). Rose then asks if she, Dotty, and Emmie will work at her upcoming Chanukah party ("Rose Recovers"). Emmie, Jackie, and Joe encourage her to keep taking the laundry money, because the family needs it ("I Saw Three Ships").

At the Chanukah party, Noah educates Emmie about the holiday ("The Chanukah Party"). Rose shoos Noah out of the kitchen ("Noah, Out! It's Very Rude") and Dotty tells Emmie about the courthouse statue ("Dotty and Emmie"). When Mr. Stopnick belittles Martin Luther King Jr.'s nonviolent civil disobedience, Emmie tells him white people have no right to be critical ("I Don't Want My Child To Hear That"/"Mr. Stopnick and Emmie"). Mr. Stopnick is impressed with Emmie's bravado, but Caroline tells her she cannot talk that way to white people; Emmie retorts that slavery is over. Caroline slaps Emmie ("Kitchen Fight"). Mr. Stopnick's Chanukah present to Noah is a $20 bill, intended as a life lesson about money and its value ("A Twenty Dollar Bill and Why"). At the bus stop, Emmie dreams of growing up to be independent and fighting for justice ("I Hate the Bus"). Back at the house, Stuart laments that he can give neither Rose nor Noah what they need ("Moon, Emmie, Stuart Trio").

Noah inadvertently leaves the $20 bill in his pants; after school he rushes to the basement, but Caroline has found it and says she is keeping it, per their agreement ("The Twenty Dollar Bill"). Noah and Caroline exchange racial insults, then Caroline returns the money and leaves ("Caroline and Noah Fight"). After five days, Caroline has not returned to work ("Aftermath"). Stuart and Rose find the bill and, in a rare display of parental instincts, confront Noah over what happened, but Noah is saved from punishment when Mr. Stopnick pretends the bill is his, satisfied that Noah learned his lesson. That Sunday on her way to church, Caroline realizes that the laundry money had only fostered greed and hatefulness; she asks God to free her from earthly desires ("Sunday Morning"/"Lot's Wife"). The radio sings of a fierce heartbreak ("Salty Teardrops"). At church, Caroline gives Emmie, Jackie, and Joe fierce hugs and accepts that her children will have better and different lives from the one she has had. ("How Long Has This Been Going On?").

Noah finally lets Rose tuck him into bed and kiss him goodnight. Caroline returns to work and assures Noah that although things will never be the same between them, Noah will learn to live with his sorrow and move on ("Why Does Our House Have a Basement?"/"Underwater"). Emmie reveals that she helped take down the Confederate soldier statue, and proudly sings that she is the daughter of a maid, but she will continue to work for a greater cause, and her children will have a brighter future. Jackie and Joe come out to shush her and she tells them that it is up to the children of Caroline Thibedeaux to change the future ("Epilogue").

Musical numbers

Act One

Washer / Dryer

• 16 Feet Beneath The Sea — Caroline, The Washing Machine
• The Radio — The Radio
• Laundry Quintet— The Washing Machine, Caroline, The Radio
• Noah Down The Stairs — Noah
• The Cigarette — Noah and Caroline
• Laundry Finish— The Washing Machine, Caroline, The Radio
• The Dryer— The Dryer and The Radio
• I Got Four Kids— Caroline and The Dryer

Cabbage

• Caroline, There's Extra Food— Rose, Caroline and The Gellmans
• There Is No God, Noah— Stuart
• Rose Stopnick Can Cook— The Gellmans
• Long Distance— Rose

Moon Change

• Dotty and Caroline— Dotty and Caroline
• Moon Change— The Moon
• Moon Trio— Dotty, Caroline, and The Moon
• The Bus— The Bus
• That Can't Be— The Bus, Rose, Dotty and Caroline
• Noah and Rose— Rose and Noah
• Inside / Outside — The Moon, Noah and Rose
• JFK —Dotty, Grandpa Gellman and Grandma Gellman

Duets

• No One Waitin' — Emmie, Caroline, and The Radio
• 'Night Mamma — Emmie
• Gonna Pass Me A Law — Noah and Caroline
• Stop Botherin’ The Night — Caroline

The Bleach Cup

• Noah Has A Problem — Rose and Caroline
• Stuart and Noah — Stuart, Noah and Rose
• The Bleach Cup — Caroline, Noah and The Washing Machine
• Roosevelt Petrucius Coleslaw — Emmie, Jackie, Joe, Noah, Caroline and The Moon

Act Two

Ironing

• Santa Comin' Caroline — The Radio
• Little Reward — The Radio, The Washing Machine, and Caroline
• 1943 — Caroline, The Washing Machine, and The Radio
• Mr. Gellman's Shirt — Rose and Caroline
• Ooh Child — The Washing Machine and The Radio
• Rose Recovers — Rose, The Dryer and Caroline
• I Saw Three Ships — Emmie, Jackie, Joe and Caroline

The Chanukah Party

• The Chanukah Party — Grandma Gellman, Grandpa Gellman, Mr. Stopnick, Rose, Noah, Caroline, and Emmie
• Dotty and Emmie — Dotty and Emmie
• I Don't Want My Child To Hear That — Caroline, Mr. Stopnick
• Mr. Stopnick and Emmie — Mr. Stopnick and Emmie
• Kitchen Fight — Caroline, Emmie, and Dotty
• A Twenty Dollar Bill and Why — Mr. Stopnick
• I Hate The Bus — Emmie
• Moon, Emmie and Stuart Trio — The Moon, Emmie, Stuart

The Twenty Dollar Bill

• The Twenty Dollar Bill — Noah, The Gellmans
• Caroline and Noah Fight — Caroline, The Dryer and Noah

Aftermath

• Aftermath — Noah, The Dryer, Rose, Stuart, Mr. Stopnick
• Rose Waltz – Rose, Mr. Stopnick, Stuart

Lot's Wife

• Sunday Morning — Caroline and Dotty
• Lot's Wife — Caroline

How Long Has This Been Going On?

• Salty Teardrops — The Radio
• Why Does Our House Have A Basement? — Noah, Rose, and Caroline
• Underwater — Caroline

Emmie's Dream

• Epilogue — Emmie, Jackie, and Joe

Characters

• Caroline Thibodeaux: 39-year-old African-American maid for the Gellmans, a middle-class Jewish family
• Noah Gellman: The Gellmans' 8-year-old curious, sympathetic, and neurotic son
• Emmie Thibodeaux: Caroline's 16-year-old free-spirited daughter, supporter of Martin Luther King Jr. and the Civil Rights Movement
• Rose Stopnick Gellman: Noah's concerned new stepmother from New York City, marries Stuart after his first wife's death
• Stuart Gellman: Professional clarinet player and Noah's father, mourning the loss of his wife
• Dotty Moffett: Friend of Caroline and fellow maid, takes night classes at the University
• The Radio: Domestic appliance portrayed by a Supremes-like trio, serves as a Greek Chorus for the show
• The Washing Machine: Domestic appliance portrayed by an actor, cleans clothes for the Gellmans and pushes Caroline to move forward in life
• The Dryer: Domestic appliance portrayed by an actor, torments Caroline throughout the show
• The Moon: Portrayed by an actor, is a calming and healing presence throughout the show
• The Bus: Portrayed by an actor, is the primary source of transportation for the African-American characters in the show
• Jackie Thibodeaux: Caroline's 10-year-old son
• Joe Thibodeaux: Caroline's 8-year-old son
• Mr. Stopnick: Rose's father, a Jewish man with a socialist ideology from New York City
• Grandpa Gellman: Noah's grandfather, Stuart's father
• Grandma Gellman: Noah's grandmother, Stuart's mother

Notable casts

Character	First Reading	Second Reading	First Workshop	Second Workshop	Third Workshop	Off-Broadway	Broadway	London	Chichester	Off-West End Revival	First West End Revival	First Broadway Revival
	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003		2004	2006	2017	2018		2021
Caroline Thibodeaux	Rosalyn Coleman Williams	Tonya Pinkins							Sharon D. Clarke
Noah Gellman	Adam Lamberg		Jonathan Press	Harrison Chad				Greg Bernstein Perry Millward Jonny Weldon	Charlie Gallacher Daniel Luniku	Charlie Gallacher Aaron Gelkoff	Isaac Forward Aaron Gelkoff Jack Meredit	Jaden Myles Waldman Gabriel Amoroso Adam Makke
Emmie Thibodeaux	Afi McClendon	Pascale Armand	Anika Noni Rose					Pippa Bennett-Warner	Abiona Omonua			Samantha Williams
Rose Stopnick Gellman	Carrie Preston		Veanne Cox					Anna Francolini	Lauren Ward			Caissie Levy
Stuart Gellman	Dan Futterman	Ben Shenkman	Denis O’Hare		Adam Grupper	David Costabile		Richard Henders	Alex Gaumond	Alastair Brookshaw		John Cariani
Dotty Moffett	Michael Hyatt		Kimberly JaJuan	Chandra Wilson				Nora Cole	Nicola Hughes	Naana Agyei-Ampadu		Tamika Lawrence
The Radio	Ann Duquesnay		Tracy Nicole Chapman Marva Hicks Ramona Keller		Tracy Nicole Chapman Marva Hicks Stacy Francis	Tracy Nicole Chapman Marva Hicks Ramona Keller Ledisi		Ramona Keller Joy Malcolm Nataylia Roni	Keisha Amponsa Banson Gloria Ontiri Jennifer Saayeng	T’Shan Williams Sharon Rose Carole Stennentt	Keisha Amponsa Banson Dujonna Gift-Simms Tanisha Spring	Nasia Thomas Nya Harper Miles
The Washing Machine	Noel True	Michael Hyatt	Capathia Jenkins				Capathia Jenkins Ledisi	Malinda Paris	Me’sha Bryan			Arica Jackson
The Dryer / The Bus	Chuck Cooper	Tommy Hollis	Chuck Cooper					Clive Rowe	Ako Mitchell			Kevin S. McAllister
The Moon	Ann Duquesnay		Priscilla Baskerville		Barbara Conrad	Adriane Lenox	Aisha de Haas	Angela M Caesar				N’Kenge
Jackie Thibodeaux			Jason Dendy	Sean Taylor	Chevon Rutty	Kevin Ricardo Tate	Leon Thomas III	Ronald Chabvuka Louis Ekoku Mitchell Zhanghaza	James Gava Zephan Hanson Amissah	Kenya Sandy Mickell Stewart-Grimes	Mark Mwangi Kenya Sandy Jeremiah Waysome	Alexander Bello
Joe Thibodeaux			Sean Taylor	Jeremy Meleek Leggett	Phil Harris	Marcus Carl Franklin		Kazim Benson Kuan Frye Jamal Hope	Josiah Choto Teni Taiwo	Josiah Choto David Dube	Josiah Choto David Dube Raphael Higgins-Hume	Jayden Theophile
Mr. Stopnick	David Margulies					Larry Keith		Hilton McRae	Teddy Kempner			Chip Zien
Grandma Gellman	Sloane Shelton	Lola Pashalinski	Alice Playten					Valda Aviks	Beverley Klein	Sue Kelvin		Joy Hermalyn
Grandpa Gellman	Ben Hammer	Bill Buell	Reathel Bean					Ian Lavender	Vincent Pirillo			Stuart Zagnit

Awards and nominations

Original Broadway production

Year	Award	Category	Nominee	Result
2004	Tony Award	Best Musical		Nominated
		Best Book of a Musical	Tony Kushner	Nominated
		Best Original Score	Jeanine Tesori and Tony Kushner	Nominated
		Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Musical	Tonya Pinkins	Nominated
		Best Performance by a Featured Actress in a Musical	Anika Noni Rose	Won
		Best Direction of a Musical	George C. Wolfe	Nominated
	Drama Desk Award	Outstanding Musical		Nominated
		Outstanding Book of a Musical	Tony Kushner	Nominated
		Outstanding Actress in a Musical	Tonya Pinkins	Nominated
		Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical	Anika Noni Rose	Nominated
		Outstanding Director of a Musical	George C. Wolfe	Nominated
		Outstanding Music	Jeanine Tesori	Won

Original London production

Year	Award	Category	Nominee	Result
2007	Laurence Olivier Awards	Best New Musical		Won
		Best Actress in a Musical	Tonya Pinkins	Nominated
		Best Supporting Performance in a Musical	Anna Francolini	Nominated

2017 Chichester/Hampstead/West End revival

Year	Award	Category	Nominee	Result
2017	UK Theatre Award	Best Musical Production		Nominated
		Best Performance in a Musical	Sharon D. Clarke	Nominated
	BroadwayWorld UK Award	Best New Production of a Musical		Nominated
2018	Evening Standard Theatre Award	Best Musical		Nominated
		Best Musical Performance	Sharon D. Clarke	Nominated
2019	Laurence Olivier Award	Best Musical Revival		Nominated
		Best Actress in a Musical	Sharon D. Clarke	Won
		Best Costume Design	Fly Davis	Nominated
	Black British Theatre Award	Best Female Actor in a Musical	Sharon D. Clarke	Won
	Stage Debut Award	Child Performer of the Year	Jack Meredith	Nominated

2021 Broadway revival

Year	Award	Category	Nominee	Result
2022	Drama League Awards	Outstanding Revival of a Broadway or Off-Broadway Play		Nominated
		Distinguished Performance	Sharon D. Clarke	Nominated
	Drama Desk Awards
		Outstanding Revival of a Musical		Nominated
		Outstanding Actress in a Musical	Sharon D. Clarke	Nominated
	Outer Critics Circle Awards	Outstanding Revival of a Play (Broadway or Off-Broadway)		Nominated
		Outstanding Actress in a Musical	Sharon D. Clarke	Nominated
	Theatre World Award			Honoree
	Tony Awards	Best Revival of a Musical		Nominated
		Best Actress in a Musical	Sharon D. Clarke	Nominated
		Best Costume Design in a Musical	Fly Davis	Nominated
2023	Grammy Awards	Best Musical Theater Album	Principal soloists, album producers, composer and lyricist.	Nominated

External links

• ​Caroline, or Change​ at the Internet Broadway Database
• Caroline, or Change at the Internet Off-Broadway Database
• Caroline, or Change at the Music Theatre International website
• Review of the Broadway production
• Review of the London production
• Tonya Pinkins – Downstage Center interview at American Theatre Wing.org