1. Introduction
1.1. Background
This section is not normative.
[CSS21] defines one type of conditional group rule, the @media rule, and allows only style rules (not other @-rules)
inside of it. The @media rule provides the ability to
have media-specific style sheets, which is also provided by style
sheet linking features such as @import and link
. The restrictions on the contents of @media rules made them less useful; they have forced authors
using CSS features involving @-rules in media-specific style sheets to
use separate style sheets for each medium.
This specification extends the rules for the contents of conditional group rules to allow other @-rules, which enables authors to combine CSS features involving @-rules with media specific style sheets within a single style sheet.
This specification also defines an additional type of conditional group rule, @supports, to address author and user requirements.
The @supports rule allows CSS to be conditioned on implementation support for CSS properties and values. This rule makes it much easier for authors to use new CSS features and provide good fallback for implementations that do not support those features. This is particularly important for CSS features that provide new layout mechanisms, and for other cases where a set of related styles needs to be conditioned on property support.
1.2. Module Interactions
This module replaces and extends the @media rule feature defined in [CSS21] section 7.2.1 and incorporates the modifications previously made non-normatively by [MEDIAQUERIES-4] section 1.
2. Processing of conditional group rules
This specification defines some CSS at-rules, called conditional group rules, that associate a condition with a group of other CSS rules. These different rules allow testing different types of conditions, but share common behavior for how their contents are used when the condition is true and when the condition is false.
@media print{ /* hide navigation controls when printing */ #navigation{ display : none} }
causes a particular CSS rule (making elements with ID “navigation” be display:none) apply only when the style sheet is used for a print medium.
Each conditional group rule has a condition, which at any time evaluates to true or false. When the condition is true, CSS processors must apply the rules inside the group rule as though they were at the group rule’s location; when the condition is false, CSS processors must not apply any of rules inside the group rule. The current state of the condition does not affect the CSS object model, in which the contents of the group rule always remain within the group rule.
Tests
If condition is true, rules applied in place.
If condition is false, rules not applied.
CSSOM contains rules regardless of condition.
This means that when multiple conditional group rules are nested, a rule inside of both of them applies only when all of the rules' conditions are true.
Tests
Nested rules apply when all conditions are true.
- at-supports-002.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-003.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-004.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-005.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-048.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-025.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-026.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-046.xht (live test) (source)
@media print{ /* rule (1) */ /* hide navigation controls when printing */ #navigation{ display : none} @media ( max-width:12 cm ) { /* rule (2) */ /* keep notes in flow when printing to narrow pages */ .note{ float : none} } }
the condition of the rule marked (1) is true for print media, and the condition of the rule marked (2) is true when the width of the display area (which for print media is the page box) is less than or equal to 12cm. Thus the rule #navigation { display: none } applies whenever this style sheet is applied to print media, and the rule .note { float: none } is applied only when the style sheet is applied to print media and the width of the page box is less than or equal to 12 centimeters.
When the condition for a conditional group rule changes, CSS processors must reflect that the rules now apply or no longer apply, except for properties whose definitions define effects of computed values that persist past the lifetime of that value (such as for some properties in [CSS3-TRANSITIONS] and [CSS3-ANIMATIONS]).
Tests
Change in condition simultaneous with change in condition application (except per transition/animation rules).
3. Contents of conditional group rules
All conditional group rules are defined to take a <rule-list> in their block, and accept any rule that is normally allowed at the top-level of a stylesheet, and not otherwise restricted. (For example, an @import rule must appear at the actual beginning of a stylesheet, and so is not valid inside of another rule.)
Tests
Valid to nest all unrestricted top-level rules.
- at-supports-content-002.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-content-003.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-content-004.html (live test) (source)
- at-media-content-002.html (live test) (source)
- at-media-content-003.html (live test) (source)
- at-media-content-004.html (live test) (source)
Invalid or unknown rules inside the <rule-list> must be considered invalid and ignored, but do not invalidate the conditional group rule.
Tests
Invalid rules do not invalidate conditional group rule.
Any namespace prefixes used in a conditional group rule must have been declared, otherwise they are invalid.
@namespace xurl ( http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink ); @supports ( content:attr ( x|href)) { // do something}
@supports ( content:attr ( n|tooltip)) { // do something}
The user agent will consult the namespace map to see whether a namespace url exists corresponding to the "n" prefix.
Tests
Validity of namespace prefixes depends on namespace map.
- at-supports-namespace-001.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-namespace-002.html (live test) (source)
4. Placement of conditional group rules
Conditional group rules are allowed wherever style rules are allowed (at the top-level of a style sheet, as well as within other conditional group rules). CSS processors must process such rules as described above.
Tests
Conditional group rules allowed wherever style rules are allowed.
- at-media-001.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-001.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-002.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-003.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-004.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-005.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-025.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-026.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-046.xht (live test) (source)
Any at-rules that are not allowed after a style rule (e.g., @charset, @import, or @namespace rules) are also not allowed after a conditional group rule, and are therefore invalid when so placed.
Tests
At rules not allowed after style rule invalid after conditional group rule.
5. Media-specific style sheets: the @media rule
The @media rule is a conditional group rule whose condition is a media query. Its syntax is:
@media <media-query-list> { <rule-list> }
It consists of the at-keyword @media followed by a (possibly empty) media query list (as defined in [MEDIAQUERIES-4]), followed by a block containing arbitrary rules. The condition of the rule is the result of the media query.
@media screen and( min-width:35 em ), print and( min-width:40 em ) { #section_navigation{ float : left; width : 10 em ; } }
has the condition screen and (min-width: 35em), print and (min-width: 40em), which is true for screen displays whose viewport is at least 35 times the initial font size and for print displays whose viewport is at least 40 times the initial font size. When either of these is true, the condition of the rule is true, and the rule #section_navigation { float: left; width: 10em; } is applied.
Tests
Media rule condition can be empty
Media rule condition is media query
White space is optional where not required for tokenization.
- at-media-whitespace-optional-001.html (live test) (source)
- at-media-whitespace-optional-002.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-whitespace.html (live test) (source)
6. Feature queries: the @supports rule
The @supports rule is a conditional group rule whose condition tests whether the user agent supports CSS property:value pairs. Authors can use it to write style sheets that use new features when available but degrade gracefully when those features are not supported. These queries are called CSS feature queries or (colloquially) supports queries.
Note: CSS has existing mechanisms for graceful degradation, such as ignoring unsupported properties or values, but these are not always sufficient when large groups of styles need to be tied to the support for certain features, as is the case for use of new layout system features.
The syntax of the condition in the @supports rule is similar to that defined for <media-condition> in [MEDIAQUERIES-4], but without the "unknown" value logic:
-
negation is needed so that the new-feature styles and the fallback styles can be separated (within the forward-compatible grammar’s rules for the syntax of @-rules), and not required to override each other.
-
conjunction (and) is needed so that multiple required features can be tested.
-
disjunction (or) is needed when there are multiple alternative features for a set of styles, particularly when some of those alternatives are vendor-prefixed properties or values.
Therefore, the syntax of the @supports rule allows testing for property:value pairs, and arbitrary conjunctions (and), disjunctions (or), and negations (not) of them.
The syntax of the @supports rule is:
@supports <supports-condition> { <rule-list> }
with <supports-condition> defined as:
<supports-condition> = not <supports-in-parens> | <supports-in-parens> [ and <supports-in-parens> ]* | <supports-in-parens> [ or <supports-in-parens> ]* <supports-in-parens> = ( <supports-condition> ) | <supports-feature> | <general-enclosed> <supports-feature> = <supports-decl> <supports-decl> = ( <declaration> )
The above grammar is purposely very loose for forwards-compatibility reasons, since the <general-enclosed> production allows for substantial future extensibility. Any @supports rule that does not parse according to the grammar above (that is, a rule that does not match this loose grammar which includes the <general-enclosed> production) is invalid. Style sheets must not use such a rule and processors must ignore such a rule (including all of its contents).
Tests
White space is optional where not required for tokenization.
Grammatically-invalid @supports rule is ignored.
- at-supports-019.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-020.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-021.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-022.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-023.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-024.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-025.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-026.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-027.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-028.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-029.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-030.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-031.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-032.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-033.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-034.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-037.xht (live test) (source)
Each of these grammar terms is associated with a boolean result, as follows:
- <supports-condition>
- <supports-in-parens>
-
The result is the result of the child subexpression.
- not <supports-in-parens>
-
The result is the negation of the <supports-in-parens> term.
Tests
Not negates supports condition.
- at-supports-009.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-010.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-016.xht (live test) (source)
Not must be followed by space.
Not requires parentheses.
- <supports-in-parens> [ and <supports-in-parens> ]*
-
The result is true if all of the <supports-in-parens> child terms are true, and false otherwise.
Tests
And condition is true iff all linked conditions are true.
- at-supports-007.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-010.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-012.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-008.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-009.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-010.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-012.xht (live test) (source)
And requires parentheses.
- <supports-in-parens> [ or <supports-in-parens> ]*
-
The result is false if all of the <supports-in-parens> child terms are false, and true otherwise.
Tests
Or condition is true iff any of linked conditions is true.
- at-supports-008.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-010.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-013.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-006.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-007.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-011.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-021.xht (live test) (source)
Or must be followed by space.
Or requires parentheses.
- <supports-decl>
-
The result is true if the UA supports the declaration within the parentheses.
Tests
Supports condition is true iff declaration is supported.
- at-supports-001.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-017.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-018.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-001.xht (live test) (source)
Declaration cannot include semicolon.
Declaration value can be empty.
Declaration cannot include invalid !tokens.
- css-supports-043.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-044.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-045.xht (live test) (source)
- <general-enclosed>
-
The result is false.
Authors must not use <general-enclosed> in their stylesheets. It exists only for future-compatibility, so that new syntax additions do not invalidate too much of a <supports-condition> in older user agents.
Tests
Unrecognized but grammatically-valid condition is false, not invalid.
- at-supports-015.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-046.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-023.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-031.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-032.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-033.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-034.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-036.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-040.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-041.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-042.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-046.xht (live test) (source)
Brackets/parenthesis must be balanced
The condition of the @supports rule is the result of the <supports-condition> in its prelude.
@supports ( display: flex) { body, #navigation, #content{ display : flex; } #navigation{ background : blue; color : white; } #article{ background : white; color : black; } }
applies the rules inside the @supports rule only when display: flex is supported.
@supports not( display: flex) { body{ width : 100 % ; height : 100 % ; background : white; color : black; } #navigation{ width : 25 % ; } #article{ width : 75 % ; } }
Note that the width declarations may be harmful to the flex-based layout, so it is important that they be present only in the non-flex styles.
.noticebox{ border : 1 px solid black; padding : 1 px ; } @supports ( box-shadow:0 0 2 px black inset) or( -moz-box-shadow:0 0 2 px black inset) or( -webkit-box-shadow:0 0 2 px black inset) or( -o-box-shadow:0 0 2 px black inset) { .noticebox{ -moz-box-shadow : 0 0 2 px black inset; -webkit-box-shadow : 0 0 2 px black inset; -o-box-shadow : 0 0 2 px black inset; box-shadow : 0 0 2 px black inset; /* unprefixed last */ /* override the rule above the @supports rule */ border: none; padding : 2 px ; } }
To avoid confusion between and and or, the syntax requires that both and and or be specified explicitly (rather than, say, using commas or spaces for one of them). Likewise, to avoid confusion caused by precedence rules, the syntax does not allow and, or, and not operators to be mixed without a layer of parentheses.
@supports ( transition-property: color) or( animation-name: foo) and( transform:rotate ( 10 deg )) { /* ... */ }
Instead, authors must write one of the following:
@supports (( transition-property: color) or( animation-name: foo)) and( transform:rotate ( 10 deg )) { /* ... */ }
@supports ( transition-property: color) or(( animation-name: foo) and( transform:rotate ( 10 deg ))) { /* ... */ }
Tests
Parentheses are required to mix operators.
- at-supports-016.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-013.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-014.xht (live test) (source)
The declaration being tested must always occur within parentheses, when it is the only thing in the expression.
@supports display: flex{ /* ... */ }
Instead, authors must write:
@supports ( display: flex) { /* ... */ }
Tests
Parentheses are required around declaration test.
- at-supports-011.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-034.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-035.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-036.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-037.html (live test) (source)
- css-supports-002.xht (live test) (source)
The syntax allows extra parentheses when they are not needed. This flexibility is sometimes useful for authors (for example, when commenting out parts of an expression) and may also be useful for authoring tools.
Tests
Extra parentheses are allowed.
A trailing !important on a declaration being tested is allowed, though it won’t change the validity of the declaration.
Tests
!important is allowed.
6.1. Definition of support
For forward-compatibility, section 4.1.8 (Declarations and properties) of [CSS21] defines rules for handling invalid properties and values. CSS processors that do not implement or partially implement a specification must treat any part of a value that they do not implement, or do not have a usable level of support for, as invalid according to this rule for handling invalid properties and values, and therefore must discard the declaration as a parse error.
A CSS processor is considered to support a declaration (consisting of a property and value) if it accepts that declaration (rather than discarding it as a parse error) within a style rule. If a processor does not implement, with a usable level of support, both the property and the value given, then it must not accept the declaration or claim support for it.
Note: Note that properties or values whose support is effectively disabled by user preferences are still considered as supported by this definition. For example, if a user has enabled a high-contrast mode that causes colors to be overridden, the CSS processor is still considered to support the color property even though declarations of the color property may have no effect. On the other hand, a developer-facing preference whose purpose is to enable or disable support for an experimental CSS feature does affect this definition of support.
These rules (and the equivalence between them) allow authors to use fallback (either in the [CSS1] sense of declarations that are overridden by later declarations or with the new capabilities provided by the @supports rule in this specification) that works correctly for the features implemented. This applies especially to compound values; implementations must implement all parts of the value in order to consider the declaration supported, either inside a style rule or in the declaration condition of an @supports rule.
Tests
Supports queries are true iff property declaration (including all values) is parsed/supported.
- css-supports-005.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-020.xht (live test) (source)
- css-supports-024.xht (live test) (source)
- CSS-supports-CSSStyleDeclaration.html (live test) (source)
- at-supports-044.html (live test) (source)
7. APIs
7.1. Extensions to the CSSRule
interface
The CSSRule
interface is extended as follows:
partial interface CSSRule {const unsigned short = 12; };
SUPPORTS_RULE
7.2. The CSSConditionRule
interface
The CSSConditionRule
interface represents
all the “conditional” at-rules,
which consist of a condition and a statement block.
[Exposed =Window ]interface :
CSSConditionRule CSSGroupingRule {readonly attribute CSSOMString ; };
conditionText
Tests
CSSConditionRule inherits from CSSGroupingRule.
CSSConditionRule has .conditionText attribute.
conditionText
of typeCSSOMString
-
The
conditionText
attribute represents the condition of the rule. Since what this condition does varies between the derived interfaces ofCSSConditionRule
, those derived interfaces may specify different behavior for this attribute (see, for example,CSSMediaRule
below). In the absence of such rule-specific behavior, the following rules apply:The
conditionText
attribute, on getting, must return the result of serializing the associated condition.Tests
.conditionText returns serialization of condition.
7.3. The CSSMediaRule
interface
The CSSMediaRule
interface represents a @media at-rule:
[Exposed =Window ]interface :
CSSMediaRule CSSConditionRule { [SameObject ,PutForwards =mediaText ]readonly attribute MediaList ;
media readonly attribute boolean ; };
matches
media
of typeMediaList
, readonly-
The
media
attribute must return aMediaList
object for the list of media queries specified with the @media at-rule.Tests
.media returns a MediaList matching the @media condition.
matches
of typeboolean
, readonly-
The
matches
attribute returns true if the rule is in an stylesheet attached to a document whoseWindow
matches this rule’smedia
media query, and returns false otherwise.Tests
.matches matches the media query, returns boolean.
conditionText
of typeCSSOMString
(CSSMediaRule-specific definition for attribute on CSSConditionRule)-
The
conditionText
attribute (defined on theCSSConditionRule
parent rule), on getting, must return the value ofmedia.mediaText
on the rule.Tests
Value of CSSMediaRule.conditionText matches value of media.mediaText.
7.4. The CSSSupportsRule
interface
The CSSSupportsRule
interface represents a @supports rule.
[Exposed =Window ]interface :
CSSSupportsRule CSSConditionRule {readonly attribute boolean ; };
matches
matches
of typeboolean
, readonly-
The
matches
attribute returns the evaluation of the CSS feature query represented inconditionText
.Tests
CSSSupportsRule.matches returns true if matches feature query
conditionText
of typeCSSOMString
(CSSSupportsRule-specific definition for attribute on CSSConditionRule)-
The
conditionText
attribute (defined on theCSSConditionRule
parent rule), on getting, must return the condition that was specified, without any logical simplifications, so that the returned condition will evaluate to the same result as the specified condition in any conformant implementation of this specification (including implementations that implement future extensions allowed by the <general-enclosed> extensibility mechanism in this specification). In other words, token stream simplifications are allowed (such as reducing whitespace to a single space or omitting it in cases where it is known to be optional), but logical simplifications (such as removal of unneeded parentheses, or simplification based on evaluating results) are not allowed.Tests
CSSSupportsRule.conditionText can have tokenization simplifications.
CSSSupportsRule.conditionText cannot have other simplifications.
7.5. The CSS
namespace, and the supports ()
function
The CSS
namespace holds useful CSS-related functions that do not belong elsewhere.
partial namespace CSS {boolean (
supports CSSOMString ,
property CSSOMString );
value boolean (
supports CSSOMString ); };
conditionText
, returnssupports ( CSSOMString property, CSSOMString value) boolean
-
When the
supports(property, value)
method is invoked with two arguments property and value:-
If property is an ASCII case-insensitive match for any defined CSS property that the UA supports, or is a custom property name string, and value successfully parses according to that property’s grammar, return
true
. -
Otherwise, return
false
.
Note: No CSS escape or whitespace processing is performed on the property name, so
CSS.
will returnsupports ( " width" , "5px" ) false
, as " width" isn’t the name of any property due to the leading space.Note: !important flags are not part of property grammars, and will cause value to parse as invalid, just as they would in the value argument to element.style.setProperty().
Tests
CSS.supports(arg1, arg2) evaluates support of property arg1 with value arg2.
-
, returnssupports ( CSSOMString conditionText) boolean
-
When the
supports(conditionText)
method is invoked with a single conditionText argument:-
If conditionText, parsed and evaluated as a <supports-condition>, would return true, return
true
. -
Otherwise, If conditionText, wrapped in parentheses and then parsed and evaluated as a <supports-condition>, would return true, return
true
. -
Otherwise, return
false
.
All namespaces in the conditionText argument are considered invalid, just as they are in
document.
.querySelector ( "a|b" ) Tests
CSS.supports(arg1) evaluates supports condition arg1.
CSS.supports(arg1) implies parentheses.
-
Security Considerations
This spec introduces no new security considerations.
Privacy Considerations
Various features in this specification, associated mainly with the @media rule but also to some degree with the @supports rule, provide information to Web content about the user’s hardware and software and their configuration and state. Most of the information is provided through the features in [MEDIAQUERIES-4] rather than through the features in this specification. However, the @supports rule may provide some additional details about the user’s software and whether it is running with non-default settings that may enable or disable certain features.
Most of this information can also be determined through other APIs. However, the features in this specification are one of the ways this information is exposed on the Web.
This information can also, in aggregate, be used to improve the accuracy of fingerprinting of the user.
8. Changes
The following (non-editorial) changes were made to this specification since the 13 January 2022 Candidate Recommendation Snapshot:
- Clarified that supports() must return false for invalid custom property values
- Fixed Web IDL, "bool" should have been "boolean"
- Clarified that a processor must support both the property and the value (Issue 8795)
- Added .matches to @media and @supports (Issue 4240)
- Updated to the new parsing algo names and block production names.
- Removed procedure to set readonly CSSMediaRule.conditionText (PR 8796)
- Made conditionText readonly.
The following (non-editorial) changes were made to this specification since the 8 December 2020 Candidate Recommendation Snapshot:
- Clarified that discarding property declarations only applies to style rules, not at-rules
- Clarified that !important is not part of the property grammar
- Split Security and Privacy into separate sections
- Defined the terms CSS feature queries and supports queries to refer to the conditional syntax of the @supports rules, to allow better cross-referencing.
- Removed the “unknown” value in CSS feature queries’ boolean logic, defining unrecognized syntaxes as “false” instead. (Issue 6175)
-
Clarified placement of conditional group rules.
(Issue 5697)
Conditional group rules are allowed wherever style rules are allowed ( at the top-level of a style sheet,
and insideas well as within other conditional group rules ) . CSS processors must process such rules as described above.Any at- rules that are not allowed after a style rule (e.g., @charset , @import , or @namespace rules) are also not allowed after a conditional group rule
. Therefore, style sheets must not place such rules after a conditional group rule, and CSS processors must ignore such rules., and are therefore invalid when so placed.
The following (non-editorial) changes were made to this specification since the 4 April 2013 Candidate Recommendation:
- Clarified that namespaces in conditionText are invalid
- New editors added
- Added explicit call to parse rather than "matches the grammar"
- Removed duplicate CSSGroupingRule, which is already defined by CSSOM
- Rewrote the supports() text into algorithm form, to make it easier to express that you pay attention to the syntax of registered custom properties in the supports(prop, val) form.
- Moved the definition of @supports selector to css-conditional-4.
- @supports' is no longer at risk.
- Rewrote to use CSS Syntax grammars, not CSS 2.1 grammars
- Changed from CSS Interface to WebIDL-compatible CSS namespace
- Dropped requirement for spaces around and, or, and not keywords for consistency with Media Queries (which are themselves constrained by compatibility with the output of some CSS minimizers that rely on some of the more arcane aspects of CSS tokenization). Note that white space--or a comment--is still required after these keywords, since without it they and the ensuing opening parenthesis will be tokenized as a function opening token.
- Allowed the
method to imply parentheses for simple declarations, for consistency with the @import rule’s supports() function.supports () - Fixed missing semicolons in IDL code.
- Updated links, terminology, and example code in response to changes to other modules.
- Spelling and grammatical corrections
- Added section on privacy and security considerations.
Acknowledgments
Thanks to the ideas and feedback from Tab Atkins, Arthur Barstow, Ben Callahan, Tantek Çelik, Alex Danilo, Elika Etemad, Pascal Germroth, Björn Höhrmann, Paul Irish, Brad Kemper, Anne van Kesteren, Vitor Menezes, Alex Mogilevsky, Chris Moschini, James Nurthen, Simon Pieters, Florian Rivoal, Simon Sapin, Nicholas Shanks, Ben Ward, Zack Weinberg, Estelle Weyl, Boris Zbarsky, and all the rest of the www-style community.